Customer Reviews

Kathleen Battle · Wynton Marsalis ~ Baroque Duet / Anthony Newman · Orch St. Luke's · Nelson

5 star:		(26)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I had been a huge fan of both Kathleen Battle and Wynton Marsalis for many years, when I had the good fortune to see a PBS tv documentary on the making of this album. I was playing this album literally 3-4 times daily, so it was a delight to see the artistry and passion they brought to the recording. Not only do you see the artists working with great joy and humor in the studio, you also get to see Kathleen Battle give a recital concert in her hometown church in Ohio, singing the roof off! Talk about a homecoming....

The album opens with a technically stunning rendition of Handel's LET THE BRIGHT SERAPHIM, which displays Battle's great coloratura. Wynton Marsalis is a gorgeous match for her silvery top notes and crystal-clear diction. She is unmatched in her ability to bring out every glorious syllable. The most beatiful piece on the entire album, and it's not easy to choose just one, has to be ETERNAL SOURCE OF LIGHT. You will literally think you're surrounded by celestial light, her singing is that gorgeous. Again, Marsalis' trumpet is perfectly matched to her voice.

They really outdo themselves in the Scarlatti material; especially in the 7 arie con tromba sola (my favorites being SI SUONI LA TROMBA and MIO TESORO PER TE MORO) and SU LE SPONDE DEL TEBRO, which features gorgeous harpsichord....Stupenda.

It would be truly amazing if Battle and Marsalis would collaborate again. This is one of the most beautiful duet albums in any genre you'll ever hear. Bravo!!!!

It is difficult to express in words the experience of hearing Kathleen Battle and Wynton Marsalis perform this brilliant and difficult pieces on this recording. Every single number on this recital of Baroque pieces for voice and trumpet is a wonder of energy and technical precision. Kathleen Battle's silvery voice is particularly fond of the Baroque repertoire. The extremely difficult arias and cantatas of this CD suit Battle's voice perfectly. The soprano shines with nimble coloratura, soaring high notes (up to brilliant C's and D's)and precise control of dynamics. Marsalis is a perfect partner for Battle, a true virtuoso capable of establishing an effective rapport with the vocal line. The ornamentation used by both artists is both tasteful and brilliant, always mindful that this music calls for both display and ensemble work. John Nelson, an accomplished Baroque conductor, conducts with his usual mastery the Orchestra of St. Luke's, an ensemble who brings excellent support to the work of the soloists. Among the highlights of the recording are Let the Bright Seraphim, with the brilliant trills of both Battle and Marsalis, the fours arias from Scarlatti's Arie con Tromba Sola, and above all, the two movements from Bach's Cantata No. 51 that close the program. These are perhaps the best interpretations of this cantata movements I have ever heard. An unique recording that proves what the term "virtuoso" really means. Highly recommended.

Jazz buffs are very familiar with Wynton Marsalis and his trumpet. Opera lovers know the quality voice of lyrical soprano Kathleen Battle. A perfect blending of these two performers, in the Baroque music, has been acheived in this CD. The match of human voice and trumpet seems to us, at the end of the Twenth Century, a mismatch. But to quote Ellen T. Harris, who wrote the liner notes, "The real and sympolic power of the trumpet makes its combination with the quieter instruments and voice seems, at first, imbrobable, but a softer sweeter style of playing in the high ("clarino") register was typical in art music for the trumpet...". Sounds simple enough, but Wynton is one of the few players who can do it well. So well in fact, that at several points Kathleen's voice and Wynton's trumpet blend into one voice, a balanced singularity, even duplicating each others vibrato exactly. A truely amazing accomplishment, which can only be fully appreciated by listening; but once you hear this glorious sound, you'll want to upgrade your stero system to capture its fullness.

Everyone I have had listen to this CD, and I've given away several as gifts, has come from the experience, with a changed paradigm, toward that "old" Baroque music. This recording presents the eras music in its true light - rich, with debth and color; and in my opinion, is more powerful than the passionate Romantics.

I asked myself, "how can such a feeling of freedom be realized in an archaic, regimented, nay strait-jacket format?" The answer is in the musicans and how they make the music live.

