44 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
LG Lotus - Stealth PDA phone, unique offering, January 23, 2009
** UPDATE ** 09/30
Going on 9 months with the phone. Still enjoying it and happy with my decision. There is word of the Lotus 2 (2nd generation) phone coming out sometime in 2010. It's too early to tell how much will have changed from the Lotus 1, but so far word has it that the micro SDHC memory limit has been expanded to 32Gb and the outer screen will be touch sensitive. The touch screen functionality suggests that the inner screen will have this too, but that was not mentioned. In any case, expect the phone to debut sometime in the summer. If you really need a phone right now, you can't go wrong with the Lotus given the extremely attractive discounts going on.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
REVIEW
======
The LG Lotus was introduced in the fall of 2008, to reasonable fanfare and press. But do you hear anything about the Lotus now? Not much, which I find strange because the LG Lotus is such an amazing phone. Maybe the surging popularity of touch screen phones overshadows it?
I bucked the touch screen trend and instead went with an LG Lotus. I had to switch from Verizon to Sprint in order to get it, because US based cellular carriers still impose a carrier lock on most phones and have significant pricing discounts when buying a phone with a plan. At first, I was worried about leaving "American's most reliable network" and sacrificing the "in network" minutes with a few of the people I know... but then I came to realize that Sprint has an excellent network as well. So far in my first few weeks of being on the Sprint network, I've noticed no performance loss.
But back to the phone. This is what attracted me to the Lotus:
1) EXCELLENT QWERTY KEYPAD. I don't like the lack of feedback from a touch screen phone; but you've no choice with it, because that's the main interface you're given (unless you do everything by voice command). On the other hand, the tactile sensation of the Lotus keypad is excellent. I have XL sized hands and have no trouble rapidly "double thumb" typing on the Lotus. I tried the Blackberry Curve and Treo--the Lotus keypad works with fewer typos.
2) SMALL FORM FACTOR. The iPhone, Storm, and Omnia touch screen style phones are all quite large and a bit weighty. They don't fit comfortably in your pocket, especially if you've got it in a case to avoid screen scratches. But the Lotus disappears in your pocket. Even in a shirt pocket, it is unobtrusive. When folded, the inner screen and keyboard are fully protected. Yet, when you open it up, the size is doubled and it is easy to hold. THIS is what cellular communications should be all about. I've tried out the Motorola RAZR and I'd say the Lotus is about the same thickness but easier to hold. Overall, the design of the Lotus is very unusual. When opened, it almost looks like a miniature laptop! :-)
3) SEMI-SMART PHONE. What does it take for a cellular phone to be called a Smart Phone? "There is no agreement in the industry about what a smartphone actually is and definitions have changed over time." The Lotus supports Java applications, can browse the web, download files, exchange e-mail (when connected, e-mail is pushed to the phone), and work as a GPS device. This certainly sounds smart to me. Aside from the default browser, you can download others (like the Opera Mini) and even use a GMail application instead of going through the HTML interface. I'm sure as time goes on, the list of compatible Java apps for the Lotus will increase.
4) PLAN VERSATILITY. With smart phones like the iPhone, Storm, and Omnia, you MUST have a data plan. With the Lotus, you can choose whether or not you want a data plan. Plus, on Sprint, you can do this change mid-stream on your contract without incurring costs or contract change penalties (the countdown to expiration remains unchanged). I find this an attractive advantage over the competition.
5) SCREEN RESOLUTION. The inner screen of the Lotus is 2.5" diagonal. It is a beautiful wide screen that looks like one you'd see on a quality digital camera. The resolution is SUPERB. Pictures appear razor sharp and in full accurate color. Even the external screen looks great, and you can choose not only a few different clock layouts but a different wallpaper from the internal screen.
