In this book, we discover the man whom later generations venerated as the progenitor of Englishness. Unconsciously, but inevitably, they projected their conception of themselves onto him until the two things became fused. That is what makes Horspool's Alfred so much more pertinent than
The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle's. And that is why, if you have time to read just one book about the great man, you should make it this one.
--Daniel Hannan (
Daily Telegraph 20060506)
David Horspool's
Why Alfred Burned the Cakes does not seek to discredit the cult of Alfred as unhistorical but instead to look at why the myths surrounding him came into being.
--Ludovic Hunter-Tilney (
Financial Times 20060514)
[Horspool] explains how laws, literacy and even national pride may have been affected by Alfred's policies and explodes some of the myths surrounding his legacy, while retaining an interest in the genesis of the stories about him that have modern currency...Readers are offered some interesting treasures.
--Susannah Stevens (
The Observer 20060603)
The personal, military and religious myths around Alfred the Great are scraped off like barnacles as the West Saxon hero is pulled from the morass of pious public schoolboy attitudes and sentimental Victorian values by a cheerfully revisionist historian. Horspool goes back to original sources and reinterprets them in the context of other historical materials now available. The result is Alfred's presentation less as a stock figure of the heritage industry than as an altogether more ambiguous and interesting character.
--Iain Finlayson (
The Times 20060603)
With infinite care, [Horspool] conducts a finger-tip search of near-contemporary sources, looking for the slivers of flinty fact that are still retrievable from underneath the layers of candyfloss accretion. In the process he discovers an Alfred who, while he may not be quite the sea-going Solomon whom later apologists such as Dickens and Chesterton want us to see, is a law-maker, a pragmatist, a safe pair of hands rather than an agent for change...It is this sensitivity, both to the way that stories start and to the means by which they transform themselves into something else entirely, that makes Horspool's little book crucial reading for anyone who is interested in how history gets put together.
--Kathryn Hughes (
The Guardian 20060801)
Horspool chronicles Alfred's childhood, his war with the Vikings, his role as the soldier king, his legal accomplishments, his reputation as a scholar, and his posthumous rise and fall. The book, with 28 halftones, is a compelling narrative of England in Alfred's time and the stories and legends surrounding him. History buffs will find it fascinating.
--George Cohen (
Booklist 20061105)
We will likely never know with certainty all the details of King Alfred's reign. However, Mr. Horspool's exacting and engaging narrative brings us closer to it and to a deeper understanding of how history makes myths of leaders past and how and why we embrace their stories.
--Carol Herman (
Washington Times 20070301)
Sifting through ancient source materials, Horspool not only focuses on the actual life and times of this great king but also examines the significance behind the legends that sprang up about him. Less concerned with what the legends say than with why they came about in the first place, Horspool diligently tracks their sources, places them into historical context, and weaves them into the life of a laudable, revered, and ultimately fascinating individual. Horspool's Alfred is more man than myth but no less intriguing, and all the more admirable for his realistic features and qualities...
King Alfred: Burnt Cakes and Other Legends is one of the best texts on Alfred the Great available and a careful demonstration of how histories should be done.
--Michael G. Cornelius (
Bloomsbury Review 20080601)
As the title suggests, the author of this book, who is editor of the
Times Literary Supplement, has not written an ordinary biography, for few other historical figures are surrounded by so many myths as Alfred the Great...Horspool’s thorough familiarity with the sources, both primary and secondary, make [
King Alfred] a work of solid scholarship...undergraduates, and even higher-level academics, will also benefit from its lessons: that history is a past constructed by people, that it is often based as much on preconception as it is on evidence, and that the very evidence we use to create history was constructed by people in their own times for their own purposes.
--Gilbert M. Bogner (
The Historian )
As the title suggests, the author of this book, who is editor of the
Times Literary Supplement, has not written an ordinary biography, for few other historical figures are surrounded by so many myths as Alfred the Great, king of the West Saxons (871–899)...Because
King Alfred deals primarily with popular myths, it is appropriate that it was written for a popular audience. Yet, Horspool’s thorough familiarity with the sources, both primary and secondary, make it a work of solid scholarship.
--Gilbert M. Bogner (
The Historian )
