| ||||||||||||||||||||
Mirsky has an excellent command of the saga style and spins a fine, page-turning tale. . . there are some truly wonderful scenes of sea-faring and berserker duels. . . Vragi's final fight is worth the price of the book all by itself. . . ." -- Diana Paxson, Author of The Wolf and The Raven and The Hallowed Isle tetralogy. -- IDUNNA Magazine, November '99
Mirsky keeps us glued to this excellent first novel, using a subtle yet powerful story-telling technique that recalls old-time adventures involving swordplay, fair maidens in distress, relatives who are scoundrels, a misunderstood hero engaged in epic exploits, strange lands full of mysterious and wonderful peoples, and the power of good versus evil. The King of Vinland's Saga is a book the reader can't stay away from . . . and mourns when it is finished. --- -- Shelley Glodowski,Midwest Book Review, Fall 1999
THE KING OF VINLAND'S SAGA is a wonderfully rich adventure novel, with memorable characters, a storyline that is faithful to the mediaeval Icelandic sagas, and enough sword- and axe-play to please even the most jaded of adventure readers. . . . Mirsky's work compares well to that of his predecessors, both in terms of capturing the gloomy mood of the saga and the larger-than-life heroes, while avoiding any blatant historical inaccuracies . . . . Besides the heroic leader Sigtrygg, the huge berserker Arnliot with his cursed axe . . . in many ways reminiscent of Haggard's great Zulu warrior, Umslopogaas, Vragi the quiet and retiring old veteran who hasn't forgotten his skills with the sword, Girstein, the most reasonable and supportive of Sigtrygg's step family, and Thjodhild the vindictive and jealous kinswoman, the book is peopled with many complex and interesting characters. The fight sequences, be they between Greenlander and skraeling or amongst the Greenlanders t! hemselves are excellently portrayed, on par with any of Mirsky's literary precursors. . . This is one to please even the likes of Snorri Sturluson, and it even passed my "keep me up reading until 3 a.m. test." -- SF Site . . . Review by Georges T. Dodds
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
32 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
a very BIG, very worthwhile book,
By NotATameLion (Michigan) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The King of Vinland's Saga (Paperback)
The false accusation that some have leveled at this book--that of having stiff prose--is patently false. It may be a tad long for some, but I have greatly enjoyed this massive epic of the North.I have always had a love-hate relationship with the great Norse Sagas. They are full of wonder and discovery. They can also be somewhat one-dimensional. Perhaps it is something that gets lost in translation. Mirsky captures all the wonder and adventure of the ancient Norse landscape while at the same time somehow bringing to his tale of Sigtrygg to fully three dimensional life. What a great journey this tale is! I know that my enthusiasm for this book will no doubt be taken with a grain of salt by those predisposed to overlook of Norse literature as a regional oddity. Such a dismissive view would be a crime. It would be like never reading Tolkien because one does not enjoy books with dragons and elves. Is Mirsky a new Tolkien? No. And I doubt he has ever intended to be. Is he a very good writer who has made an exceptional book? Yes. And you should read it. I give The King of Vinland's Saga my heartfelt recommendation.
25 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Have read it twice, nevertheless, will read it thrice ...,
By "bigvalley48" (Stockton, CA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The King of Vinland's Saga (Paperback)
I enjoyed the book even more the second time around! The King of Vinland's Saga is fiction about a subject difficult to research, it is based on scant record and few viking runes left behind by the Norse. However Stuart Mirsky has seamlessly filled in the historical record with a colorful and knowledgeble imagination! Stuart has crafted a saga of adventure and intrigue, even of unrequited love that alas even an ole macho like meself could handle! A drifting together and gathering of a small group of down and out n'er-do-wells, political refugee's from King Harald, and incorrigibles have Norseman sailing west from an overcrowded Greenland. There is little land available in Greenland to farm and therefore little wealth to be had for those without. No land, no farm, no status. Status was above all of vital importance to a norseman for status was power. Those without status were looked down upon by the 'haves' and treated not much better than the clan goats. However they see a way out by voyaging to a new land, ostensibly to claim the heroes inheritance, Leif Ericksons lost colony in Vinland, America. The personalities in this saga are distinctly individual, they are alive and vibrant. They're just like ... us. You know, not every norseman was at all eager to go on what they thought was a fools errand, and some that went did so just to keep a step ahead of viking justice. But what makes fictional history and this book fun for me is this ... that the story is alogether plausible! It is written in a style that that seems to have a thrumming rhythm, almost lyrical at times and is written in syntax that is appropriate to the Norse and that period of history. I found myself being drawn deeply into the tale every time I settled in to read, angering at the injustice inflicted on hero Sigtrygg, the betrayals and lies by his arrogant, treacherous kinsmen. To me Sigtrygg is the Clint Eastwood of the Norse, but he keeps a cool head. If it were me in his place I'd of been lopping off heads left and right! Each evening when I opened the book I became a part of the tale, when I become part of the story I know I am reading a superb work by a superb author.I was initially drawn to the novel because Mr. Mirsky asked that I review it several years ago. Lack of time prevented me from doing so at the time but after reading it once again I made it a point to review. I was also drawn to the book because I had yet to read any substantive account of real or surmised Norse interaction with 'skraelings', American Indians, a subject barely recorded and virtually ignored. Inasmuch as I am a student of history and American native tribes in particular, I was very interested in Mr. Mirsky's treatment of two diverse cultures colliding unexpectedly, how the skraelings may have reacted to these rather arrogant, burly giants with beards coming from the sea. The book passages and events involving viking prejudice and treatment of the stone-age skraelings and the skraelings subsequent response rang true to what I know of viking culture, native indian culture, beliefs, and history of the time. Also, the premise that the Norse may have penetrated much farther inland in America than previously thought is not just wild speculation; ancient stone forts have been discovered as far inland as Kentucky, implements discovered far inland not of indian technology, and blue-eyed indians were a fact. In my view it is more credible that such is derived from a culture we absolutely can prove came to America, the vikings, than other theories that have been advanced. For the history buff and adventure-minded this book is a keeper for the ole bookcase, and even though it is a large volume, an intimidating volume, the tale still ends much too soon. Thanks Stuart!
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Standout in the Historical Fiction Genre,
By
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: The King of Vinland's Saga (Paperback)
Stuart Mirsky is one heck of a story-teller. He manages to replicate an archaic verbal tradition, while hooking us into an incredible action/adventure involving characters we genuinely come to care about.The story line involves Greenlanders, descendents of Eirik the Red who live in a less swashbuckling time than either Eirik or his famous son Leif. The main character is a young man named Sigtrygg. If Sigtrygg's paternity is unquestioned (he's a grandson of Leif Eirikson) his uncertain maternal blood makes him a second class citizen in his Eiriksfjord clan. He strikes a deal with his snooty uncles that will give him Leif's holdings in the by then almost mythical land of Vinland, to the west across the great sea, if he will simply go away and renounce his Greenland inheritance. The relationships and customs and ways of dealing with one-another of the Norse cultures provide a fascinating backdrop to the adventure, as does the dialogue. This novel takes place in the now-accepted-as-historical pre-Columbian era of Norse exploration and settlement in North America. Seldom or never have I read a true-to-voice saga of this imaginative quality. Stuart Mirsky has a magic touch with the saga style, and the ability to create fiction that could be history. The most striking feature of the book is, oddly enough, character development. Normally in a saga, the characters tend to be icons almost. Mirsky makes them live and breathe and never once departs from the archaic style. And yet the heroism of deeds and adventures that characterizes this genre is there in spades. Don't miss this richly endowed story.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|