From Publishers Weekly
This disquieting story aims straight at the preoccupations likely to visit adopted children. Katie, who thinks "a lot" about babies, wants to know if she grew in her "real mommy's" belly. "Of course . . . " her mother says. "But I'm your real mommy, too." Later the youngster asks, "Why didn't my first mommy want me?" The adoptive mother assures the girl that her birth mother loved her: "She wanted you to have a better life than she could give you"--a concept that few children Katie's age will be able to grasp. After a visit to the zoo, Katie "adopts" a toy koala from the gift shop and, in an excursion to Katie's imaginary world, the book shows her caring for the koala and protecting it from danger. Jabar's intimate, circular compositions reflect the warmth and love that abound in Katie's family while her light touch with her watercolors gives the book mainstream appeal. However, London (see below) focuses more on anxieties about biological vs. adoptive parents than on the love that motivated Katie's parents to extend their family in the first place. An insightful note to parents, by a social worker with the Northwest Adoption Exchange, precedes the story. Ages 3-6.
Copyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Toddler Katie thinks a lot about babies. She wonders why she was never in her adoptive mother's belly and wants to know why her birth mother didn't want her. When she sees a mother and baby koala at the zoo, she wants a toy koala. At home, she plays out her questions. When her mother kisses her goodnight and says, "'I like your baby,'" Katie replies,"'I'm really her mommy now.'" This gentle story presents a few very important concerns of adoptive families in an even, nondidactic manner. Jabar's watercolor illustrations have an upbeat, cartoony brightness that is well balanced with the easy-going, spare text. A "note for parents" opens the book and is entirely unnecessary, as the author and illustrator have done a fine job of creating a picture book that serves a broad, general audience.
Anna Biagioni Hart, Sherwood Regional Library, Alexandria, VACopyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc.