Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Move it to the Children's Section?, July 16, 2006
This book is another in a series of novels which use a conspiring church as the backdrop for their plot. In a sense, another attmept at da Vinci Code, perhaps inspired by the Code's phenomenal success. The author also uses more or less the same formula: a ghastly event at a museum, an attractive female archaeologist, a straight male companion (this time an FBI detective), a wicked priest(?), and a deadly church secret in the background. Some of the touches that the author uses are an improvment on Dan Brown. For instance, there is a philosophical duel between faith and ratinality that the FBI detective fights within himself. Similarly, the initial scene about the museum robbery is quite vivid and spectacular and you can easily visualise the drama that goes on. Instead of being a sample of what is to come, the author gets a little lost thereafter, stretching coincidences across two continents, so that they all start looking extremely contrived. Possibly the museum scene comes out so well because Khoury is primarily a screen-writer. In terms of characterisation, the FBI detective comes out very well. Similarly, the older archaelogist comes through with some conviction. The lady archaelogist is done in a weaker manner. However, the weakest work is the priest (?). His motivation, the background to his skills, is never filled in. Therefore, it is more difficult to understand his character. In fact, it may not be easy to figure out whether he was really a priest or a secret agent. Talking of secrets, the Templar secret, over which they are supposed to have blackmailed the Church, itself comes out as a bit of a disappointment. The ending is interesting, in the sense that it is not anti-faith, but is somewhat disappointing, because the build-up is weak. The weakest part of the book is the plot, which is full of unbeliveable coincidences. In Angels and Demons, Dan Brown does some manipulation of laws of probability to accomodate the development of his plot. In this book, Raymond Khoury simply assumes that no such laws exist. He also ignores how the US Government works (brining a priest into FBI meetings, and allowing him to dominate the meetings), and how the Vatican works (the link between CIA, the priest and the Vatican is never cleared up). The result is a book which you can enjoy if you treat it as children's fiction.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great basic idea but not what you might expect, July 3, 2006
This review is from: The Last Templar (Paperback)
In 1291 a ship sets sails to escape the defeat of the city Acre (Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem). The Knights Templar on board are to protect the secret they carry with them at all costs. But the ship never reaches its destination. In present day four horsemen dressed as Knights Templar storm the gala opening of an exhibition of Vatican treasures at the Metropolitan Museum in New York. In a bold and bloody attack they steal a medieval decoder and manage to vanish without a trace. FBI agent Sean Reilly and archaeologist Tess Chaykin (also a witness at the scene) team up to solve the centuries-old mystery - always trying to stay ahead of killers who try to protect the secret at all costs for very different reasons... The characters and the (predictable) developing love story in the book are quite good. I also liked the idea to put in some chapters that go back to the Knights Templar's journey in 1291 to give the reader a better idea about what happened back then. But overall the book was not what I expected. 1) I was surprised how easily the FBI traces down 3 of the 4 "Knights Templar" and what they actually are. 2) The identity of the master mind behind the robbery is revealed too soon and also just too "simple". 3) The book then takes off in a completely unexpected direction - chasing down the lost ship. (How they got they idea where to search exactly is still a riddle to me.) Unfortunately this is a very large part of the book and it never gets back into anything that I was hoping for. The book's original idea of a search for bold thieves turns into a deep diving treasure hunt on a different continent which reminded me of a Dirk Pitt adventure (Clive Cussler's books). OK, a different direction as expected does not need to be bad - it might be a positive surprise. But in this case it was not because this part was too long and not that thrilling. And it took the focus of the reader on a completely different area. Unfortunately there are other aspects that spoilt the fun for me: Throughout the book there are just too many coincidences that make the book less and less believable. The wrong person always shows up at exactly the right moment for him to make his move. Therefore the book is kind of unwillingly "funny" or ridiculous sometimes. Te ending was also disappointing to me. Might be because I am not religious but I just wished for something else. (In order not to spoil the fun I cannot reveal more in more detail.) Bottom line: The basic idea of the book starting with the four Knights Templar's very bold robbery at the museum is really good. Also the combination of today's knowledge and the centuries-old mystery made me want to read the book. (Having read several other fiction books about the secrets of the Knights Templar already I just had to know what secret it is here that made the Knights Templar so untouchable and wealthy.) The book is easy to read and entertaining but it won't keep you up all night. And it is not nearly as gripping as e. g. Dan Brown's books. (To compare the skills of these authors seems like a bad joke to me - but some actually did so!)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
"The Last Templar" by Raymond Khoury, July 12, 2009
This review is from: The Last Templar (Paperback)
If you like Dan Brown's "DaVinci Code" & "Angels & Demons", you are surely to like Raymond Khoury's "The Last Templar." The paperback book, while used, was still in pretty good condition and was a reasonable price.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|