Customer Reviews

Kyra: A Novel

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

This novel is not your typical love story. It is a very academic read, full of references to opera, human psychology, classical music and literature. The framework of love and human relationships is explored and the therapist/patient relationship is challenged in thoughtful ways. I remember Carol Gilligan's name from my studies in graduate school. Her work in gender studies and moral development was groundbreaking. This is not a light read, it will leave you thinking about love, human tradgedy, the architecture of our lives, and the nature of human perserverence long after you put down the book. It is not for everyone, but if you would enjoy examining love at an academic level, you will enjoy Gilligan's unique approach. I found it a page turner and a real gem.

This is a one-of-its kind book, not cliched like several others, and though not for everyone, it will certainly offer food for thought for many.
First off, to me it was quite clear that this was a debut novel from Gilligan. The writing is almost the same structurally throughout which made for tedious repetition. Yet the story itself is wonderful. It weaves together history, romance, and pyschology into a unique pattern of its own. In part because of her writing and treatment of the characters, the situations, though tough, do not seem too distressing or heavy. While certainly not a light read, this won't consume you.
I loved how this book chronicles a woman's journey earnestly, insightfully, but does not-for the sake of writing fiction-try to wrap her life up and tie a big bow on top in the end. Nor does it overdramatize. It is an understated, real, and a very worthwhile read.

Having been a fan of Gilligan's work for over 25 years as a Professor of Speech & Intercultural Communication I was excited to read her first novel. I was not disappointed!!! I found it to be a refreshingly new twist on an old theme. She kept me interested from the first page to the last. Kyra and Andreas have complicated lives that lead to a complex relationship. Gilligan wove a rich tapestry of all the nuances of difficult relationships. I was facinated not only with the love story but the ideas presented on theraputical relationship. A good read and one I'll take to my 10 year book group. Much grist for the mill!!!

Kaye Jensen Nubel

"Kyra" is a gorgeously written, intelligent love story set against a cold New England backdrop. It's complex in the tradition of great novels of that past: It creates ambiance and makes you think. Few authors devote themselves to research and the craft of writing the way Gilligan does. There are many passages sculpted to beauty. The opening salvo, a chess game, is perfectly choreographed and hints at the many layers of thought and meaning contained in the novel and inherent in the complicated relationships that define us as human beings.

I couldn't finish this book, no matter how hard I tried. And, I *always* finish a book. I think Professor Gilligan should stick with her academic work and leave fictional writing to others

After finishing this book, I can understand the mixed reviews. Although this book is said to be a love story, I found the love story relationship part of the story boring. The author spent way too much time detailing each person's career. Their jobs certainly were unique, just not very interesting and at times I really struggled to not chuck the book. The storyline that kept me going was the relationship between Kyra and her therapist. I also really enjoyed Kyra's other relationships with her women friends and sister. That part of the book was really great and complex. Those themes were more universal and I could really relate to them.

This book was a contradiction -- it was well-written, but boring at the same time. This book dealt with some big topics, mostly the loss of loved ones, making it difficult to move on with life. Kyra is dealing with all of these issues and they are affecting her life, still, ten years later.

The book was a slow, thoughtful read, which is probably what made it boring, but there was so much potential to have a really powerful story. Like I said, a contradiction. I had trouble getting through the book, but was kind of intrigued, but bored at the same time.

Carol Gilligan is an exceptional writer, however, I think her writing style might work better in psychology texts rather than novels.

The book's dullness and heavy language put me asleep repeatedly. I did not like it. I left it in the seat pocket of a airplane on purpose. Hopefully it will help someone else go to sleep.