An ambitious, funny, lucid, and unfailingly honest novel...No other writer has yet synthesized [the coming of age in the '60's] as well as Ms. Alther has.
Review
Amazing...a very funny book...about serious matters, full of people one would like to meet, and oddly invigorating. The tone of voice throughout is a tone that has been missing in American fiction for years -- the speech of breezy survivors, of Holden Caulfield, Augie March, and ultimately Huck Finn. --
John Leonard, New York Times Book Review, Mar.14, 1976An extraordinary first novel.... Funny with the touchmark of acute, aching, poignant reality...the most marvelously described teens, adolescent mores and attitudes, sex and sensibilities since Salinger took us on Holden Caulfield's journey...Ginny is the classic outsider and her fine sense of the comic permits the novel to approach a kind of high seriousness...In the august company of The Catcher in the Rye, Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, and Huck? Yes, indeed. --
Doris Grumbach, Saturday Review, Mar. 20, 1976Composed of an adolescence of small-town suffocation, an education of Ivy League respectability, a dropout into lesbian communalism and then a copout into matrimonial conventionality, Ginny's life promises to be the progress of a 1960's pilgrim with all the resoluteness of a cork on a stormy ocean....At the very end, when Ginny at long last takes a serious stand, we not only respect her position but we also finally take seriously all the clowning that led up to it. And feel thankful to Lisa Alther for a rewarding reading experience. --
Christopher Lehmann-Haupt, New York Times,Mar.16,1976I very much like this book, am sure Alther will be recognized as a strong, salty, original talent. Is the word I am looking for balanced? She does fuse qualities, being robustly despairing, tenaciously critical, yet vigorously creative, grim but comical -- she had me laughing at four in the morning. No man could have written it, but it is very far from being 'a woman's book', and it made me wonder what Tom Jones would be like, written now. It is the size and scope of the territory Alther claims which is impressive. --
Doris LessingSo continuously funny that its wisdom takes you by surprise....We are in the presence of a most powerful and remarkable talent. --
Alice Adams, Harper's, May, 1976