A word about those liner notes, which we seem to never appreciate anough, in this case they are very good. Ellen gives us very good background information on the composers, the principal musicians, the text (with English translations where appropriate), the track listings and playing times, and the list is printed on the CD. The only information missing is that concerning the conductor and the orchestra.

Though to period purists this CD is marginal,it is only because period instruments are not used. The engineering, editing, and acoustics are all excellant.

In addition, some of the composers are revealed in all their humanity. As in the case of Alessandro Stradella..."was involved in an embezzlement scheme against the Catholic Church and in 1677 avoided assination as a result of an affair, was murdered in 1682 as a result of another affair." Makes you curious what kind of music a Casanova would write.

Track Notes: 1. George F. Handel-Let the Bright Seraphim Text in English. Kathleen on tone through out.(Most vocalists tend to flatten those really high notes, but not Kathleen-not once!) Good distinct sound between all the instruments. Kathleen has crisp pronunciation and diction.

2. Alessandro Scarlatti-4 Arias from 7 Arias with solo trumpet. Tracks 2-5. Text in Italian. (Aria#1)Let the Trumpet Sound. Wynton is excellent at playing his own trumpet echo, at reduced volume, yet he is just as precise in his sound. Good blending of voice, strings, and trumpet. Kathleen has vibrato on her high notes that are just the right speed, which is what you'd expect from her.

3. With Festive Voice (Aria #3). In Italian. Playing this presto tempo piece was smooth and steady through out. Kathleen's Italian is melted in the music, as any good Italian singer would do, yet her pronunciation is crisp. You can feel the fun the performers are having with this music; even though the fast tempo has the potential of bogging down during the tough bits, the players stays sharp. "The flowing 12/8 meter affords continual opportunity for voice and trumpet to alternate and overlap in waves of sound."

4. She Breaks, She Scorns (Aria #4). In Italian. This one begins in a Major key at an allegro tempo with Kathleen rolling her 'r's and trilling her high notes followed by Wynton in an echo pattern. This piece is so short and is my only disappointment, with reguards to the composer's length not this presentation. One would think that maybe all these pieces would sound the same but that isn't the case.

5. My Love I Die for Thee (Aria #6). In Italian. This aria uses an adagio tempo in major key with the harpsichord continuo very clearly heard as, contrasted with the old 'LP' days when continuo was never heard. Wynton exhibits his breath controll by trilling on the high notes just when you think he'd run out of air and I found myself taking in air for him.

6. Alessandro Scarlatti- On the Tiber's Banks (no relation to the earlier mentioned Alessandro Stradella's Vatican embezzlement scheme). Tracks 6-13. In Italian. Sinfonia, without voices, is the introduction to this work. The chorus for this work is not presented. Only the soprano.

7. Recitative - is sung by Kathleen and accompanied by the continuo instruments (ie., cello and harpsichord).

8. Sinfonia - in this part, Kathleen almost runs out of air in a couple of spots but has that extra punch to just make it. At the end, she leads the trumpet in alternating the solo line and intertwining the sound into a duet unison, most lovely.

9. Recitative - the second, as the first (track 7)the voice is accompanied by the continuo and at the largo tempo allows us the opportunity to listen to longer singing lines for all instruments, which flows directly into the next movement.

10. Largo - maintaining the former tempo but shifting to a minor key, which begins simply with violin, then viola, and then cello each brought in to play measure by measure (no trumpet) and transitons into major key at the end. "The trumpet plays the melody before and after the singer, transforming her song into a plantive wordless cry." One of the best sensual movements Scarlatti wrote.

11. Aria - back into the minor key at a bit faster tempo with her voice and strings repeating each other into the ... Ritornello - at adagio tempo, orchestra only; very brief, then directly into...

12. Recitative - again voice and continuo in minor key, which breaks into major key and allegro tempo lead by the trumpet, most effective on the composers part because it leads into Kathleen's next...

