5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good book, except for a few inaccuracies., August 2, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Kuwait (Enchantment of the World) (Library Binding)
I liked this account of the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait and the history of the country itself. It has a lot of good information, but I think that the author or publisher should have consulted with more experts. The author makes a few errors in her facts. An example is that she notes the sand storms that strike Kuwait in the winter. Anyone who has lived in Kuwait can tell you that sandstorms are a summer phenominon. Several of photographs that contain Arabic writing were printed backwards as well. While the errors in this book do not discredit the book as a whole, they are inaccuracies that could have been avoided quite easily. Dispite these errors, I beleive that this book gives a fairly good picture of what Kuwait is like. It also paints a good picture of what Kuwait was like during the time between the Iraqi occupation and liberation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting history that needed to be fact-checked., June 28, 2010
This review is from: Kuwait (Enchantment of the World) (Library Binding)
Leila Merrell Foster's "Kuwait" is part of a Young Adult (YA) series called "Enchantment of the World" published by Children's Press, a division of Grolier Publishing Co., Inc.
Unfortunately this book contains the same blooper as another YA book on Kuwait that I recently read (
Kuwait (Creation of the Modern Middle East) by Susan Korman) in that it has 7th Century Arabian tribes challenging the might of the powerful Ottoman Empire.
The Ottoman Empire didn't take shape until nearly a millennium after Muhammad's death.
Neither of these authors has been to Kuwait or has a background in Middle Eastern history, although Leila Merrell Foster claims to have visited "Iraq, Iran, Yemen, Egypt, Syria, Israel, Jordan, and Lebanon."
Since editors of these two books used writers without much background in the countries they wrote about, shouldn't they have edited the resulting manuscripts for factual content?
This author shapes her history of Kuwait around the Iraqi invasion of this country, and tells the story of the 1990 attack through the eyes of twelve-year-old Ahmad and his family, residents of Kuwait City. Unfortunately, what Ms. Foster does not tell the reader until her own brief autobiography at book's end is that "Ahmad, Fatima, and their family and friends are fictional characters." Since this book purports to be a true history, she should have informed us up front that her characters, who narrate the brutality of the Iraqi soldiers and the sufferings of the Kuwaitis, do not actually exist.
Kuwait's history, like many of the countries on the Arabian Peninsula is divided into before and after the discovery of oil. Pearl-diving, fishing, and ship-building were the main Kuwaiti occupations before the discovery of vast oil fields under its soil and in the Persian Gulf. It wasn't until after World War II that drilling began in earnest.
This author does a good job of balancing the positive and negative impact of oil money on Kuwaiti society. On the minus side, there are now more foreign workers in this small country (the size of New Jersey) than there are citizens, and Kuwait's neighbors (Iraq and Saudi Arabia) have made several attempts to take back what they consider to be 'their' territory.
Ultimately, this is an interesting book. I only wish it had been edited more thoroughly, and the author hadn't led me astray about her fictional characters (I became quite attached to them).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No