80 of 84 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Comprehensive Overview of the Healthcare Bill, May 24, 2010
This review is from: Landmark: The Inside Story of America's New Health Care Law and What It Means for Us All (Publicaffairs Reports) (Paperback)
I'm a family physician that has followed the healthcare reform debate closely, dating well back into the Democratic primary season when Hillary and Obama were duking it out, dating even as far back as the failed Bill and Hillary Clinton first attempt during Bill Clinton's presidency. I found Landmark: The Inside Story of America's New Health Care Law to give a much richer historical perspective, and to give a much better analysis of the actual impact that the bill is likely to have, than was available from the fragmented and sensational mainstream media coverage.
The book is a collection of essays written by Washington Post reporters, followed by the actual text of the bill. The essays in the book are far more analytical and informative than what was typically available throughout the somewhat histrionic coverage of Republican and Democratic maneuvering to respectively block or pass the eventual bill. One could have been left with the impression, when it was all over but the shouting, that the resulting bill was weakened to the point of being inconsequential from the point of view of reform, and enormous regarding eventual cost. Read Landmark, and you'll have a different opinion on both those points.
What was useful in the book? The many failed historical efforts to provide some form of national healthcare coverage go back over 100 years, a battle that until this last month stymied many presidents (including Teddy Roosevelt). The historical review alone made the book a worthwhile read for me. Secondly, the authors make a convincing case that, much in contrast to the typical media coverage, this bill represents a deep and broad change in the American approach to healthcare for its citizens, far more so than the Medicare and Medicaid legislation. After reading the essays, and even more powerfully after reading the actual legislation, I'm convinced that the authors are correct. Why? Though it is true that the bill is corrupted in places by special interests, and weakened by the deletions forced by political compromise, it also becomes clear that through a combination of fiat and incentive the new healthcare law will, for better or for worse, markedly change the way doctors/providers do business, and how their patients/clients experience their healthcare.
Fiats? No exclusion for pre-existing conditions, no excisions from insurance because you actually USE what you've purchased, no lifetime limits on coverage just because you actually got sick. Incentives? Buried in the legislation itself is a long list of encouragements to do what amounts to serious R & D (research and development) in methods to improve American health, and to treat American illness. In a country where 85% of health related research is done by notoriously biased private industry (the reverse of the ratio in Europe), creating conditions more amenable to less biased scientific research is a welcome and little discussed part of bill. Creating incentives for physicians/providers to focus on quality will change what you experience when you go in for healthcare, and this book details what you will be seeing change over the next few years.
As a socially liberal, financially conservative physician (voted for Reagan, actually went to his inaugural parade) my bottom line about Landmark is this: whether you love or hate the bill, your perspective on it will be different, and better balanced, when you are done reading it. Your ability to discuss the bill accurately will be significantly enhanced, as I've already found out on multiple occasions when confronted with nonsense statements from both the left and the right. If you wish to consider yourself informed on the Healthcare Reform Bill, this book will go a long way to getting you there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Research and Expanation of the New Health Care Law, May 24, 2010
This review is from: Landmark: The Inside Story of America's New Health Care Law and What It Means for Us All (Publicaffairs Reports) (Paperback)
This book gives the history of the work put into the passing of the new health care bill. Then it goes into explanations of how the new law works and tells the good and bad of each segment. Each writter put their own knowledge and research into their part of the book. It made me look at the new law with a more open and optimistic mind.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
28 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting, but nothing new, May 12, 2010
Much of this book is simply a summary of the events surrounding the passage of the health care legislation. There's not much new in the way of "insider" accounts (those books are forthcoming, I'm sure), and what appear to be enlightening passages is simply rehashed conventional wisdom (Rahm Emanuel like to curse, we get it). For people that didn't follow the process as it unfolded over the past year and half, this part of the book should prove interesting. The real utility of the book is its comprehensive summary of what's in the legislation and how it will affect different people.
I do have one major technical issue with formatting of the Kindle edition. The entire book is presented in brief one- or two-sentence paragraphs (much like a newspaper article) with a space between each paragraph. The spaces are very distracting, as if I'm reading a bullet list rather than a cohesive, flowing narrative. It makes for very halting, choppy reading.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