6) MENU SYSTEM. The default "Carousel" style menu system is actually very nice. It is customizable and provides very easy access to popular functions of the phone. It is great for novices but a little annoying for the technically adept. However, you can dispense with it and go with the LG menu system. With the help of a Sprint store rep, you can get the default LG menu activated (or if you know your MSL number, you can do it yourself). I prefer the LG menu as it removes the Carousel clutter (if the menu would auto-hide, I'd like it more) so you can see your wallpaper image in all its glory. Plus, you go from 5 to 12 favorites (shortcuts), something I really appreciate. Not only that, but the left menu button becomes a quick access link to the Calendar/Scheduler, instead of it being hidden behind a carousel tile you have to hunt for. Supposedly, going with the LG menu saves you some battery life, too.
7) NO THEFT MAGNET. Large and glamorous PDA phones are a theft magnet, especially the coveted iPhone. Personally, I find the idea of constantly whipping out an expensive device increases the chance for damage (who here hasn't dropped a phone at least once on a hard surface?) and involuntary loss due to theft. The Lotus is nicely inconspicuous (especially the black version).
8) MUSIC PLAYBACK QUALITY. The built in music player is a little cumbersome at first, in that upon initial insertion of the SD card, it scans all of your music and creates an internal index. But once that index is created, it is quick and easy to play music selections by "All Songs", "Artists", "Genres", and "Albums". Plus you can create your own playlists, as well as use random or sequential play by Genre, Artist, and All Songs. A very nice attribute for the way the SD card is used is that you can subdivide your music by whatever folders you want--the Lotus scans the card and finds them, rather than requiring all songs to be in one folder. Sound quality is impressive, although for this small size the bass is lacking. But mids and highs are clear and accurate. I couldn't believe what I was able to hear... better than the iPod earbuds, that's for certain. Plus, it has a 2.5mm jack so you can plug in earbuds if you wish to listen privately. Bluetooth headsets are also supported.
9) EXCELLENT GPS SOFTWARE. I was about to buy a Garmin Nuvi 255w. But now, I don't have to. The Sprint GPS Navigator is excellent! It really works. Plus, it's full featured. You get horizon view and bird's eye view, turn-by-turn voice navigation with street names, easily stored favorites, and interfacing with Google maps. It also audibly informs you about traffic conditions. What more could you want?
10) DECENT CAMERA. A 2.0 megapixel camera sounds passe, when 3.2 and 5.0 cellphone cameras are available. Well, I don't know what firmware LG put in this phone, but this is the best 2.0 megapixel camera I've ever seen. I'd swear it was 3.0 megapixel. Photos are of very high quality. It works OK in low light if the subject remains still. There is NO flash, unfortunately. I wouldn't use this over a full fledged digital camera, but it makes for an excellent backup.
11) OBVIOUS CHARGING INDICATOR. On many phones, you need to look at the LCD screen to see a message that charging is complete or that the battery indicator is now on full. With the Lotus, the external music controls are lit up red when charging is taking place, but change to white once charging is finished--quite obvious to notice from a distance, which is very convenient.
12) MINI USB CONNECTOR. The mini USB connector works very well with this phone, sliding into place securely. And now there are vendors supplying car chargers with retractable cords that work with the Lotus. It's an excellent solution for convenient charging on the go with no cords to hassle with.
OTHERS - the phone has 5 alarm settings, one "quick alarm" and 4 main ones that you can set for whatever period you need (once, daily, weekly, monthly) and with whatever sound you want (default or downloaded). There is even a feature that allows you to record a phone call--not bad.
So, those are the things I really like about the Lotus. But alas, no phone is perfect. Here is what I see needing improvement:
1) VOICE QUALITY. During calls, voices are projected through an internal speaker on the lid. Depending on the party reached, some calls sound a little flat and tinny on high volume. This is in contrast to the excellent voice quality I had on a Motorola E815. Now, it's not so bad that it is a deal breaker, but I wish it was a little better. If you're in a noisy room and crank up the volume, you'll be a bit disappointed. I tend to keep the volume set to about the mid-point. Using an ear set works well, as an alternative. In fact, at home I plug in a wired ear set and it works beautifully. I tuck the phone in my pocket and walk around hands free. The speakerphone quality is excellent, though.
