Most Helpful Customer Reviews
26 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
To Hell and Back Again, February 24, 2000
This review is from: Knight of the Demon Queen (Hardcover)
During the past few years, Hambly has spent much of her time sending her characters to hell, sometimes figuratively (in her mystery series (Graveyard Dust, et al)) and sometimes literally, as in this series. Decades ago, many characters might have experienced such a journey, but most of them would emerge unscathed, except for the rare one such as Frodo. A more recent trend is to see how much damage, physically, emotionally, and mentally, a character can endure and yet return. While not completely dark as that, the separate travels of Jenny and John are something you would rather stay home and read about rather than experience yourself. The hells include the usual physical difficulties, but also the ones of figuring out who to trust, how to survive in different environments, and having to worry about personal survival, the survival of those that you love, and at the same time worrying about the future of the land that you live in. I cannot recommend that anyone start the series with this book. Knowledge of what happened before is vital. As it is, since it has been months since the previous book, trying to separate out the various minor characters and determining whether they are important enough to worry about and why, is very difficult. On the other hand, Hambly brings us, among her hells, a new world, a mix of Blade Runner with the cities of Walter Jon Williams, a place that is not our own, but one that might be one of our own future hells. That piece is very well done. I hope that Hambly can bring about a conclusion of all this in the next book. Besides the concerns we have for the main characters, the lights are going out across the land, even without this plague of demons. While I do not expect a solution to all the problems facing Jenny and John, some more immediate than others, it would be good to allow them some peace and a chance to regroup.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Hambly is a Hambly, but..., November 6, 2000
This review is from: Knight of the Demon Queen (Hardcover)
I thought "Dragon Shadow" (the previous book in this series) was brilliant but depressing. It could have been subtitled, "When Bad Things Happen to Good People". However, things get much worse for Jenny and her bespectacled husband, Lord John in "Knight of the Demon Queen". The book opens with their son's attempted suicide. Lord John's people begin to die from a demon-caused plague...and the situation deteriorates from there. Lord John goes hunting for a demon on a world that resembles a half-drowned, New York City of the near future. His only allies are wired-in, wannabe wizards in a world of violent gangs, bad smells, and screaming, in-your-face-24-hours-a-day drug ads. Ugh. Get me out of this world, and don't send me back! Jenny spends her part of the novel trying to come to grips with her loss of magic. At least she gets to hang around with a dragon. At any rate, Hambly leaves us hanging at the end of "Knight of the Demon Queen". We don't know whether Jenny and Lord John are alive or dead. They seemed to have jumped from Purgatory straight into Hell. And here I am, still waiting for a reasonably happy ending. I'll read the sequel, but I wish I'd skipped "Knight of the Demon Queen".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Is the problem the ending -- or the middle?, September 30, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Knight of the Demon Queen (Hardcover)
There is a rhythm to science fiction/fantasy, and especially to Ms. Hambly's works. In a word, three is supposed to be the charm. As you turn page after page, the excitement builds because you are finally going to get a resolution of plots and subplots. I did not realize until the very final paragraph that this third book in the Dragonsbane series would not be the end. Like others whose reviews I have read here, my reaction ranged from disappointment to downright anger. But although it is easy to point to the ending as the problem with the experience of reading this book, I think that's just what sticks in your mind. The fact is that there have been other of Ms. Hambly's books -- notably any of the Darwath Trilogy or Windrose Chronicles -- which I never wanted to end. This was not such a book. There were times, particularly during the cyberpunk portion of the book, where I continued slogging along ONLY for the promise of resolution. I do not expect sunshine and roses in my fantasy reading -- God knows that The Mists of Avalon has a definite dark side -- but like some other reviewers, I had the sense that there was an almost sadistic strain to the way this book tortures the two main characters. One can only hope that the tone and mood of the book does not reflect something equally dark going on in the author's life; in the past, even in the midst of hardships, fears and difficulties, there has been a life affirming warmth and strength to her characters (think of Joanna trapped in the crystal, or Antryg in the silent tower). I have read, and will contine to read, anything Barbara Hambly sets down on paper. I just hope I feel better about it in the future than I did when suffering along with Jenny and John here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|