Customer Reviews

Kim Jong-Il: North Korea's Dear Leader

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

Michael Breen is well qualified to write about the Korean peninsular, having lived in Seoul for many years, and visiting North Korea several times. Although no scholar (he is a former journalist) Breen is also the author of "The Koreans - Who they are, what they want, where their future lies", an excellent commentary on South Korea.

Access to NK is well controlled, and highly fettered; much of Breen's book is based on testimony of NK defectors to the South and conversations with other visitors to the state. Breen has never interviewed the Dear Leader, (although he did meet the Great Leader and relates that he felt that the GL must have been struggling with flatulence!) journalists, especially foreign journalists, being treated with suspicion in North Korea. So in this respect, there is nothing really substantial to the book, and Breen has merely gathered and compiled a series of anecdotes and known facts about the Dear Leader, and added his interpretation of the man. However, I would stress that the lack of hard facts reflect more on the subject of the book, than the author: Breen literally does not have much to work with.

Breen discusses Kim Jong-il's early upbringing, quoting from school reports supposedly cited in official books about the Dear Leader. What rapidly comes through from the quotes that Breen uses, much (or all) of the state's writings about its leader smacks of brownnosing and trying to put a positive spin on events.

The section about Kim Jong-il's adult life is much more based on hearsay - as Breen acknowledges, there are large sections of the Dear Leader's life about which very little is known. It is known that Kim Jong-il integrated himself to his father, although always remaining in the background, even for a time after his father's death in 1994. Even then, Kim Jong-il did not take his father's title as the Great Leader, instead preferring to use the Dear Leader, playing the dutiful son to the end.

As well as relying to an extent on hearsay, Breen also uses the Communist state's own writings - it transpires that the Dear Leader is quite a prodigious author. Although the Dear Leader probably didn't intend it that way, considerable mirth can be found in his works which are quoted by Breen, which cover topics such as movie making (Kim Jong-il is such a movie buff, that as Breen relates, he organized the kidnapping of a prominent South Korean director and his actress ex-wife) and journalism. Breen does at times go overboard in ridiculing the Dear Leader - comments about the "big hair" are rife throughout the book.

"Kim Jong-il: North Korea's Dear Leader" is not just a biography, but is also a commentary about North Korea, and how the population and military accepts his, and his father's, leadership of the country despite the dire state in which the average North Korean citizen lives. Despite numerous famines, and despite (or because of) the majority of North Korea's resources being channeled towards the military, the Dear Leader continues to have a firm grip on power. However, there are encouraging signs of increasing warmth towards the South, particularly as South Korea continue to increase their investments in North Korea, although this could be seen as a cynical move, giving the need for cold hard cash in this cash strapped country.

Although not a substantial book, and light on hard facts (through no fault of the author), I would still recommend this book for those interested in North Korea and its leader, especially for those who shy away from the heavier, drier books out there.

Although Breen, I'm sure, is a fine journalist, this particular work is little more than a compliation of Kim Jong-il news wire snippets and passages from memoirs. Breen offers little in the way of biography other than material provided by DPRK itself. Granted, Kim Jong-il is enigmatic, however Breen's work would have been substantially furhtered had he persued his psycho-political research. The author's brief passages subjecting Kim Jong-il to J.D. Barber's The Presidential Character methodology was clever and thought provoking. Had he been able to move his argument further in that direction, perhaps drawing new scholarship into the picture, a clearer picture of Kim Jong-il would appear. Still, Breen's descriptions of his own travels through North Korea were enlightening. As it is indeed, "the hermit kingdom" any description of the North proves intersting. In conclusion, for a good compliaiton of Kim Jong-il info, Breen serves well, but if one is looking for a more indepth biography, it would likely be best to look elsewhere.

Breen's outline of the Dear Leader is approriate for the bizzare, often silly nature of his subject. The author moves back and forth between academic and personal observations, happily mocking the disgusting powers that be in North Korea.

I agree with the review who did not like the "Is Kim Jong-Il evil?" chapter. It seemed like filler at one point. I also felt that the end of the book lacked some of the witty writing I found in the very well done introductory part.

All in all an enjoyable read- worth the cash for a few insights into a fascinating (but disturbing character).

