Most Helpful Customer Reviews
44 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not much "lib" here, November 16, 2005
This review is from: Knitter's Lib: Learn to Knit, Crochet, and Free Yourself from Pattern Dependency (Paperback)
The inside of the book seems at odds with the outside; in other words, "freeing yourself from pattern dependency" seems a trifle odd when this is predominantly a pattern book. Of course knitting and crochet stitches are taught in the first half, and I give the book 2 stars for treating crochet equally, and also for showing continental or left-hand held kntting as the default style since this is very rare (and how I now think some people are better off learning).
There are other inconguencies. In a chart on page ix, there is a "what you will and won't find in the book" list and first under the "will" is "XL patterns because big is beautiful dammit". There are a lot of things wrong with this; XL is hardly plus sized for one thing, but more importantly, *no XL patterns actually appear in the book*. All garments are sized S (M,L). Period. On the other side of the cahrt, is what you will not find and that includes, "a D-cup bikini because its beyond the bounds of sanity and decency." Excuse me? In the crochet bikini pattern featured later in the book, this is again reiterated. How much "pattern liberation" is that? I would call that just plain offensive and ignorant. The author should check out Knitty, the free online knitting magazine as well as White Lies Designs who sell many patterns for women with D-cup and above, and all are sexy, sane and decent. In the techniques area we are introduced to a technique called "Intarisa" which is actually *stranded* knitting. Sigh. Keep in mind these are only the errors I found upon the first day of owning this book.
As far as the patterns go, most are accesssories and terribly underwhelming such as the same (inadvertantly) nipple-shaped hat over and over but called something else each time. Ponchos, bags, scarves etc. and crocheting around clogs. Nothing terribly new here. Many of the designs shown will inevitably end up on the blog, "You Knit What?"
The book gets kudos only for treating crochet as compatible with knitting, which it is and I would like to see more books and patterns which combine the two. It might be a book to learn to knit and crochet with since the stitches are shown in photographs which are quite clear. There is nothing here for the advanced knitter or crocheter, and maybe little if anything for the intermediate.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
not what I expected, November 15, 2005
This review is from: Knitter's Lib: Learn to Knit, Crochet, and Free Yourself from Pattern Dependency (Paperback)
This book has instructions and patterns for both knitting and crochet, but it is much more crochet oriented. That's not exactly what I expected from a book called Knitter's Lib. It may be just the thing for people who are interested in both, but just be aware that the author seems much more into crochet.
The style of the patterns is very narrow, they're mostly for people who have a trendy, urban fashion sense. Some of the most memorable patterns are the knitted skater pants, a mesh skirt, and yet another bikini top pattern.
There is a short introduction to knitting and crochet and a technique chapter. Though a lot of techniques were given, I didn't find much that would really help me use them together and create my own patterns. That was a disappointment, because the book description sounds like it would have more design help.
I also dislike the very wordy way that the patterns are written out. It makes them hard to skim and all the extra text would be distracting when trying to work from them. The book says that they're written out that way to explain why certain things in the pattern are done, but it just seemed like a lot of unnecessary text to me. I'd think that all that extra stuff would confuse a new knitter or crocheter and frustrate a more advanced one.
I would not recommend this book for beginners. Some of the shortcuts and tips that the author gives are pretty bad advice, they encourage knitters and crocheters to cut corners and do some things in a quick, easy, and sloppy way. One thing that I really disliked was the suggestion to crochet seams instead of sewing them. Yes it's faster, and yes most of us hate finishing. But crocheted seams are much less flexible than knitted ones and they just don't look as nice. If you spend a lot of time knitting a beautiful project, wouldn't you want to put as much care into finishing and make it look as nice as possible?
If you're looking for a knitting book with instructions and hip patterns, check out Stitch 'N Bitch. I'm not a very good crocheter, so unfortunately I don't have a crochet book recommendation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Increasing is too hard?, November 23, 2005
This review is from: Knitter's Lib: Learn to Knit, Crochet, and Free Yourself from Pattern Dependency (Paperback)
The author says that she avoids body hugging shapes because they're just not urban. OK. Fine. We'll ignore, for a moment, that more fitted pieces LOOK better (even on plus sized folks!) and boxy shapes make you look BOXY.
She also writes that she prefers to start with ALL the stitches and decrease down because increasing (in knitting) is just too darn hard. What?
She calls fair isle or stranded knitting "intarsia," which it's not.
For a "knitter's" book, there is a TON of crochet. And not just as accents or edging, but whole projects made with only crochet.
Skip this one. It seems to be a book written to cash in on the knitting frenzy (down to calling a mostly crochet book a knitting book) and it's got too many errors in it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|