12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Catching up with Russia..., December 16, 2005
This review is from: Kremlin Rising: Vladimir Putin's Russia and the End of Revolution (Hardcover)
As the title may suggest, my purpose in reading this book was to get a general update on the status of Russia. Specifically, I wanted a closer look at the status of its political system, the economy and what challenges Russians face today.
Baker and Glasser succeed in delivering a well researched, documented and written account about Russia (w/ focus on the years 2000-2005 a sort of a pyatiletka history review).
Any reader exercising his or her reason will detect a "less-than-favorable" view which the authors hold of president Putin. This should not be grounds for dismissing "Kremlin Rising" as an inaccurate-ideological book. Whatever benefits brought to Russia by Putin and his cronies, a plausible if not credible argument can be made (is made by Baker and Glasser) that the incompetency, corruption and other "costs" outweigh the benefits.
I would recommend the following 5 chapers (out of 18) as the chapters which in my opinion discuss flaws that Russia needs to address if only to retain her position in the world:
Ch.9) Sick Man of Europe: decline of population, HIV, reasons why this is so and what is being done to "heal"
Ch.8) Fifty-seven Hours in Moscow: Nord-Ost seige, a vivid account
Ch.18) Lenin Was Right After All: the teaching of Russian history; a new generation longing for Stalin/Soviet Union
Ch.10) Runaway Army: problems with the military, conscripts and their treatment
Ch.1) Fifty-two Hours in Beslan: Beslan handling, another vivid account of how crisis is dealt with in Russia
Well, I hope this helps.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Empire Falls 101, July 9, 2006
This review is from: Kremlin Rising: Vladimir Putin's Russia and the End of Revolution (Hardcover)
I was a little skeptical of this book when I first picked it up, expecting it to be one of those typical occidental treatises on "them quirky Soviets" and about how Russia and her new chief were going to be ruined because of the clear disdain for democracy.
On the one hand, Kremlin Rising is exactly that: the book makes no attempt to veil its contempt for Putin on all subjects from A to Z. It's as if the man invented the bubonic plague, and had the authors been charged with writing a history book, I'm sure they would've included that detail.
On the other hand, Kremlin Rising is something quite unprecedented, a broad-spectrum analysis of what's wrong with Russia today and why. The chapters on Beslan and Nord-ost were especially arresting, craftily written but without much pomp or sap. The bulk of this book is factual information, introduced to us by various "characters" the authors met in their tenures at the Washington Post in Russia. Everything from Chechnya to the crippled Red Army to the adolescent zeitgeist to the radio revolution is covered, and that's extremely impressive for two American journalists for whom the peculiarities of Russian culture may have been a little difficult to grasp.
My main complaint with this book is the overwhelming bias that sometimes resulted in the omission of certain truths, just to emphasize how much of a beast VVP really is. For example, even though Baker & Glasser go to great lengths to talk about Yeltsin's alcoholic incompetence, they portray the years under him as some kind of democratic paradise, a decade of unregulated freedom with few tangible consequences. While television wasn't state-owned - that much I'll hand to old Boris - those nine years of the true perestroika were a textbook case of rampant chaos, starting with the free-for-alls of privatization schemes to the alarming crime waves. Yet none of this is covered, to add contrast to Russia today. Only about a sentence is dedicated to the fact that crime diminished (just a little, I know, but in a nation where it was so popular, a little means a lot), and nowhere is it talked about that perhaps Russians have a valid excuse to "fear" democracy.
The second thing that irritated me about B&G's account was how much they strove to portray Khodorkovsky as the boy wonder of democratic reform. They talked about his privatization deals under the umbrella term "shady" and mentioned his boasting to buy parliament in '03, yet at the end of the chapters, sympathy toward a man who basically dug his own grave resonated throughout the concluding paragraphs. When a guy goes around talking about how he's going to purchase a deliberative body and then lecture a president about corruption - I'm sorry, but that paradox doesn't merit the kind of pity that was relegated to him by Kremlin Rising.
Lastly, the relentless underlining of Putin's past as a KGB agent seemed hypocritical at best. It's well known that it's now a big part of who he is as a political leader, but the analogous situation of Bush, Sr., a former head of the CIA, is not treated. The CIA is responsible for numerous attempted and perpetrated coups. Why are we not outraged by erstwhile directors becoming presidents? Why is the guy who never even made colonel portrayed as the next coming of Dzerzhinski? It's ridiculous and unnecessary, at least until the authors begin to talk about how his KGB past has influenced his decisions in the present, such as to increase the hiring of former operatives in the Kremlin network.
Overall, the book was fascinating and rarely boring. It's a great piece of work for someone who wants to get a thorough introduction to what Russia is, how she thinks and why, and what the future holds for the largest country in the world. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Putin 101, June 23, 2005
This review is from: Kremlin Rising: Vladimir Putin's Russia and the End of Revolution (Hardcover)
One of the best books I have read on the New Russia--which, after reading the book, you see may not be so "new" after all. This excellent study of present-day Russia and its leader is concise, interesting, well-written, informative, and not just a little bit scary. After the Wild Wild West-ness of the Yeltsin years it was inevitable that a Sheriff would ride into Moscow and reign in the party. Vladimir Putin is that Sheriff, a man of (very) few words who prefers to let his actions speak for him. Anyone with even a passing interest in where Russia is today, where it might be headed, and the implication for the rest of the world will find this book well worth their time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No