Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Study of the Peter Principle, March 30, 2009
This review is from: The Last Confederate General: John C. Vaughn and His East Tennessee Cavalry (Hardcover)
I have read a lot of Civil War Histories, but The Last Confederate General provides a different perspective. First, it is well researched and well written. (OK, that is not a different perspective.) Second, it looks at a leader who never made it into our history books until Larry Gordon decided to write about Brigadier General John Vaughn. Most Civil War histories ignore Vaughn and concentrate on Grant, Lee, Jackson, McClellan and the others we all know. The role of the second level leaders like Vaughn is easy to overlook these days, but back in the 1860s with poor intelligence and poor communications, the ability of all officers to lead their troops was probably more important than today. While the top leaders in war or business are important, having competent second level leaders is necessary. I wish Gordan had explored that more.
Some have said that Vaughn was basically an incompetent, but Gordon shows him to be a better--but flawed leader than that simple assessment. Vaughn was a great example of someone who was elected colonel by the volunteers that he recruited. He led them well and was promoted over his head to the rank of brigadier general. Vaughn had no training as an officer, but he made the best of what he knew. He never learned how to command a brigade effectively...how to get ammunition, food, transportation, strategy, tactics, and those other details that can win the battle. Gordon tells the story of the various battles that Vaughn was with and makes them very interesting.
The Last Confederate General brings out the atmosphere in a border state. There was no law and order. Union and Confederate supporters tried to burn down each others homes. Civilians were physically attacked for their political beliefs. Vaughn's family was arrested by the Union and sent to prison for their/his support of the Confederacy. I wish Gordon had explored the conditions back home more.
Another interesting question that Gordon could have explored more is how generals learn their craft. Vaughn never went to West Point. Maybe if he had like Lee and many of the other successful leaders on both sides, he would have been able to succeed, but for many of us learning by doing makes it difficult to expand on the lessons that we should have learned. Of course many incompetent generals in the Civil War went to West Point (and more recently).
So Vaughn was an example of the Peter Principle: someone who was good as a colonel, and was promoted over his head.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Last Confederate General, March 29, 2009
This review is from: The Last Confederate General: John C. Vaughn and His East Tennessee Cavalry (Hardcover)
I've just finished reading Mr. Gordon's book "The Last Confederate General" and found it to be very well written. Mr. Gordon covers General Vaughn's prewar life in East Tennessee to his service during the Mexican War. During the Civil War, the reader follows Vaughn as he recruits troops for his regiment, later to be designated the 3rd TN Infantry. During the Battle of First Manassas, Vaughn and his regiment distinguished themselves very well, and from that point, we follow Vaughn as he is promoted to brigadier general, and commands a brigade in Mississippi during the Vicksburg Campaign.
After the Vicksburg surrender, and when Vaughn and his brigade is paroled, he mounts his brigade and serves in East Tennessee fighting lawless bushwhackers, and Federal troops in the area. Late in the war, part of Vaughn's brigade serves in Virginia and later returns to East Tennessee. After the fall of Richmond, and Lee's surrender, General Vaughn escorts Jefferson Davis as he attempts to flee Federal authorities.
After the war, Vaughn settles in Thomaston, Georgia where he eventually remarries after the death of his first wife. He briefly returns to East Tennessee to serve in the state legislature, but prior to his death returns to Thomaston. In my opinion, this is a very well written book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Last Confederate General: John C. Vaughn and His East Tennessee Cavalry, By Anthony F. Gaudiano, March 21, 2009
This review is from: The Last Confederate General: John C. Vaughn and His East Tennessee Cavalry (Hardcover)
I have just finished reading "The Last Confederate General" by Larry Gordon. Before writing this review, I looked for reviews that others had written about Gordon's work. The only review that I found was by Charles B. Sabin. I will not go into the intricate depths of the book, as did Sabin, for I do not possess his eloquence, or his apparent knowledge of military history. I suggest that you read his review for a thoroughly factual appraisal of Gordon's work from a military historian's point of view.
Larry Gordon's opus is as thrilling to me, a military historian "want-to-be", as the many Shaara' works that I have read. But Gordon's tome is totally factual, not laced with smatterings of what I perceive to be author's prerogative, as are much of the Shaara books. While most of my interest in military history has involved World War II and also the battles for Texas Independence, I have also read a great deal about the War Between the States. However, my interest in the War Between the States had previously only followed the major battles, and the notable Generals that fought them. Having early in my military career visited Gettysburg and Antietam (later in life to Appomattox and Manassas); my interests were based around the battles fought in these geographic areas. Until Gordon's book, I gave little thought to East Tennessee, and do not recall previously reading about John Crawford Vaughn.
One of the things that the book's jacket describes about Larry Gordon is that "he has long been a park volunteer at Manassas National Battlefield." I have been on a tour of Manassas Battlefield with Gordon as my guide. His narration of the battles at Manassas (First and Second) gives you the feeling that you are there at the time of the conflicts. You can readily visualize CSA Brigadier General Bernard Bee rallying his troops by pointing toward General Thomas J. Jackson, and saying, "There stands Jackson like a stonewall!" My interaction with Gordon, and his in-depth knowledge of the Manassas battles piqued my interest to purchase and read "The Last Confederate General: John C. Vaughn and His East Tennessee Cavalry". I was not disappointed.
Kudos to Larry Gordon for writing a very well researched and finely presented piece of military history. I especially appreciated the interweaving of Vaughn's personal life with his military prowess ... or lack thereof.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|