Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
delightful cozy, August 4, 2007
Liss MacCrimmon is one of the few people who are ecstatically happy with her career. She is a professional dancer in the touring how Strathsprey and she knows every Scottish dance and each number in the show to perfection. Tragedy strikes when she injures a leg and the doctor tells her she can never dance again. She is depressed because her leg will work normally only as long she puts no extraordinary stress like dancing on it.
She returns to her child home of Moosetookalook, Maine where her aunt owns a store selling Scottish products. On the day she arrives, her aunt leaves for Scotland and Liss in charge during the Maine Highland Games. When Liss returns home from the fair, she finds the dead body of her third grade teacher, Amanda Norris in the stock room. The autopsy shows she was killed and state police officer LaVerdiere thinks Liss is the only suspect. Refusing to wait around to be arrested, Liss looks for other possible suspects, not knowing her actions could get her killed.
KILT DEAD is a delightful cozy, the first in what this reviewer hopes is a long running series. The heroine is feisty, determined, and strong-willed; when she believes she is right, she obstinately goes her own way and doesn't listen to the advice of others. The setting is a small quaint town in Maine (capital of American cozies) with a support cost of wonderful quaint characters. Mystery readers will welcome Kaitlyn Dunnett as a fresh author whose protagonist provides the audience with a delightful opening act.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Reviewed by Barb Radmore, August 2, 2007
Liss MacCrimmon is devastated when a knee injury ends her dream job as a Scottish dancer. With her future up in the air, she returns to her hometown, the small Moosetookalook, Maine. Her aunt has asked her to take care of her business while she is gone, a Scottish store. But instead of the relaxing refuge she hoped to find, Liss is caught up in murder. She discovers the body of her elderly neighbor in the storage room of the shop. It is hard to imagine who would want to kill the retired third grade teacher, even if she is by far the nosiest woman in town. Liss is drawn into the investigation to clear her name by finding the real killer.
Ms Dunnett is an experienced, professional author. She weaves the tartan plaid of suspense into a bolt of solid mystery bound by a strong character thread. Her setting is detailed and realistic (as makes sense since she she just has to step outside her door to see matching surroundings.) The small world of rural Maine lends itself well to the cozy genre. This is the first of what should prove to be a long running Liss MacCrimmon Mysteries. Ms Dunnett has created Liss as a character that can develop over time; she lays the foundation for Liss to grow and progress without skimping on her character's strength in this debut. First books in a planned series can often feel like just an advertisement for the future. Ms Dunnett has not done that, she has written a solid mystery that could stand alone if desired. She paces the action with a structured rhythm that draws the reader into the story from the introduction to the truly surprise ending without pause.
The second and third books in the series will be Scone Cold Dead in August, 2008 and A Wee Christmas Homicide in October, 2009. It will be interesting to see what is planned for Liss in the future. The character is clearly enough defined in Kilt Dead that readers will care what happens to her. There is also enough romance left hanging to leave the curious reader dangling and coming back for more.
Kaitlyn Dunnett is best knows as Kathy Lynn Emerson, the author of the successful series of "Face Down in' historical mystery series, and many other works of fiction.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not the Strongest Debut, March 25, 2009
This review is from: Kilt Dead (Liss MacCrimmon Mysteries) (Paperback)
After a career ending knee injury, Scottish folk dancer Liss MacCrimmon has returned home to Moosetookalook, Maine to run her aunt's store, the Moosetookalook Scottish Emporium. It's only a temporary assignment since her aunt just needs the help while she is gone for three weeks. But Liss hopes this will give her time to figure out where to go with her life.
Her aunt has just left for her trip when Liss finds Mrs. Norris dead in the stock room. Mrs. Norris had been Liss' third grade teacher. The old woman was a bit nosey, but she certainly wasn't a danger. Or was she? When the police focus only on Liss as the suspect, she feels she must catch the real killer or do time for a crime she didn't commit. But why would someone want to kill Mrs. Norris?
Based on the title alone, I wanted to like this book. And I certainly did like the characters. Liss may be facing some uncertainty in her life, but she is still a strong woman. The potential boyfriend is another strong character as are another couple supporting characters introduced.
The problem comes in the plot. It's just too shallow and slow. I honestly would go pages where I felt like hardly anything was going on. Things definitely picked up in the final 80 pages, and I had missed several clues that pointed to the killer.
Will I give the next book in the series a try? Most likely. But it won't be as high on my reading list as I had hoped.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|