Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Same book as Slip of the Knife, April 5, 2009
For those seeking all of Denise Mina's books, Slip of the Knife and The Last Breath are the same. So too are Sanctum and Deception. Apparently she publishes with different titles in Great Britain vs. USA.
Ms. Mina has two series with plucky female protagonists and gritty plots. All her books show respect for the reader and reward us with intelligence, intensity, and some humor. The first - "Garnethill Trilogy" - might seem a tough slam with a background of sexual abuse, exploitation, and betrayal mixed with the murders, but the path is wise and her "Resolution" includes, thank goodness, some redemption by the end (well, and some more killing.)
The second series is more accessible with a less troubled lead in Paddy Meehan. However, in all her writing Ms. Mina is tough and she expects us to be as well.
The novel Deception (Sanctum) stands independently. It is presented as journal entries, and we decide whether they are accurate. It is perhaps more a tour de force than a treat.
The voices are Scottish with rolling vowels and twirling consonants. The city of Glasgow breathes fog and ice and steam, presenting tenements and alleyways that threaten and beckon. Denise Mina gives us biting fiction.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Last Breath by Denise Mina, June 5, 2008
This is the third of Denise Mina's novels to feature Paddy Meehan, the feisty reporter first introduced in `The Field of Blood'. We rejoin Paddy in 1990 where she is now a leading newspaper columnist with a flash car and a flat. Just as Paddy settles down on a Saturday night, intent on relaxing in front of the television in a comfortable pair of pyjamas, a knock on the door changes everything. Terry Patterson, her first lover and journalistic hero, has been found naked and executed in a ditch.
Who killed Terry and why? Paddy has been named as his next of kin, and he has left her everything in his will. Paddy believes that the answer to his murder is contained in his past and as she seeks to unravel the case, she realises that she and those closest to her are also in danger.
Paddy Meehan is an unlikely hero. She is brash, abrasive, doggedly determined, likeable and so very human.
While this novel can be read alone, I'd recommend reading the novels in order. The development of Paddy's character in the earlier novels is an important part of the backstory. Many of the other characters have also been introduced in the earlier novels, and their relationships with each other are as much a part of the novel as solving the murder is.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Completely implausible story, February 4, 2010
I was rather let down by this book. Writing is fine, good humor, nice Glasgow atmosphere, descriptions of events fine. But the story... The contradictions kill the joy of the book. The whole premiss for the mystery ** spoiler alert ** is that Paddy is right about who the villain is. But the villain comes to her - first - for no plausible reason - and keeps leading her towards him. Of course, if not there wouldn't be much of a mystery, but it is annoying reading on with so many illogical events. One waits for it to come together meaningfully, but it really doesn't. I'm sorry, but this was a completely implausible story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|