Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Ending needs revision..., July 21, 2001
This review is from: Lady of Conquest (Mass Market Paperback)
I honestly didn't know how to rate this book in the beginning. After the book ended, I didn't even know whether I liked it or not. Thing is, I had to read this book twice in order to get a proper conclusion. Then, I realized it isn't an awful read to deserve lower than 2 stars nor was it a "so-so-not-bad" kind of book to deserve a 3 stars either. I admit, I particularly didn't like the ending of this book. I would have love to see Conn proved his trust, begged or perhaps even 'ask' Gelina for forgiveness and acceptance with more effort, depth and passion. I didn't appreciate the idea of someone as strong-headed and strong-willed as Gelina to simply fall over and forgive after hearing a sweet one-liner from Conn's lips! The Epilogue didn't help much either. Perhaps the ending should be revised. Anyway, The initial plot of this book is a LOVE/HATE relationship. To be honest, it kindda make u feel the same way about the whole story in general too. Conn and Gelina's relationship was melancholy yet luring and intriguing. Heart rending, relief and more heart wretching all throughout the book. What Gelina went through in the hands of Conn-her martyrdom, her confusions, her courage and her love & hatred! She is brave yet she isn't afraid to cry also. That makes her more human in my eyes. I really like her. Conn did a lot of awful things to Gelina that makes my heart ache but then again, she also did her share to infuriate even a Saint. A man's pride, honor and ego can only take so much of a blow! Conn actually did give her chances but then Gelina's young, not to mention that she was shaped to hate Conn from an early age. How can one differentiate love from hatred when both is felt and given in extreme passion? ugh, totally frustrating. A very emotional read. So perhaps this is why I rated this book a 4 stars in the end. I had conflicting emotions, conflicting opinions of this book. It made me think about it even after it was put down. When I was ready to write my review, I read here that there is indeed a lot of controversy about this book. Some hate it, some love it. If an author can pull readers together this way, I say it deserve a higher rating. If not for the abrupt ending, I would have rated this "one of a kind" book a fiver. This is only my third book of Teresa Medeiros but I will most definitely read more of her works. The Ireland setting in this book also piqued my curiosity since most of the historical romance books I've read are in Scotland/Highland-England settings. This love/hate relationship in an Ireland setting was a distinctive and a refreshing change. I like it, so... TRY this book. I won't guarantee that you will find it as I see it but then again you might even enjoy it more than I have. This book is not for everyone. It's all a matter of taste and preferences.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Follow up after reading all the other reviews, January 15, 2003
This review is from: Lady of Conquest (Mass Market Paperback)
Ok, I read all 43 reviews and I'm not sure anymore that we were all reading the same book, excatly when was there love in this book? The hero was abusive, and yes the heroine was a little flighty but she was like 14 at first, its understandable. I honestly did not see love in it, Conn is nice to gelina like one time when she is still his foster daughetr and thats it. I had to add this review because reading that so many people thought the book was fantastic and touching and breathtaking, etc. seriously worries me. Do that many women in this country think that abuse equals love? I've read hundreds (if not more) of romances, and ive seen almost everytime of relationship possible, and never has a hero been as abusive to the heroine. I mean the man raped her REPEATEDLY!! If you liked the book because you couldn't stop reading it, tyhen sure, I couldn't stop reading it either, but if you think that is love, then I'm really worried for you. And finally, rape has no place in romance, it is one of the worst crimes, if not the worst, perpetrated against women, and the impression on the victim lasts forvever. Obviously the authors that incorporate it in their books have never experienced it themselves, those who actually had I'm sure would not so trivialize it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
reluctantly drawn, August 16, 2002
This review is from: Lady of Conquest (Mass Market Paperback)
While Medeiros is my favorite writer of romance and generally excellent historical fiction, this book left me with a bad taste in my mouth and a fear of ever being as "in love" as these two characters. This book shows a classic example of a horribly abusive mean-spirited relationship. While these two could have had a good relationship, the choices they made and the truly intense hatred they show for one and other would make me want to end up far from seeing them written into a lasting love. I wouldn't wish their brand of love on my worst enemy. Violence reigns in their story. I would never reread it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|