Most helpful critical review
52 of 54 people found the following review helpful
on January 24, 2013
I first was ready to give this seat 5 stars, but then I really examined it thoroughly before reviewing it. As you can see I am supposed to give an honest review. So honestly the price is wonderful. The wooden seat provides firm seating, and pretty comfortable. And the seat stays firmly in place not wobbling or even moving at all. Like another reviewer stated it does seem to sit a little over to one side, but that is fine, and I won't deduct any stars for that. However I am deducting 2 stars for the bad paint job on the side of both the seat top and seat bottom. Since another reviewer has written that his seat too has a bad paint job, I am wondering if these aren't Kohler's seconds that are being sold here. Anyway because of the bad paint job resulting in a rough texture on the side of both the upper and lower parts of the seat, which is facing my bathroom door, I can only honestly give it 3 stars.