Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
No clean shots and meaningful last words., December 1, 2003
This review is from: Last Citadel: A Novel of the Battle of Kursk (Hardcover)
This is an extremely well written work. Like the British historian-novelist David Howarth, David Robbins is able to take an enormous yet isolated incident and wrap it around three separate stories, a Spanish officer in the German Panzer Division trying to recapture his dignity after a near fatal shooting the year before, a young Russian woman trying to find her pilot lover shot down behind enemy lines, and a father and son on both sides of Russian Communism incarcerated in tight, hellish quarters in a Russian T-34 Tank during the Battle of Kursk in July of 1943. All this unfolds in the largest tank battle ever culminating with the American invasion of Sicily on July 11, 1943. You don't have to be a WWII buff to be thoroughly mesmerized by this book, but as in reading an Alan Furst novel, it helps. Professor Robbins deftly paints an accurate view of Hitler's last stand in Russia after the savage defeat of the Germans at Stalingrad, rolling the dice before the Americans enter the war in Europe, thereby turning his near impossible two front war into the resulting three front war. Yet Robbins does this with beautiful writing. At one point he describes a train station where a passenger train lays in wait while tracks are replaced from a bombing 12 hours earlier: "It had no roof left, just scored beams, and it's sills were marred with brows of soot." Later Katya, about whom one of the stories revolves, awakens before her night mission as some other aircraft take off. "Once they took off [she] listened to the silence return . . . serrated only by crickets and a mechanic hammering at something stubborn." While telling his stories the description of the battle takes on a more vivid meaning as the reader has humans to appreciate as Churchill wrote, 'their blood, sweat and tears.' An excellent novel. Rarely are we so intrigued about historical events that involve no Americans, on a plain in the Ukraine we never heard of, with the names of players for the most part we can't pronounce. Kudos to David Robbins. 5 stars. Easily 6 or 7. Larry Scantlebury
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
another fine WW II novel from this author, August 30, 2003
This review is from: Last Citadel: A Novel of the Battle of Kursk (Hardcover)
This has a flavor similar to that of the author's excellent War of the Rats. As with Rats, the chapters switch back and forth between Russian protagonists (a T-34 tank driver, his sons who commands the tank, his daughter who is a pilot) and two Germans (an intelligence officer and a tank captain--who is actually a Spaniard). As with Rats, or Len Deighton's Bomber, there is a good amount of technical detail--particularly regarding the T-34 and Tiger tanks--design strengths and flaws, what it's like to be in one, and this adds a lot to the novel. Too many war novels like to employ the device of having an evil antagonist--someone who relishes torturing prisoners, etc, and who gets his comeuppance in the end. Neither Rats nor this novel use this device, thank goodness. Engrossing and well- written!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant novel, August 19, 2003
This review is from: Last Citadel: A Novel of the Battle of Kursk (Hardcover)
David Robbins' Last Citadel is one of the most compelling, exciting and impressive novels I've read in years. I can't remember the last time I read a book like this, one I literally couldn't put down. The epic backdrop of the battle for Kursk - where Soviet Russia and Nazi Germany engaged in history's largest and bloodiest battle - serves as an unforgettable stage, meticulously researched and panoramically rendered. Amazingly, the intense conflicts of the novel's characters exist larger than the titanic clash playing out behind them. Dimitri Berko, once a Cossack, now drives a Russian tank alongside his Communist son, still trying to teach a young man who no longer thinks he needs the wisdom of his father, hoping for one final chance of communion before the two of them face almost certain death. At the same time, Dimitri's daughter, Katya, guides Russian bombers to German targets, a "Night Witch" circling overhead. The stakes couldn't be higher for this family at war. Luis De Vega, the Spanish bullfighter commanding Germany's invincible Tiger tank, rolls closer and closer to Dimitri and Valentin, seething from past wounds, more dangerous than the stabbed bulls he once drove to the ground. The complexity of Abram Breit, a Nazi SS officer turned spy for the Russians, is particularly striking - a man who sees his apocalyptic world reflected in the work of the Cubist painters of his time, broken down into key universal elements that transcend both war and politics. The last battle scene is absolutely riveting, in itself worth the price of admission. The Last Citadel is a grand-slam novel, perfect.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|