2) BATTERY LIFE. If you leave your phone connected to the Internet most of the time, you'll probably need to recharge your phone daily. But if you shut off the Internet connection when not in use, battery life should be about average for standby and talk time. The Lotus is rated at 5.5 hours, but I'd say it's just about 3 hours. Most phone manufacturers exaggerate their talk time anyway. My last phone was supposed to be 3 hours but it was more like 2. The...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Cool phone but correctable shortcomings make it a tough sell., May 18, 2009
I have been using this phone for several weeks now. I will refrain from repeating much of what others say and focus instead on a few more obscure but very important issues I have noticed. If you rely heavily on any of the features mentioned below, you might want to consider these points...
1. Audio quality:
This phone's audio is not as good as the last few phones I've owned (Rumor, Razr, others). Callers sound muddled, and if you're talking to someone who is mumbly at all, or is not talking directly into their mouthpiece, it is difficult to understand their words.
On the plus side, this phone has an earpiece that is very easy to position properly over your ear, and you can feel it when it's not positioned right. With the Rumor I was constantly moving it around trying to mate the speaker with my ear.
Speakerphone on this phone is a significant improvement over the Rumor which sounded distorted at any volume loud or soft.
One other auditory note... there doesn't seem to be a way to turn off the power-up and power-down songs it plays (ostensibly to congratulate itself for taking a long time to follow your instructions). This is extremely annoying in situations when you remember to turn off the phone after the class or meeting starts... there's no way to turn it off silently (even if you turn the volume all they way to silent, it still plays a song). I've never had a phone before that didn't let you silence those permanently.
2. User Interface:
It is frustrating for several reasons, mostly it's lack of customizability. The carousel system might please you if you like icon menus, but I prefer text-style menus and that's not an option on this phone. They say you can add custom items to the carousel, but that's sort of a misnomer. You can add a limited selection of 'features' to the carousel--mostly data-gathering web features like weather reports and stock tickers--it's a very limited list of pre-chosen items, you can't make up your own, and you can't add menu items. If you want quick access to a menu item (such as the calculator, note pad, or alarm clock) you can add it to the 'shortcuts' carousel item which puts it in sort of a quick-menu, but and it's limited to five items. Older LG phones allowed you to program one-touch buttons (usualy the 4-way arrow keys) but this phone has no one-touch buttons you can customize. Everything's done through the carousel which isn't any easier than finding stuff in menus so I'm not sure what the point is. And its very confusing to figure out how to customize it. It's not intuitive at all.
By the way, this carousel menu system is Sprint's proprietary user interface which they have forced all their non-smart phones to use, regardless of manufacturer. It's their attempt to brand all the phones with universal Sprint interface. So it appears that the old days of variety are over. It used to be that the different manufacturers did their software differently so if you didn't like one brand's interface, another brand might work better for you. Now they all have the same interface so you're stuck with it unless you want to switch carriers. There is a way around this if you're comfortable doing a little hacking. A program called "CDMA" can help you revert back to the phone's native user interface (very similar to what it comes with only the carousel one-click system will be gone). Browse the sprint user forums for more info, I did it and I like it much better without the carousel.
3. Charger/USB interface:
As unforgivable as this has always been, this phone uses YET ANOTHER new kind of charger/usb connector, so you have to go out and buy new chargers AGAIN. The B Micro-usb connector is gaining popularity though, so perhaps it will be somewhat standardized, but I'm not hopeful. I think there's just too much money to be made on needlessly (and wastefully) replacing all those components with every new phone--especially at $35 each in the Sprint store. Be sure you buy those items ANYWHERE else for at least 75% savings.
On the plus side, the charger that comes with this phone is simply a usb cord with a power supply that has a usb connector on it. So you can disconnect the cord from the charger and connect it to a computer for charging. I love this. I bought an 18" usb cord so I can use this charger on the kitchen counter without an annoying coil of wire to contend with.
