This review entails my experience with three packs. The Kelty FC3, the current FC 3.0 and the Deuter II. I originally owned the older Kelty FC3. Over the course of a year of heavy use, it began wearing out (material was tearing, and ripping, foam was coming off the internal stays). To be honest I probably put over 200 miles on this pack in all kinds of weather. Kelty agreed to replace the pack with the FC 3.0, the current model. But only after sending them pics of my old pack with the shoulder straps cut from the pack. A big mistake on my part...
The Kelty FC3 was probably the premier backpack out there when it came out. It probably still is. It fit well, the kids loved it. Getting them in and out was a little cumbersome but not too bad. Lots of little extras. The pocket on the back came off to be a separate backpack, the small mirror to see what junior was up to, the reflective piping all over the pack, the diaper pad, cupholders on the back, the all weather type hood, and the kickstand. Lots of niceties. Safety wise it was the best, with the rollbar type cockpit, that probably actually saved my son once when I took a bad fall. Any other pack and he may have been crushed.
The FC 3.0 keeps the rollbar type construction and the kickstand, but the similarities pretty well stop there.
a. The new harness assembly upper belts are not attached to the back of the pack passenger compartment but rather float on two straps in the back of the compartment. (the older model had some serious velcro here)
b. The back/sides of the passenger compartment padding are no longer attached with velcro due to the mesh sides panels. This can make them collapse while trying to insert the child.
c. The base of the open area where the childs legs hang now has mesh at the bottom, which if the childs legs are inside the mesh when he is inserted can make it next to impossible to raise his legs to get them out. Before he could just move them out if he desired. Now, you have to once again lift the child out and try to guide both legs to the outside of the mesh as you lower him( more of an issue as you child get larger).
d. The sunshield. Previously this was more of an all weather hood. Given that I am outside in all kinds of weather this was a real sell point for me. In addition to the material itself, my concerns are as follows: (this might be repetitive). The shield seems to sit about two inches lower, even with me lowering my son to a lower seat height, the shield sits on his head. If I put him any lower the sides of the pack would probably not allow him to lower his arms. The top cross piece is now manually inserted vs being sewn in. The bottom elastic of the side netting runs across my sons face. He looks like an dog in one of those airline under the seat pet carriers stuffed in there.
e. Passenger material. Initially I thought the softer material was an improvement. Now I'm not so sure. My son spends a lot of time back there eating, drinking, drooling, whatever. This stuff is lighter in color and will show stains more than the older black nylon material, and looks like it could be a real pain to clean. Only the front pad is removable for cleaning, but the entire compartment has this stuff on it.
f Lack of small details. THe old pack had the reflective piping which I was happy about as a lot of my walks end up finishing as the sun goes down, and I'm walking home. The web cup holders on the outside of the pack were very useful. The mirror was great for knowing if my son was sleeping, done drinking from his water bottle or had made a mess of the last piece of food I gave him.
Anyway,I no longer have the FC 3.0. I picked up a Deuter II to replace it. Initially I liked the Deuter. I really like the sunshield, rainhood combo which is about thirty bucks extra but well worth it. The main issues with this pack are:
a. I don't know why but the shoulder tightening straps on mine seem too short. When I take my son off I have to release the straps all the way, and even then its a challenge to get my arms out of those straps. Then when putting the pack on with the straps full released, its hard to grab them to pull tight, as I only have about an inch to do so. It's very awkward/uncomfortable.
b. The kick stand is awkward too. You need someone to push it back in or to pull it out unless your very flexible. I keep forgetting it's out there and go into places knocking over everything, when I realize it's the kickstand.
c. The frame. I love the fact that it has the side entry. However I really miss the safety of the Kelty rollbar.
d. For some reason my son hates this thing. Perhaps he spent too much time in the Kelty.
Anyway, the Deuter is gone. I managed to find a new Kelty FC2, which is the same as the FC3 on a closeout site for $99.99. It's the same as the FC3 only without the mirror, diaper pad, or all weather hood, all of which I still have anyway. My next choice was going to be Ebay for a good used FC3.
Be careful in reading the reviews for the FC 3.0. A lot of those reviews are really for the older FC3. Many 09 reviews and all the earlier reviews are for the FC3. The two packs are radically different, although similiar in appearance. I sent Kelty a lot of photos and info and they said they are looking at redesigning it again in the future. I still think they're a great company. Looks like they just tried to really cut costs on this new pack. If safety is a big concern, I still think Kelty is the way to go.