Customer Reviews

Korean War Stories [VHS]

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Korean War Stories (Robert Uth, PBS) presents a unique combination of interesting interview pieces with amazing film footage, offering the viewer the rare opportunity to see into the characters that have saved us from more struggle throughout the last 50 years (this is 2005). One of the most poignant collections of interviews is that which details Brad Smith's efforts to defend the Army's position in the early, heartbreaking months of the War; how our under protected, underequipped soldiers woke up to a wall of Chinese, Russian, and North Koreans bearing heavy tanks down on Americans with nothing but unsophisticated rocket launchers to defend themselves. The producer, Robert Uth, seems to have found the perfect blending of true history and testimony, with documentary footage and imagery. The original music (other than the Willie Nelson performance) is exceptionally moving and draws the viewer into the experience even more. Korean War Stories is a magnificent production I thoroughly recommend.

I'm a United States history teacher and I've seen quite a few by now, and this is the best I have seen covering the Korean War. It has great maps that show the different stages of the war. The maps help illustrate things such as the DMZ, The Pusan Perimeter, The Inchon Invasion and The Chosin Reservior. Actually I think it is far better than "Dear America: Letters From Vietnam" because it doesn't have actors reading the letters, it has the real vets talking about their experiences. If you're looking for a great documentary to explain and give insight on the Korean War, this is a must. Be prepared, some of the interviews are tremendously emotional, to say the least. Definitely a forgotten victory.

The best line in this video is near the end, where a veteran of that war says, "The Korean War is not a forgotten war, it is a forgotten victory." Absolutely true, but a point few people in the United States seem to understand. In the age of nuclear weapons, total victory in the Korean War, as measured by Korean unification under the leadership of the United Nations, was not possible. That was something that General Douglas MacArthur never seemed to understand, which cost him his command and much of his historical legacy. The problem is that the people in the United States generally do not understand the principle of limited war for limited gains. In the end, it turned out to be a tremendous victory, the policy of containment was the correct one, as communism self-destructed, overcome by the internal contradictions. Modern commentators are fond of saying that President Ronald Reagan won the cold war, which is not true. Harry Truman, a vastly under-appreciated president, made the decision to go to war and stop the spread of communism. He understood that a stalemate was a victory, as communism will either succeed everywhere or nowhere. The free Europe we know today germinated from a seed planted in Korea.
By far, the best part of this tape is the personal comments from celebrity veterans of the war. Until I viewed it, I did not know that baseball great Ted Williams was the wingman of astronaut and Senator John Glenn. I also did not know that singer Willie Nelson is also a veteran of the Korean War. Their comments and the footage take you back to a time where the world had changed and the bulk of the free population had not yet caught up.
Finally, one of the most telling moments that will ever exist in historical videos occurs near the end of the tape. A doctor, returning from Korea, arrives a few minutes before nine in the evening. He is all primed to be welcomed home and talk about his experiences. However, when nine o'clock arrives, he is told that "I Love Lucy" is about to come on, so the attention shifts to the television. Understandably, he is angered and leaves the premises, remaining angry for two years. However, no story more accurately describes the situation of that time. The advent of television has led to a short attention span, and the American public finds it difficult to accept partial results.
This tape is an excellent recapitulation of that era, where there was a seismic shift in political perceptions around the world. The free countries stood their ground and fought against communist aggression, pushing it back to the point where it started. However, this victory was only clear decades later, and there was an enormous cost in blood and treasure. Nevertheless, it was no doubt much less than it would have been had the communists won in Korea.

This movie may have gotten an Award , but it is a story that is incomplete & inaccurate .See "The Korean War" (Fire & Ice)DVD or The History Channel (Korea The Forgotten War)DVD.These two DVD's are accurate & complete.I was with the First & Third Marines for the entire War (36 Months).

I purchased this DVD because my father fought in Korea, and hasn't talked much about it. It's an emotional description of Korea and what it meant to those who fought and those at home who didn't. It's worth seeing for anyone wanting to know more about the emotional toll Korea took on the membes of the military who were there.

Korea: My fathers time. As a baby boomer who's prior generation got caught up in this conflict, I find this tape to be most usefull. It's presentation of heroes well known to my generation such as Ted Williams, Scott Glenn and others tell stories of the conflict I never knew and enjoyed hearing. I have bought this tape and handed it out to heroes I met on the street to pass along to those whose families still do not the the hardship these men went through. It will bring relief to those who have never vented their stories to their loved ones. Buy it, Keep it, and pass along an extra one to someone who could use an uplift from that time .

This was a gift for a Korean War Vet. I was told by him that this was one of the best telling of the stories of " The Forgotten War"

Dad was given this for Christmas and he really enjoyed it. Great gift for vets of Korean war & history buffs.

For those of us a little to young to know much about this war, this dvd really filled in the gaps.

Deppressed, emaciated,tiered, poncho weared US.Infantry
. under the Raining, -Among the Americans--"Forgotten
War".
Completly unprepared many Amercan Young Men went to koprea for "Polce Action" in korea.
After repeated losted Battles and repeated retreats from many combat experienced
N.K.Army especially CHINESE war experenced 3rd and 6 th Div.with WW11,famous T-34 Tanks.
UN.Forces retreated to Pusan Perimeter.Anotther DUNKIRK be wdrried.
After the Inchon landing, Recapture of Seoul, Advance after crossing 38 th paraelle,some UN Forces
reached Yalu Liver. At that time, US.had 2 Great mistakes.
1) Ignore the continuous warning of involvment of Korean War, If UN Foece cross the 38 th pararell.
2) overlook Pow with Chinese language.
Ghosy,silent infiltration,and encirclement of all 8th Army, West front and Ist Marine and 7th dIV.
10th Corps,east front, of the Chinese Suprise Attack disintergrate West Front.
Only US Marine 1st Div.sucessfully fight back Reatreat( Chinese esmated 6 Div.is neccesary for
desruction of US.1st Marine Div.). They could evacuate from Heungnam Pot.
'But disintgrated 8th Army retreated until 38th Pararell with Horror and losted thir Fighting Spirit! 1
Many casualties,POWs and MIA made deep sorrow oe remaining Families and All Americans with Wlthdraw
of Korean War!