13. Aria - which symbolizes the triumph of good over evil and concludes with a repeat of the original sinfonia (track6).

14. G.F. Handel - Eternal Source. In English. From the Ode to Queen Anne on Her Birthday. Largo tempo in major key. If you are only familar with Handel's Messiah, get ready to have the most lush, full music ever written to delight your sences. This is the track for the long, souring singing lines for all the instruments, but especially for Kathleen, whose lines are followed by the trumpet. Handel is the only major composer, who's English texts I like put to music. Every other composer I've heard fall so far short when compared to him.

15. Luca Antonio Predieri - Peace Just Once. From Zenobia (1740). In Italian. Adagio tempo in major key transposing to minor key and back to major. Trumpet and orchestra lead out, followed by the voice, which again comes so close to not having enough breath but I think this is the fault of the composer. (After all Stradella wasn't the only ladies man and what a cleaver way to be the hero by helping the lady in distress, who was trying to sing his music and hyperventilating, and needed a rest in his chambers.) Kathleen has amazing voice control on the coloratura and with very high finishes with lots of trills on the trumpet's peak parts. Voice and trumpet blending in unision and you cannot discern either one distinctly. Well done.

16. Alessandro Stradella - Sinfonia to the Serenade Il barcheggio (1681). Tracks 16-19. Trumpet and orchestra, no vocal part. Adagio tempo in major key.

17. Allegro tempo in minor key.

18. Allegro tempo in major key.

19. Gavotte tempo in major key. Trumpet leads the orchestra with the main musical theme in unison and/or harmony. Great inner support between soloist and group.

20. J.S. Bach - Sighs, Tears, Grief, Misery from Cantata No. 21 Endured Much Misery. In German. With all that you can guess that this is a sad number and it's taken at Largo tempo and of course minor key. The trumpet and organ start with the voice following one third lower. What a great language to express this music. Wynton did an amaziong cover of an error by turning it into a two note trill - what a great save. I wish I could save my off notes that well.

21. G.F. Handel - To the Bronze Warrior's Voices from Cantata No.19 Oh! How Bright and Beautiful. This is my favorite track because you can hear Kathleen working her voice placement around to different parts of her mouth for a marvelous effect. Her voice is the musical statement echoed by the trumpet and the two weave around each other ending up in unison at the top notes, spintingling is possible, all with solid orchestra support. Handel did most of his stuff in English, though he originally went to England to write Italian opera. This piece shows he did indeed know how to do just that.

22. J.S. Bach - Rejoyce in the Lord All Ye Lands from the Cantata No.51 Tracks 22-23. In German. Aria - My favorite Bach cantata is this

OK!! I have just listened to this album and I am breathless!!!! I have never heard anything like this before. Amazing!!!!! I was shouting like a madman during the second song 'si suoni la tromba'!!! There is such chemistry between, Kathleen Battle, Wynton Marsalis and Anthony Newman. It is out of this world!!!!

Kathleen Battle has outdone herself here!!! There is nothing that she can possibly do that can beat this feat. And a feat it is!!!! Simply stunning!!! And I MEAN stunning. You will not be able to move. Every number is just perfect. One glorious piece after another.It makes you want to dance and sing and....

WOW!!!!!

A lot has been said about the way both Kathleen Battle and Wynton Marsalis sometimes embelish their baroque performances, but this recording is an exeption: all feeling and no flashiness - both performers display a dazzling enthusiasm coupled with immense talent. The opening track, Handel's Let the Bright Seraphim, is a brilliantly refreshing version of a very famous and often recorded piece that sets the tone for the whole CD. Other highlights include Handel's Eternal Source of Light Divine and Bach's Seufzer Tranen Kummer Not. Kathleen's voice is delicate and expressive and perfectly suited for this type of music, her technique may not be perfect, but her ability to convey feeling makes up for this minor drawback. Wynton in the ultimate trumpet virtuoso, both innovative and technically flawless, and you feel he could turn any piece of music into something worth listening. The repertoire is fabulous and you can hardly imagine two more complete performers for these masterpieces.

