| ||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
26 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A dead language? Minime!,
By FrKurt Messick "FrKurt Messick" (Bloomington, IN USA) - See all my reviews (VINE VOICE) (HALL OF FAME REVIEWER) (TOP 500 REVIEWER)
This review is from: Latin for People : Latina Pro Populo (Paperback)
This book, 'Latin for People: Latina pro Populo', is an engaging way of learning the basics of the Latin language. Humez and Humez intersperse history and story with grammar lessons to make them less intimidating and more accessible. Alas, you will still need to learn conjugations and some words (languages are like that, you know), but you will practice on translating such sentences as: An island is not a suitable place for an adulterer. For the record, they do not give advice as to what would be a suitable place.In the chapter entitled 'Mood Music', one learns a bit about pre-Christian Roman music, including the forerunner to our do-re-mi-fa-so-la-ti-do, that being hexachordal ut-re-mi-fa-so-la (the unsingable ut being happily replaced now with the modern do). Other chapters bring in specific topics to deepen the vocabulary and quality of texts as well as explicate grammar points. All the basics of a Latin grammar are included in this brief book, but there is always more to be had. Humez and Humez in the final chapter proceed to give suggestions, which include many of the classics (the Aenied, the Biblia Sacra, Caesar's De Bello Gallico) as well as texts such as Harrington's Medieval Latin. This book certainly contains all the Latin a non-scholar would need, and goes a long way in making one appear much more educated than the average bear (especially if one supplements this with memorised quotations from Winnie Ille Pu!). It also is a good refresher for those of us who did the Latin course with such drier tomes like Wheelock.
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Latin for which people? Not most people.,
By
This review is from: Latin for People : Latina Pro Populo (Paperback)
I'm inclined to like this book, but I really wish I liked it better than I do. The style is breezy and engaging. The background material on language is quite interesting, the grammar explanations are at least entertaining when they aren't outright fascinating. But really, this is no book for the novice who wants to teach himself Latin. It demands either a good teacher or a dimly remembered Latin class. Comments on the back cover ("[they] have fashioned an easy-going and satisfying introduction to the language...") and in the text ("this book is intended as a course in Latin for the nibbler and the glutton alike...") are misleading. This book is no introductory teach yourself Latin text.What's wrong with it as an introductory text? In the first chapter we're given some very interesting history of Latin and the Romance languages, along with the probable pronunciations of the alphabet. These are followed in chapter 2 with all six cases, singular and plural, of first and second declension nouns and the complete declension of adjectives. There's barely a mention of what grammatical function the different cases serve, just occasional comments in passing - e.g., "agricolae is in the dative because the farmer is being given something. Dative comes from the verb "to give," of which dat is a form." Gee, thanks, now I'm ready to use the dative case. Then come the exercises, which show the authors' unfortunate predilection for word play. The reader is trying to get a handle on the declensional patterns of words like "liber" (free) and "malus" (bad), and the exercises use them in the meanings "children," "Bacchus," and "apple." Yes, we've been warned not to confuse the neuter nominative adjective "malum" with "apple," but it's hard on the reader when the authors go all playful on us with those words before we've mastered the basics of declension. I teach Russian from time to time and am well aware of the difficulties of teaching cases and declensions. I think there's a very good reason that most texts present each case on its own, with lots of explanation about its use and exercises to help nail it down. This book doesn't do that. I don't really mind - I already know what the dative case is, thanks - but I have a lot of experience with different languages and a degree in linguistics. People without that experience and without prior exposure to Latin certainly will mind. So if I'm so down on this book, why four stars? Because if we look at it for what it is and not for what it pretends to be, it's really a very good book. It's a refresher course for people who studied Latin, a supplement for Wheelock, a language book for professional and dilettante linguists. And in being those things it's well written and informative. I'm just going to put it aside until I finish Wheelock.
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
definitely not for the novice,
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Latin for People : Latina Pro Populo (Paperback)
The title would lead you to believe that this book is for anyone who wants to get an idea of how Latin works. When you actually read it, you'll see it's really more of a grammar book that quickly explains many major grammar points and lists all declensions, verb conjugations, etc.... For someone who has never studied Latin, the information is not comprehensive enough to really learn it, plus it assumes that you have a pretty good head for grammar in the first place.However, this book is much more useful for someone who has already studied a year or so of Latin and is searching for some non-stuffy explanations and examples of what they have already learned. The authors certainly aim to make these points more fun than authors of traditional textbooks. The problem is that sometimes you need a deeper explanation to really learn a point -- take the subjunctive for example. In my opinion they just gave an overview of the subjuctive which gives the student a rough idea, but to really master the subjunctive, you'd need to see a real list of rules and tenses. My favorite Latin textbook is the Moreland and Fleisher which is the comprehensive version of all Latin syntax and grammar broken up into 18 chapters. This book is a good supplement to a grammar text, but not a replacement for one.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|