Product Details

• Actors: Saif Ali Khan, Kareena Kapoor, Vivek Oberoi, Kiron Kher, Om Puri
• Format: NTSC
• Language: Hindi
• Region: All Regions
• Number of discs: 1
• Studio: UTV
• DVD Release Date: February 5, 2010
• Run Time: 160 minutes
• Average Customer Review: 3.4 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (7 customer reviews)
• ASIN: B003AMUAEG
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #47,224 in Movies & TV (See Top 100 in Movies & TV)
• For more information about "Kurbaan" visit the Internet Movie Database (IMDb)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5 stars Love It., August 1, 2011

By 

sarahlee - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: Kurbaan (DVD)

If you like Bollywood. This is such an awesome movie. had me un the edge of my seat. Kareena is in a different role from all her other movies. Very serious in this. I really got into the characters. love the sound track.

3.0 out of 5 stars Recurring theme?, June 19, 2011

By 

Von DuMozze - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: Kurbaan (DVD)

I would have liked to have known that there were subtitles, even though I was pretty sure that there would be. It was similar to "New York" with its theme of religious terrorism, showing both sides of the fence. I don't care about that either way. If you have an open mind, just take it for what it's worth, a decent film.

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

1.0 out of 5 stars How has 9/11 changed you? Submit your story., September 5, 2011

By 

G. T. Bysshe (San Francisco Bay Area, CA USA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: Kurbaan (DVD)

Karan Johar responds: We have lost many innocent friends and family in America's senseless hunt for terrorists, and now we seek retribution and recognition for their suffering by blowing up airplanes and subways in NYC. (Riyaz:) "If you mess around with peoples' lives in other countries, you have to expect a backlash!" This is the story of Kurbaan. (A backlash on a backlash?)

Many of my favorite Indian actors stepped forward to do this film. I feel sympathy for them because they are actors. Especially Kirron Kher who appeared in both Fanaa [Fanaa [Blu-ray] (Indian Cinema / Bollywood Movies / Hindi Film )] and Rang De Basanti [Rang De Basanti], and always appears as a true stakeholder in this dialogue. And the rest of the crafts people as well, all artists. I love you guys!

Karan Johar, who has been successful for the most part, probably thought that he was good enough for a movie like this, put big money behind it, and line it up for big release. Isn't that Indian cinema's big problem- not enough capital? More capital, more success, working the equivocation, using the audience as a polling place for political events. Its just like that. Commercialism at it best.

But he "shined on" the entire cast and crew and the location interviews and press releases... it is all too obvious from the DVD Bonus Features on the making of the film that not only the actors but also the entire crew as well thought the film was SOMETHING GOOD, something to help the situation of Islam and the West, something universal, beyond the stated plot of the movie.

ALL with the assistance of a book called "Who Speaks for Islam, What a Billion Muslims Really Think" (Who Speaks For Islam?: What a Billion Muslims Really Think) specifically photographed in the Bonus piece, sitting beside the Director on his side table. A book produced in the U.S.A. was used to pitch the meaning/opportunity of this film to everyone.

From the Publisher: "In the wake of the terrorist attacks on 9/11, US public officials seemed to have no idea whether or not many Muslims supported the bombings." Also this: "Muslims say the most important thing Westerners can do to improve relations with their societies is to change their negative views towards Muslims and respect Islam."

Ten years after 9/11 we know that a significant number of Afghans don't even recognize the photo images of NYC 9/11 and never knew anything about it, let alone support it or not.(Helmand 8/2011) Haven't you noticed, 9/11 does not mean the same thing around the world as it does to NYC/USA. France's great statement "Today, 9/11, we are all Americans," I guess that doesn't apply here, apparently not to Indians & Pakistanis, they are innocents. 9/11 starts when the the bombs fall on them. (Have you noticed how in Indian film, Hitler is a kind of vile demented comic hero like Charlie Chaplin, a part of the corruption of the West, somebody that Indians/Pakistanis could never be? Its like that with the terrorists, "that's not us.")

Ten years, the American public only accounts for its own, 3000 dead 9/11; 6,000+ service dead 45,000 wounded, $6 TRILLION; we never take account of the casualities on the other sides of our conflicts (Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan), which are in the millions. ("America, when will we end the human war?//America when will you be angelic?//When will you look at yourself through the grave?//America why are your libraries full of tears?//America when will you send your eggs to India?//... Allen Ginsberg January 17, 1956.... )

These are valid issues and they do come up in the film, but what does this movie do for these issues? Nothing, actually something negative: a movie about a sleeper cell seeking retribution and recognition of their suffering by blowing up airplanes and subways in NYC actually goes completely against the supposed findings in this book.

I feel bad that Philadelphia gave use of their subway system for the filming of this movie. Many others refused to do so. The producers even presented the "struggle" to get some city, including NYC itself (!), to agree to this use of subway facilities for the film as an admirable vissitude of the film making process- (!!) I bet Philly feels differently about this now, after being pitched by any of the lines in John Esposito's book.

And how come I can't embrace Indian film producers when they go on foreign location?- a depiction of the New York City that is not THE city, (like Bhansali taking the cast of Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam to Prague as a stand in for Rome-) I am not stupid-I know the Philadelphia skyline when I see it, and the housing styles too. But, hey- who cares? right, what does it matter, this is done in film making all the time...

Except: this film WANTS to support reality as actuality, both geographically and politically. It needs this to be New York City of 9/11. It isn't a film if it is not the BONIFIED AMERICAN TARGET...After all these years they still don't get it- Indians don't make film that embrace reality of the world and the camera.

This movie was made only for Indians who wouldn't care that much, but see an innocent Hindi woman involved in a Islamist terrorist action against her will, and a Islamic immigrant working in US media fighting against it, AS A BALANCE. While at the same time another Indian audience can vent its anger and frustration at the US in a city that HAS TO BE associated with 9/11, (but isn't NYC, and in reality, COULD NEVER HAVE BEEN.)

Why not make a contribution to our debate about Ground Zero and the new downtown Muslim Cultural and Education Center, help us out, but...oh I forgot that won't sell tickets in India....

As it turns out, Indian audiences didn't buy it either, the movie barely made back half its costs. Some thought it didn't have a burning issue, even lacked a soul. They neither praised it nor panned it, just treated it as another action movie.

Rather than something universal, this movie is a hypocritical failure. For Westerners, life is by definition equivocal. And it is the endurance of the "duration" (Henri Bergson) of the equivocal nature of life that makes for western tragedy. Without acknowledgement of the equivocal, there is no tragedy, no hope for truth. This movie shows NOT ONE SECOND of the history of sacrifice among the terrorists, does make any case for the suffering of the terrorists, merely references it, does not show one moment of hesitation, or doubt AMONG THE TERRORISTS. NOR does not show one scene of sacrifice on 9/11, merely making it into a reference for their own subsequent suffering.

US audiences spent $734,209 on Kurbaan, Indians $18M, half the movie's cost. Devdas 2002 raked in $18.8M from US markets alone, 25 times that of Kurbaan.