This album by Kathleen Battle shows her in top form, as a true diva and fantastic interpreter of Baroque music. She is incomparable in these incredible difficult but very beautiful arias. Her version of Let the Bright Seraphim is simple the best ever recorded, she sails through these challenging lines with such ease. And of course Wynton Marsalis is there as a great partner. In many arias Kathleen's voice has to compete with his trumpet, like in Seraphim or Si Suoni La Tromba, and they sound so triumphant together. And there are many more arias when her singing is simply radiant, and divine.
This recording is very famous and acclaimed, it won a Grammy, and you should find out why so many people love this album!

During the 90'S Kathleen Battle did CD after CD with a famous instrumentalist. Some of these CD's were ill fated, like her Bach Album. Thankfully, this outstanding baroque performance rose above those others. She and Marsalis clearly have a chemistry. Battle has incredibly coloratura flexibility and for once shows fabulous breath control throughout the pieces. The material doesnt overwhelm her as sometimes happened. She has all the opportunity to show off her shining high notes and pure tone. More importantly the pieces dont all sound the same, the diverse composers and selections vary between dazzling and slow and tender. Definitly my favorite battle album

If I were forced to take only one CD with me to the proverbial desert isle, this would be the one. Battle is brilliant as always, and Marsalis complements her perfectly. Together they shine, with perfect control and warmth. The first and last tracks are showstoppers. I had the chance to listen to Battle in concert when she was in Toronto last year, and this CD actually manages to capture some of the essence of her live performances. I cannot recommend this work highly enough. This would make a perfect gift for anyone who likes classical music.

Well, where shall I start? First of all, I must say "wow" for the person from Washington. That must have really worn out the hands. If you haven't seen it yet, go take a look. It summarizes the entire, yes entire CD, track for track.

First, I will start by saying that the trumpet usually is paired with a castrato due to their striking similarity of tone. Here, a light-lyric soprano has stepped up and sung. There couldn't be a better match in my mind. Wynton Marsalis is fantastic and strides up and down the scales like lightning yet exuding much preciseness. Kathleen Battle does the same, and shows off her ability to do coloratura with her own flare.

I especially recommend the first track from Handel's Samson, "Let the Bright Seraphim," due to its tonal pyrotechnics. Absolutely a job well-done. The rest of the CD is great as well with some more pieces by Handel and also by Bach. These also come highly recommended, as Battle's german is quite superb and they are quite showy too. There are other composers, namely Scarlatti, Predieri, and Stradella, and the work here is very good as well, yet this time some tracks are without one of the soloists. This doesn't pose any problem however as the music is very nice, and each shows their individual talents off even further.

And now for sound quality. The orchestra is well-handled and conducted by Mr. Nelson, creating a pleasing accompaniment to the two soloists. The sound quality is excellent and the encoding is top notch.

To sum it up, this CD is exilerating and makes you want to hear it over and over again. This is an absolute must for Battle fans, and a good one to have for Marsalis fans since it shows off his classical side. A final note to make, this is my second CD of Battle's, and I can say that if you liked this, you'll love her in her CD titled "Kathleen Battle in Concert" where she's accompanied by the renowned conductor and artistic director of the Met in NY, James Levine. Special to note are the four spirituals she sings at the end of it....just divine.

Enjoy.

Yup. That's it. This is how baroque music was thought to sound. I do not know what Handel had in mind when he wrote "Let the bright Seraphim", but I am sure he wanted to condense his image of this angel by his music. And from there, the Seraph's wingtips shine even after several centuries.

Wynton Marsalis and Kathleen Battle make a fabulous Baroque Duet. Both artists demonstrate in this recording their outstanding ability to perform pieces very accurately and to have the audience carried away by the fascinating brilliance of rhythm.

The collection comprises pieces for voice and orchestra, trumpet and orchestra, and the full ensemble. The technical difficulties are overcome with an easiness that is hard to describe, both by Marsalis as by Battle. And not to forget the really excellent performance of the Orchestra of St. Luke conducted by John Nelson - names I've never heared before. The recording of the Sony engineers is at a high level and brings this heavenly sound directly to you. Enjoy this disk, it's art at its best: superb technique that twinkles with joy!