Normally, I'm not a fan of short story collections (my own lunacy) or writers that are hailed by the so-called "hip" media (In this case I think it was Esquire). The whole David Eggers is finest writer we have train passed me by. Nevertheless, I bought Schickler's book--it sounded intriguing, was a first novel about young people and romance--or so I thought.
The reviewers here all have differing and interesting thoughts. I'm probably not going to have many original insights at this point, but I wanted to endorse this astounding work of fiction.
The first sign of how much I liked this is that is that I'm nervous that this will become a movie. I can see the the James-Rally-Patrick triangle becoming a film--and them casting Christian Bale in some absurd (patrick's word)attempt to capture the zeitgeist--yikes. The essence of this book is in Schickler's voice, his deceptively simple writing. The detail, the rich voice, the subletity of the writing.
The stories are all gently connected and it is fun to see small details and characters appearing again and again. The weakest story, by far, is the first one. Checkers and Donna. However, we are introduced to some themes and characters who will come up again. Several reviewers have touched on the weakness of the female characters--and while I don't even come close to agreeing with that assessment--Checkers and Donna might make you squirm. However, the rest of the book just traps you. I felt like a young James hiding in his dumb waiter and drowning out the rest of the world as I was propelled deeper into the story.
There is a change of pace--from comic to darkly comic to dark to light again. However, it works, if you are willing to go with Schickler. The magic is there--actual magic perhaps. Jacob's Bath is a moving & beautiful story. Rally and James make a couple, who, you care for deeply. The book touches on huge themes--themes I'd studied in literature classes from day one--grace, sins, and salvation (or remdemption).
Just who is Sender the doorman? Who is the mysterious JOhn castle--could it be...? Even Thomas Merchant seems otherworldy. I won't spoil this review with ruining the plot (esp. the last 3 chapters/stories), but there is some definate addressing of life's biggest issues. Salavation of some kind or another is found by the all the characters, even young actor Jeremy Jaxx (I think). Not an original theme, but starkly rendered at times (Patrick's "awful grace"), lyrical at others (Talking to Otis among others), and wonderfully romantic ("It can happen like that sometimes. The city can tilt its hand and let two people fall for each other as completely" as they did).
Nitpick if you will. I say spend that time reading and enjoying a welcome new voice to our American canon. You can keep your David Eggers, I'll hang out with David Schickler.