4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
exhilarating tense thriller, October 30, 2007
The city is frantic, especially the women as the Butcher dismembers females limb by limb and stacks each of them into eerie pyramids in their bathtubs. He is extremely precise with his human Lego's, but never leaves behind a forensic trace of any sort.
NYPD Deputy Chief Harley Renz knows he needs his best serial killer specialist to lead the inquiry; however the department's top gun is retired. Still Harley asks former NYPD homicide detective Frank Quinn to return to the field to stop The Butcher from killing anymore women. Police Officer Pearl Kasner, Frank's former girlfriend, is assigned to work with him. However, Frank is immediately stunned when he realizes the first letter of the surname of the five victims spell the proper noun Quinn.
John Lutz provides an exhilarating tense thriller using the old standby High Noon premise of a retired police detective in a cat and mouse struggle against a diabolical clever grandmaster killer. The cast is fully developed especially the hero, but it is the serial killer who methodically steals the story line. Readers will enjoy this chess game between two intelligent opponents with the falling pawns being women of the city while Frank's endangered queen might be his partner or perhaps his visiting daughter.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Suspension of Disbelief, August 31, 2008
Read the book in only a couple of sittings. Very compelling read, a real pageturner. Highly recommended and I look forward to reading the rest of Lutz's work.
A couple problems with this book though.
1) The whole back story of the serial killer is unbelievable.
2) The Pearl character is completely witless. I don't know how things work in the police world, but in my world if a detective has an affair during a case with the prime suspect and/or witness, she never works again. I saw Quinn's daughter as a target a mile before Pearl should have. Pearl never did, and only a dimwit wouldn't have thought of it.
3) It was never explained why the serial killer had a thing for Quinn. Maybe i just missed it. (I skipped a lot of the father-daughter interaction stuff.)
4) The evil mother, whom the police suspect is a little off, asks for a shotgun and they supply it without question, without discussion. A true rolling of the eyes moment.
5) Given the boys' background, who their mother and fathers were, the chances of them having these genius level IQs is about 0. Gimme a break. They grew up in a swamp, killing transients for a living.
There is quite a lot of stuff like this is the book. but it's a fun read, just don't think too deeply about it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Serial Killer Duels It Out With Veteran Police Detective And His Team, January 12, 2009
He was called The Butcher. He drowned his victims and then dismembered them. He was brilliant and had grown up dirt poor near the swamps in Florida. Subsequently he moved to New York His mother had taken in older boarders. They disappeared. Their body parts tossed into the swamp as alligator feed. His mother was his teacher. He ran away at age nine or ten. But the psychological damage had been done. Unknown to him his murdering mother conceived another child. A brother. Frank Quinn a retired detective was brought back to bring down the serial killer. Quinn reassembled his former team, both retired, consisting of his former live in girl friend Pearl Kasner and Larry "Feds" Fedderman. The story evolves as the murders continue. The mother and brother read about the killings and come to New York. Detective Quinn decides to use the mother as bait to reel in the killer. An interesting twist to the story is that the brother consumates a brief affair with Kasner and the killer begins to target Quinn's daughter Lauri who had come to New York to find herself. Other reviewers have suggested the story to be bordering on the unreal. Actually, I found it be an excellent page turner that did seem realistic albeit though there were a few parts that pushed the limit.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No