| ||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Doesn't Pass Muster In My House,
By
This review is from: The King Of Ireland's Son (Paperback)
Some things are great about this book: The Irish cultural references, beautiful artwork, and unique fairy tale elements like the three very old men. Some things are downright hilarious, like references to new-fangled foods, food appearing in the ears of the horse, and the places where the king's son hides (I won't give it away). But this book doesn't pass muster in my house, despite the Waldorf recommendation and the fact that we are homeschooling with a Waldorf curriculum. Here's why: It's very male-centered, and the female protagonist does nothing but sit around and wait to be rescued by a man. Then she marries the man (after being sure, of course, that he is royalty). Also, the hero's brothers needlessly try to get rid of him, without provocation, and end up banished at the end. The sibling hostility and banishment is such a minor and unexplained part of the story that it seems completely random and unnecessary. Why not just have the brothers try to help him in the beginning, and welcome him home at the end? This is the kind of detail I change when I am retelling classic fairy tales.
Maybe I would feel differently about this book if I had sons, but in my Pagan Feminist Waldorf Homeschooling house, raising daughters, this book went back to the public library quickly!
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very cute,
This review is from: The King Of Ireland's Son (Paperback)
I bought this for my son and was very glad I did. It's an adventure tale of a prince who must defeat a giant. The pictures are lush and beautiful, and it's delightfully written with great descriptions.
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"That's Nothing - I'm the King of Ireland's Son!",
By
This review is from: The King Of Ireland's Son (Paperback)
"The King of Ireland's Son" is an original fairytale by Brendan Behan, but so immersed in the traditions and familiarities of Irish folk-lore that is could well be taken for a true tale from that huge mythological canon. Behan narrates in a jaunty-like prose that reminds one immensely of the language usually connected to stories from Ireland, and incorporates many of the usual fairytale components: a tricksy giant, a damsel in distress, enigmatic guides upon the road, a helpful talking animal, a threefold trial and a triad of brothers: two malevolent ones to the virtueous youngest. The King of Ireland hears the sound of "heavenly music" in his kingdom, and promises half the land to whichever son manages to find its source. The two eldest, Neart and Ceart, take the oppurtunity to get rid of Art, the youngest, by lowering him down the hole from which the music appears to be coming from. Art however, is sincere in his wish to follow the music, and follows the tunnel connected to the dark hole, ushered on by three elderly men, each one older than the previous, each the son of the following one. Art follows their advice to a beautiful garden, where a beautiful, magical stallion carries him through an equally beautiful garden. There he finds the music's source: the daughter of the King of Greece is held captive there, under the power of a huge and evil giant. Captured by the giant, Art agrees to his challenge: for three days the giant will hide, and if Art does not find him, he'll be killed. If by any change he does succeed, then it's Art's turn to hide whilst the giant seeks. Again, should Art fail, it will end in his death. Helped by the Princess and the stallion Art takes up the challenge, leading to the most rewarding part of the book: the ingenius hiding places held by the two opponents. Here P. J. Lynch's always-stunning illustrations come into play. The bold yet delicate watercolours are a feast for the eye, and Lynch seems to be able to paint *anything*, from any angle, whether it be comical facial expressions, the giant's eye view of the world, or the cavernous tunnel where all the actions takes place. In particular, the expression of the Princess gesturing to her ring is priceless! I couldn't help but laugh at the perfect expression she wears of a person desparately trying to convey secret information without the antagonist realising she's doing so. The giant also is a great creation - menacing without being too terrifying. Like most folklore heroes, Art relys more on the advice on helpful guides than his own devices (the stallion is solely responsible for his salvation) and the Princess, in her own words has: "been here for a year and a day and I can't get away from this old fellow until someone comes to rescue me." Obviously the idea that such damsels could be their own rescuers had not yet reached fruitition, but Lynch's portrayal of her, with sparkling wit and humour makes her not a total loss as a female role model. Despite some narrative faults, "The King of Ireland's Son" is a great addition to the bookshelf, especially for those with a love for folklore and fairytales that are brought to life with thoughtful, creative illustrations.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|