Customer Reviews

King of the Klezmer Clarinet

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Descended from the Strettener Hasidic family of Rabbi Yehuda Hirsch Brandwein of Stratyn, Naftule Brandwein was born in the Polish Galician town of Przymyzl in 1889 and died in 1963. By the time of his death, klezmer was on the wane, and though Brandwein was a pioneer of a peculiar Yiddish American style, and a legendary talent, he was largely forgotten.

That's sad, because this rogue clarinetist known in the 1920s, 30s and 40s for inebriated antics both onstage and off, in 25 cuts reproduced here demonstrates an extraordinary talent.

Like Dave Tarras, Brandwein came from a long line of musicians. His family was the primary source of music in his region of Poland. His father Peysekhle played a violin and was (also like Tarras' father) a badkhn, or improvisational wedding poet. Brandwein had 12 siblings. His brother Moyshe played the violin, French horn and valve trombone, Mendel played the piano and Leyzer and Azriel played drums and cornet respectively. The latter was Naftule's teacher. Also like Tarras, Brandwein did not start on clarinet. His brother first taught cornet. Only later did he switch.

But unlike Tarras, Brandwein never learned to read music. His daughter recalled her father's stories of playing Poland, for Poles, Gypsies, Jews. He left Poland for America in 1908. By then the Yiddish theater had been invented and dramatists were earning their keep, and giving work to orchestras as well. But Brandwein brought the musicians out of the orchestra pits and onto the stage in their own right. Within nine years in New York, Columbia Records A&R (for artist and repertoire) man Abe Schwartz had discovered Brandwein.

The clarinet virtuoso left Schwartz in 1923, when he formed his own band and moved to the Victor label. But where Tarras' musical literacy afforded him many theater jobs, for Brandwein these fell off as the American jazz style of klezmer took hold.

He recorded 24 numbers between 1922 and 1927, nearly a third of them with his own name in the title. He did not record another until 1941. (Two of these cuts are duplicated on Music From The Yiddish Radio Project.) These were sold to the Jewish community through Ukranian, Rumanian and Russian catalogues. Brandwein composed many of the numbers, but according to the Library of Congress Copyright office he failed to copyright his work.

Brandwein may have been difficult, but he was also a musical genius. This recording is brilliant.

--- Alyssa A. Lappen

Twenty-five tracks, mostly from the twenties, the best period for Naftule Brandwein. This album is a must for any klezmer fan, or for any who wishes to know more about klezmer. The technical quality of the recording is sufficient to appreciate the skill and the sensitivity of this disorderly genius of the clarinet. Most of the tunes in this album have been recently revisited by several modern performers, but listening to them in their original version is a strong emotion. Brandwein's style is naive, irruent, powerful, virtuous. The booklet is lean and informative.

I learned about Naftule when I was watching the Pearlman Klezmer special on PBS. When they mentioned Naftule , my father screamed, "hey thats my mothers 1st cousin who played at my parents wedding". I learned that my grandmother loved this guy but thought he was a little mashugana(crazy). After listening to this I can state, yea he was crazy- as a fox, the same way mad geniuses like Hendrix , Mozart etc were tagged. Not to be missed

Naftule Brandwein is the greatest clarinettist I've heard in my life. Klezmer music is obviously not for everyone, but I believe any musician, and certainly any clarinettist, ought to hear the unbelievable sounds and effects that Brandwein elicited from his instrument--much more varied and inspired, in my view, than what you hear from Dave Tarras, the Klezmer clarinettist to whom Brandwein is most often compared. Just listen to some of the excerpts that Amazon lets you hear on this page, and see if you're not tempted to buy this CD. Tarras sounds like a human being playing a clarinet; Brandwein sounds like he's from another world.

Unfortunately, like most mainstream music lovers, I had not even heard of Brandwein until recently, and the liner notes explain that his unpleasant temperament, combined with his inability to read music, had a lot to do with the frustrations of his career. That makes this CD especially valuable: it's not easy to find this music anywhere else. (Two recordings on this CD can also be found in the collection called Music from the Yiddish Radio Project, ASIN: B000060P7J.)

Ok, not everyone is actually "studying" klezmer music. If you want the clearest recordings, buy a modern CD from the San Francisco Klezmer Experience, Budowitz, Brave Old World, the Klezmer Conservatory Band, Joel Rubin, etc.

If you want to learn from a master (kind of like all jazz players should be listening to Charlie Parker, Miles and Coltrane), then you must have this collection. It has the greatest hits (or maybe every recording) of Brandwein, who was absolutely far and away the most inspired klezmer clarinet player who recorded. Some love Tarras, some love others, but if you don't know "Nifty," then you don't know jack!

If you simply enjoy klezmer music, this is still a great album, as Brandwein is such a hot player the mono-78 sound quality is worth listening through. Actually, compared to the 78's from which we used to have to transcribe in the 80's and 90's, this is a really super clean sound. But there is still some static, so don't be surprised.

Oh, it's also nice to have some recordings at the end from the end of his life (when he wasn't afraid to use the lower register that Dave Tarras used to dominate in the old days). Those are at the end of the CD.

Naftule Brandwein was one of the pioneers of American klezmer music. A brilliant clarinetist but so paranoid of being copied that he often played with his back to the audience. Even so, his musical genius is brilliantly presented in this compilation disc remastered from cleaned-up 78's. Don't miss this collection.

The recordings are old and are perhaps typical of the day but Naftule shines through. Here are some of the wildest runs on a clarinet you will ever hear. Absolute genius!

I am looking for a CD better than Klezroym, but I haven't found it yet.