Customer Reviews

Kitchen Supply Toaster Oven Non-stick Cookie Sheet

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(6)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(8)

 

 

Just what I wanted! I have a boyfriend who comes around often to collect his handout of chocolate chip cookies (he actually bought me the toaster oven!). These sheets do not warp, they fit perfectly into my toaster oven, they bake great cookies, their non-stick feature stays like new, and they are easy to clean and store in my RV. So glad I found these! Get more than one, because your cookie recipients will want a double recipe!

Just what I needed! This works great for just two people. Everything slides off & it cleans up easily!

I use it almost everyday to cook a variety of things from chicken nuggets and fries to cookies. Food cooks evenly on it and it's easy to wash and store.

Yeah, I know, it has the measurements in the description....but somehow, this product was still smaller than I had expected it would be. Like, easy bake oven small. That said, I have used it a couple of times to bake rolls in my toaster oven with success. The item I received is exactly as pictured with the slightly raised edges. This may not be advised, but I throw it in the dishwasher and so far it's held up just fine. One benefit of it being small is that in the larger toaster oven you have room for this and another item to cook at the same time.

Product shows as "rimmed". It is not. Everything slips right off.
Yes it says "Cookie Sheet" but it is displayed as a "raised rim sheet
pan. I was mislead by the picture. Not to mention that it certainly
is NOT WORTH $15.00

my fault for not getting out the ruler ahead of time... otherwise a nice pan that cooks nicely and cleans easily. I like that that the sides dont have a high rolled edge as food can easily slide right off onto your plate. Edges do feel a bit unfinished however, like they have a sharp edge.

I purchased this item to use with a new toaster oven - primarily because it is made in the U.S.A. It was authorized for return the same day it arrived. The cookie sheet arrived marred, with numerous scratches - not shipping related. But, more importantly, it is ridiculously small. The actual useable size is 6" x 9". The 7" x 10" measurements noted in the description include the lip.

This cookie sheet was a real bummer. I've recently come to love baking small batches of cookies in my newish toaster oven. I usually just put a sheet of aluminum foil on the rack, and the cookies bake very nicely. I can fit eight or ten good-sized cookies in the oven with this method. I thought this sheet would be an improvement, but I'll probably rarely use it.

Pros: The edges are raised, but the corners form a sort of spout, which makes it easy to clean--gunk doesn't get caught in the corners, because there are none!

Cons: TINY. It has less usable area than a typical dinner plate. It fits about four typical chocolate chip cookies, which means it takes twice as long to bake the same amount as my foil method. Also, it arrived with no packaging, and it was scratched up quite a bit. It's purely an esthetic issue, but it still sucks to buy something damaged for full price. It looked like it probably had a label at one time, because the scratches were isolated to the outside edges--as if a card stock label had been wrapped around the middle.

In the end, I paid almost $13.00 for an EZ-Bake Oven sized cookie sheet that looks like it should have been on the clearance shelf at Ross for $1.99. Like I said, bummer.

This sheet has been great for my toaster oven. Its non stick surface is ideal for any item I put in there. Definitely a great buy.

The item works every bit as advertised. I have used it several times to cook almost anything, not just cookies, in my toaster oven. It cleans easily.