I have read quite a bit on North Korea, including Breen's book 'The Koreans', so I do not think I learned much new in this fairly thin book. However it was an enjoyable book, marked by Breen's humorous comments and would recommend it to anyone wanting to learn up on not just Kim Jong-il but the whole North Korean system. Breen gives a well-rounded look at Kim from childhood to the present day, all the while providing good context to understand what has shaped the little dictator. He even takes a look at the plight of those at the other end of the North Korean spectrum from Kim Jong-il.

I've been interested in North Korea ever since the nuclear crisis flared up in late 2002. Yet my search for worthwhile books to read about that sad little country has not turned up very much. The literature seems to be divided up into ideological rants about how the Bush administration provoked the new crisis (given the fact that the North Koreans began cheating before Bush was president that makes no sense) or impenetrably dense academic tomes (I noticed a reviewer of Breen's other book sneering at the fact that it is a "popular" book).

In my view, I learned a great deal about Kim Jong-Il and the state that he runs by reading Breen's book. I thought the chapters on the North Korean slave labor camps and the one titled "Country of the Lie" were particularly enlightening. I'm starting to perceive North Korea as less a country than a cult and the typical North Koreans as the equivalent of abused children who persist in believing that the "Dear Leader" loves them, even as he lets them starve.

This being said the book is not perfect:

1. It could have been longer. It was only about 190 pages. I would have liked more information about the nuclear crisis and North Korea's arms and drug dealing enterprises.

2. The chapter "Is Kim Jong-Il Evil?" wavers from being highly perceptive to being annoyingly "new age-ish."

3. The author makes a few minor errors (understating a number or two by several orders of magnitude and stating that the average North Korean's weight is 16 kilograms -34 pounds which is impossible).

Still, I feel that I am far better informed having read this book. I believe it deserves a five star rating even with its faults because it fills such a yawning gap in public understanding of this strange little man and his strange little country.

Read it and learn!

Having read several book's on North Korea this is by far the best of the selection. The book covers all of the questions the world is asking about North Korea and gives a fantastic insight into the life and mind of the man running this bizarre country.

I hate to give this book just one star as I really enjoy Michael Breen's writing and humor. His first book, "The Koreans", is the best book on the South Korean people I've ever read and I was eagerly anticipating this book, hoping it would complement the first book. Unfortunately, it is mainly a compilation of other books with a couple of personal notes from an old trip or two Breen made to North Korea prior to the famine of the 1990s. If you read "Aquariums of Pyongyang" by Kang Chol-Hwan and "The Great North Korean Famine" by Natsios, you will have basically read this book as well.

For the best information on North Korea and its people, "North Korea: Through the Looking Glass" by Kong Dan Oh is probably still the best book to read.

I have to agree with the previous review .It was an outstanding book espcially with the begining sentence "If you scan Northeast Asia from the space at night-which the United States does,for obvious reasons ....etc" is really one of the best opening lines in most of the books i have read.But the two set backs were that in the preface he mentions his wife and boast's about her "professional editing skills" when their is alot of errors in the manuscript.But over all it was a must for bookshelves all over the world!

I purchased this book with the intent of providing some back ground on Kim Jong-Il as I was reading his official North Korean biography, and foolishly thought this would be one additional perspective.

I was wrong. This book essentially culls common western thought about Kim Jong-Il, references his state biography a few times and repeats many things from the press without note. Poor writing compounds. The only thing of interests were his personal experiences, which are fairly rare from North Korea and did shed some light.

Overall, one would be better off reading Bruce Cuming's work on North Korea, either his book Behind Closed Doors or his excellent survey history Korea's Place in the Sun.

It is not worth paying money for this book. Mr Breen offers no new insights into Kim Jong Il and has simply rehashed information available on the internet. I suggest anyone interested in North Korea and Kim Jong Il either select another book or save their time and money and spend 5 minutes doing a google search.

In describing North Korea and it's leader in terms such as a "dump" Mr Breen has reduced this book from simply being boring and worthless to nothing more than tabloid type gutter press.

Kim Jong Il is a major player in wrld politics and I was interested to see that finally someone had taken the time to write a book on him. I was sadly disapointed when I sat down to read the book. It was a waste of my time and my money. I hope Mr Breen makes no further attempts to insult our intelligence by writing more books.