Most Helpful First | Newest First
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars HAM RADIO A.M. OLDIES---BAD SEED STYLE,
Lord knows what prompted them to cut this, but in the 1986 Post Punk/Alternative/Underground scene, a covers record was unheard of. Furthermore, to feature songs made famous by the likes of Johnny Cash, Gene Pitney &Tom Jones was perversely unfashionable to say the least.
Looked at this way, Kicking Against the Pricks is a big middle finger to fans & especially critics alike. But it was also a genuine ode to the music Cave & The Bad Seeds sincerely loved, which is precisely how they pull this stunt off.
In terms of ballads like "By The Time I Get To Phoenix" & the pure Pop embrace of "Something's Got A Hold Of My Heart", a startling side to Cave is revealed for the 1st time: Nick The Crooner. He genuinely gives his all to "Sleeping Annaleah", while the Bad Seeds provide suitably demented backing.
More than any other recording artist, Johnny Cash has the honor of being paid tribute to the most. This album boasts not 1 but 3 songs cut by the Man In Black. But you have to remember that Cash's resurgence of popularity was more a few years away. At the time, he was far from hip.
The brooding opener, "Muddy Water" is from Cash's 1979 Silver album, an obscure choice that fortunately did not escape Cave's notice. The same goes for Cave's menacing interpretation of the Cash rarity, "The Folksinger". As for "Long Black Veil", while the version here can't hope to compete with The Man In Black's, in terms of mood & atmosphere, it's certainly commendable. If some journalist wanted to coin a genre for these 3 I'd suggest, "Gothic Country".
The Bad Seeds' previous, First Born Is Dead was steeped in John Lee Hooker's influence & Cave launches into "I'm Gonna Kill That Woman" with merciless abandon. Amid the plethora of Hooker covers out there, I'll go so far as to say this is up there along with Them's "Baby Please Don't Go" as being definitive.
Another standout is The Hammer Song which I feel surpasses Alex Harvey's original.
As for the full on Gospel of "Woman At The Well", this was something that just was not done at the time. Then the curtains draw to a close with a gorgeous, haunting rendition of The Seekers' classic, "The Carnival Is Over".
As with all the re-issues in this series the sound is amazing. You can hear every pin drop. In terms of the bonus tracks, Cave's ferocious near a cappella take on Leadbelly's "Black Betty" is essential.
To say this is the Bad Seeds at their least ground breaking would be missing the point. All that's absent is any hint of cynicism or mockery. In many ways this is Cave's most innocent & nostalgic offering since he 1st "released the bats". He would later cut many a fine love song, but at this point in his career anything resembling a traditional ballad was a rare commodity.
Despite all the musical inanities that prevailed in the 80's, what's so remarkable is how this & all of Cave's records hold up so well some 23 years later. They simply don't sound dated. And Kicking is if anything, as much out of step as it is out of time. This is Ham Radio Oldies AM 101...Bad Seed Style.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Great Sound, Few Extras,
One thing I always ask myself before buying a beefed-up version of an album I already own is whether or not there is enough value in the new package to warrant opening the wallet. In the case of Kicking Against the Pricks, the product description made it seem like there was and some of the amazon partner offers were attractive so I took the plunge.
As it turns out, there is little extra offered. The songs are the same as on the one I already own but on the remastered version, two of them are subtracted from the CD and offered on the DVD as "bonus tracks". The main benefit to getting this one is the variety of formats in which it can be listened which is useful only if you have a decent stereo system. I do and the sound is a vast improvement over the original. Other extras are one video and the ongoing project of having band members and fans natter on about Nick and his band at the point in his career the featured recording was made. That is interesting exactly once.
As for the body of work, Kicking Against the Pricks is an album which set Cave apart from his contemporaries and gave the musical world notice that his talent is far deeper than most suspected. This is an eclectic album of covers, and Nick covers his picks with panache. He covers the work of a wide array of artists, some of whom were the antithesis of cool. That surely surprised his fans and perhaps caused some of them to view those made newly cool in a new way. Johnny Cash, Gene Pitney, and Jimmy Webb all gained new admirers as a result of Cave's record. Here's what I like best: Muddy Water, Sleeping Annaleah, By The Time I Get to Phoenix, Something's Gotten Hold of My Heart, The Carnival is Over, and what is now a bonus cut, Running Scared.
This CD/DVD package is presented in a handsome tri-fold and comes with a booklet containing pictures, notes on the remaster, pertinent album information, but unfortunately no lyrics as none of the songs are Cave's. I recommend this highly only to those who are able to take full advantage of all the listening options the remaster offers. You won't be disappointed.
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars kicking against the pricks rocks,
I expected little from this album since it was a cover album and bought it to add to a collection of Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds. Was I ever surprised! It was, in a word, stunning, especially Muddy Water and Sleeping Annaleah. And it is just my opinion of course, but I think that it should be against the law for anyone but Nick to sing By the Time I Get to Phoenix. Glenn who?? There is not a mislick on this album.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Nick Cave; need I say more?,
This, I feel, is actually one of his strongest works. Although it is all covers, Cave truly possesses them as they possess him. The Glenn Campbell cover is surprisingly well done. Lots of Birthday Party personnel were involved on various songs. Absolutely a Must Have for any Cave fan/zealot. It's f---ing incredible.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A Brilliant Album Of Covers,
I am passionate about great covers and this album delivers twelve, plus two extras on the bonus DVD. Tracks that stand out are the ones already familiar to me: Muddy Water, Long Black Veil, Hey Joe, The Singer and All Tomorrow's Parties. The album is rounded out with songs I would not likely ever have heard. Nick's interpretations are excellent. This brilliant album of covers is a favourite Cave album that should not be overlooked.
5.0 out of 5 stars play loud aand often,
This review is from: Kicking Against The Pricks (Audio CD)
when I read other reviews of this I thought they were misguided but no. it's all true. this is a wonderful collection of tunes and I love the title of the cd. right from scripture. yeah fun stuff
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars l.a.m.f,
Nick Cave's album of covers is named kicking against the pricks.
that title is lifted from the holy bible.
i do not remember which verse,but this album is full of Nick Cave's favorite songs
i would guess.
because the selection is great.
and his voice is deep,confident and strong.
he sort of glides from song to song and like i said,they're all classics.
johnny cash,leadbelly,velvet underground are among the heroes Cave honors.
NIck Cave was and is great.
but my favorite period will always be the 80s.
Most Helpful First | Newest First