I was a fan of both Absinthe Blind and Maserati for quite awhile before Headlights' first EP came out. Simply put, it blew me away - though I'd heard all the elements (shoegaze, electronic, dance) before, they were arranged with just enough of a twist to make it something special. I listened to it compulsively, and pored over every demo they released on their website during their "Enemies" tour. I was extremely excited for "Kill Them With Kindness" to come out, and actually drove an hour-and-a-half to a record store I knew would be carrying it, just so I could buy it the day it came out.
I was a little disappointed upon first listen. Sure, the songwriting is pretty good, and the production is pretty good; but the overall product is a little too polished to be truly effective. That first EP had a sense of adventurous unpredictability that really elevated it above a lot of other bands trying similar styles (see, specifically: Stars). For lack of a better phrase, "Kill Them With Kindness" shows Headlights becoming very, well, conventional. Predictable. Boring, even.
Which, as I said earlier, doesn't mean the album isn't worth a second listen. "TV" is incredibly, ridiculously catchy (if a little too perky/chirpy), and "Songy Darko" (probably the worst pun in existence) turns its' odd instrumentation and awkward repetitive bassline into a genuinely affecting song.
The high spots, though, are few and far between. Like most albums poised for some sort of mainstream acceptance and radio play, you've got a couple of singles, some nice tracks that don't bear close listening, and some obvious filler. Here's hoping that Headlights will redeem themselves on their next outing (titled "Some Racing, Some Stopping" and due out later this month).
In the meantime, if you're looking for sonically adventurous indie rock/pop in the vein of the "
Enemies" EP, I'd recommend Dirty On Purpose's "
Sleep Late for a Better Tomorrow" EP and Stars' last full-length, "
Set Yourself on Fire."