From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 2-Samuel Moss, a 12th-generation Grizzly Scout, wants to earn his place in his family's Album of Scouting Greatness (you have to be in it to even look at it). He has his badges for ninja training, thermonuclear dynamics, Bigfoot tracking, and a host of others, but now he must earn his Moon Frog badge. The problem is that the Moon Frog hibernates for 30 years, only appearing in the open on the 12th hour of the 10th night of the 8th month. Predictably, his father helps him on his frantic race against time to meet his deadline, allowing the boy to learn a valuable lesson along the way. The mixed-media illustrations border on the busy side, but they are funny, and young readers will warm up to Sam and his quest to become part of his family's legacy.
-Lisa Gangemi Kropp, Middle Country Public Library, Centereach, NY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 1-3. The near-cultish aura surrounding certain kids' activities is gently mocked in McClements' second picture book. Grizzly Scout Samuel longs to earn the never-before-conferred Moon Frog Badge and secure his place in his family's Album of Scouting Greatness. After intensive research into "alignment angles and . . . moonbeam refractions," Samuel sets off with gung-ho Dad to capture the rare creature on film. When it occurs to Samuel that curiosity seekers and prying scientists are likely to disturb the frog once its discovery has been publicized, he selflessly opts to keep his achievement a secret--a decision that his father greets with a secret of his own. Neither text nor McClements' collage artwork is quite polished enough to distract from the sheer silliness of the plot. Even so, kids (and parents) familiar with scouting's seemingly arcane requirements for advancement will recognize the truth in the broad comedy and will particularly chuckle over Samuel's collection of badges memorializing everything from burping the alphabet to thermonuclear dynamics.
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved