|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Umm, it 'grows on ya.', May 2, 2000
OK, props to James below for his thoughtful assessment of Ian's contributions to Kill Taker. Made me think. After a solid minute of contemplation, this is what I came up with: I still love every single song on this album. I bought it when I was in the 10th grade -- oddly enough, I found it at the Base Exchange on an air base in Germany. Go figure. Anyhow, I couldn't stand 10 of the 12 songs for a good year -- everything they had done before was so...melodic, in that fugazi kind of way. And then one day, right in the middle of that perfect execution of a feedback jam (on 23 Beats Off), I had what can only be called a musical epiphany. This album has inspired me time and time again to make my own music better, and unfortunately, it has made hundreds of other albums (hardcore, indie, whatever..) look poor by comparison. Why is it so good? What's so special? Just about everything. The contrast of quiet and loud, beautiful and abrasive -- not much else comes close to the changes within the 5,6, and 7 tracks: Rend it, 23.., and Sweet and Low. It's a tough record, certainly not open to everyone. Hardcore for the thinking man, or something like that. For me, it is THE textbook on how to make an excellent album. The balance between Guy's more melodic, emotive songs, and Ian's rough, grating sounds is just right -- I don't think they've done an album this cohesive since. Repeater and Kill Taker are tops for me!
|