4. Keyboard & Buttons:
The keyboard on this phone is great. Nice sized buttons and they're nicely rounded such that it's very easy to type on. I can type one-handed quite easily on this phone which was nearly possible on the Rumor. I still wish it had dedicated number buttons but apparently that's too much to ask. The dedicated 'text' button is a nice feature, it brings you right to the 'send a text message' screen. It's pretty much the only one-touch feature button on the phone aside from the camera button which seems to always get pressed by accident. I am not a fan of putting buttons on the sides of the phone where you're supposed to be holding on to it.
5. Screens/Backgrounds/Pictures.
Screen visibility in most features is very poor outdoors. Aside from the text message screen and note pad (which are black-on-white) nearly every screen is white(or another color)-on-black making it very hard to see in sunlight.
There is no option to have a blank background on the phone's screen. You're forced to use an image, and the pre-installed pics are crap. It's quite comical actually, the background pictures for the external screen are all so detailed that they obscure the clock from being readable. I ended up using the built-in camera to take a picture of a blank surface and I use that as the background picture.
Another oddity... similar to the Rumor, if you assign a picture to a phone number so it can show you a picture of who is calling, it overlays a text box on top of the picture so you can't see it anyway except for what's visible around the edge. (WTF, does anybody at the factory actually USE these things before they send them out to market?)
6. Alarm Clock:
While a standard feature on most phones nowadays, this one is quite crippled. The completely unforgivable oversight (which was also a problem on the Rumor) is that if you miss an alarm it does not show up on the missed alerts list. This is especially bad for me because I use it as a medication reminder, and if I leave the phone in the other room and I don't hear it ringing before it turns off on its own after a few minutes, I have no idea that i've missed it.
Also, if you press snooze to silence it temporarily, there is absolutely no way to deactivate it until it rings again (aside from going to the alarm clock menu and deleting the alarm).
A nice touch would be to have the default time for the alarm be the last time used, but instead it always defaults to 9:30 am. Extra hassle.
7. Text Messaging:
Here's a really nice feature of this phone (really the sprint interface, one of the few benefits)... text messages are organized into threads by recipient/sender, so if you're having a conversation with someone, it shows all the messages (both sent and received) in a single list in chronological order. So you can see the full conversation without having to switch between the inbox and sent folders. Great improvement. It takes some getting used to, but I like it.
8. Speed-dial/Contacts list:
Nobody does this better, but it's worth mentioning... why limit the one-touch press-and-hold speed dial buttons to just the number keys? With all those letter buttons, it seems you ought to be able to assign a speed dial number to any of them. I would love to program 'mom' to the M button for example, but you can't on this user interface. I suspect this is just a paradigm shift that phone makers haven't caught up to yet. They're still thinking as though there are only 12 buttons on the phone.
Another speed dial issue with this sprint interface (although my old Rumor had the same shortcoming)... when you press the speed dial button the only option is to call the default number for that person. My sanyo and samsung phones in the past have allowed you to press the button briefly to bring up the person's contacts entry, then use the L/R arrow buttons to scroll through that persons various numbers to choose the one you want to call. That feature is missing on this phone so if I want quick access to my wife's cell number and work number, I have to assign each to its own speed dial number (further reinforcing the need to allow speed dial programming of the letter keys).
9. Phone body:
Sadly this phone has fallen prey to our modern addiction to rubberized grippy surfaces. The exterior surface is coated with sticky junk so it clings to your pocket and does not slide in or out easily. Luckily it's only mildly grippy so it's not as bad as some other phones, but I find this stuff completely unnecessary and it actually makes the phone harder to use. Ugh.
10. Web browser:
Now this is the killer issue that truly ruins this phone. The browser offers absolutely no capability to scroll sideways or zoom out, which makes it completely useless. When looking at a web page that isn't specifically designed for use on mobile phones (so pretty much everything except facebook), you can only see a small strip of the left side of the page... everything to the right just disappears off the screen and there's no way to go look at it. The up/down arrow buttons scroll the screen vertically, so you would think the left/right arrow buttons would allow you to scroll horizontally, but no. Seriously? Who in their right mind thought that was an acceptable...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No