Customer Reviews

The Kosher Guide to Imaginary Animals: The Evil Monkey Dialogues

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Okay, this slender little book charmed my socks right off! That's a fact. And I write reviews of every book I read. Another fact. But for some reason I'm having a difficult time articulating exactly why I enjoyed this light-hearted gift so much. I think it's actually because there's quite a bit packed into this small package. What I can tell you is this: It brought a smile to my face when I was well and truly blue.

After a couple of very brief prefaces, the bulk of the book is made up of an alphabetical listing of fantastic creatures. There are 34 total, each with a two-page spread. Squeezed neatly into those two pages is a charming black and white illustration of a critter; a colorful description of its history, origin, habitat, etc.; and the "Evil Monkey Dialogues." Despite the bizarre name, this is simply a little light kibbitzing between husband and wife authors Jeff and Ann VanderMeer on the presumed kosherness of said creature. She's a member of the tribe, he's the Evil Monkey.

Of the 34 creatures covered, I was familiar with about a dozen of them. Some were as basic as a Dragon or Mermaid or Sea Monkey, but other creatures were exotic beasts from far away lands and cultures like the Jotai, the Encantado, and the Abumi-Guchi. I'm fairly positive at least one, the Borges, was made up entirely in the authors' imagination. As it happened, that was my favorite listing in the book.

After the creature listings, the final section of the book was discussion with chef/baker Duff Goldman about how one might prepare these creatures, kosher and treyf alike. Now I've never seen his TV show, Ace of Cakes, but he must be an entertaining guy because he's got a delightful sense of humor and a whimsical streak a mile wide. Not only does he discuss the creatures featured previously in the book, but he improvises with other imaginary animals. In fact, he may be a closet sci-fi fan, because he proposes recipes for a Chewbacca and a Tribble, which, let's face it, is pretty much a hairy Rocky Mountain oyster.

My copy of this book had a delightful bonus. Tucked inside were three postcards that the publisher had used for promotional purposes. They were recipe cards for the preparation of Mongolian Death Worm and other culinary delicacies.

I'll tell you what, this little tchotchke is the perfect gift for the person in your life who could use a little more whimsy, a little more magic, and a little more laughter--even if that person is you. I can only hope there's a second volume on the way!

This book is Very Highly Recommended (!!!), as it is quite simply guaranteed to bring the joy of laughter into your life.

Described as `whimsical', it could also be accurately called `wonderful' or `delightful', even `delicious' (pardon the pun) and despite my goy-dom, I thoroughly enjoyed getting in touch with my Inner Jew for the duration this book. All 34 Imaginary Animals contained in this bite-sized book (Darn! There I go again!), are wonderfully illustrated and each and every entry features an extremely funny short dialogue between Ann and Jeff's devilishly twisted alter ego, Evil Monkey. When I wasn't chuckling outright, I was smiling all the way through, and even, most unusually for me, the book provoked five or six out-loud belly laughs. Make sure you don't miss out on the hilarious exchange between Ann and Celebrity Chef Duff Goldman at the end on the proper way to cook imaginary animals - you'll never think of Cherubs, Cthulhu or Tribbles in exactly the same way again!

In addition to the content, when you consider the production values (this book is a properly bound (stitched), dust-jacketed hardcover that will last for years through many readings), the value-to-money-spent-ratio becomes even higher.

A great gift idea and an ideal way to while away a couple of idle hours.

Sequel! Sequel!

Jeff VanderMeer and his wife Ann have come up with a winner this time. Let's take some imaginary animals, and try to decide whether they would be kosher or not. Add to each animals descriptions a conversation between Evil Monkey (Jeff) and Ann in an IM format and you've got the table set for a belly full of laughs.

Imagine such creatures as Abumi-Guchi, Akaname, Jaud, or Shedim; bring in the legend and a tale of them, and follow up with a hysterical commentary and you'll have this adorable book. Reminiscent of VanderMeer's `The Thackery T. Lambshead Pocket Guide To Imaginary Diseases', this thin volume of imaginary animals is bound to entertain you. Perfect to keep in the purse for those waits at the doctor or DMV, you shouldn't allow yourelf to miss out on this extraordinary treat of literature. Enjoy!

I received this book yesterday and read it in an hour or two. It's a really fun idea, in which the two authors ( a couple) contemplate various types of mythical beasts and whether or not such a beast would be kosher to eat according to Jewish practice. The format is 2 pages per mythical beast, one of which describes the animal and identifies its origin on folklore. The facing page includes a transcript of the authors' discussions about the kosher edibility of the creature, many of which are laugh out loud funny. The book is derived from a series of blog postings, and if you are familiar with the "Evil Monkey" blog you probably have already seen much of the material.

The choice of beasts is rather random and often obscure but I would like to have seen either many more included in this small format, or a more interesting and substantive discussion of the application of Jewish practice to each creature. If the book included the latter it would be a really fun way to learn and reinforce the practices of kosher, and would be a cool addition to otherwise often dry Hebrew school classes.

As it is, it's a fun novelty for a gift or your coffee table, along the lines of Jewish Haiku, but I was hoping for more to, you should forgive the pun, chew on.

Just didn't find it funny. Most of the animals are so obscure it doesn't really make for an interesting book. There's a description of each animal, and then a brief dialog between "Ann" and "Evil Monkey" supposedly about the animal's kosherness, but I felt like they tried to hard to be clever, and often doesn't even answer the question.

Just a note that the book is indeed available for the Kindle: The Kosher Guide to Imaginary Animals I've entered four stars to preserve the average for this book--obviously, we think it's a five-star book!

As a seriously kosher individual (4 sets of dishes, pots, draining boards, sponges, etc. I was quite disappointed in the rather cursory way in which the individual creatures were treated. Hopefully the authors or some others will treat this important topic in a more academic fashion in the future.