Customer Reviews

Lawless Heart [VHS]

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

This is a lovely, touching film about human relationships set in a small English town, where the death of a man sets in motion a number of unpredictable changes in the lives of the man's intimates as well as complete strangers. The plot and characters are actually poorly described in the promotional copy reproduced above in the Editorial Reviews. And certainly the cover photo misrepresents the film entirely. It's not about sexy-looking women taking off their clothes.

The film is really three inter-related stories, each told with a different central character - a brother-in-law of the dead man, a best friend who's returned home after many years, and the dead man's gay lover. Unlike "Rashomon," the stories don't contradict each other. Each, being from another point of view, emphasizes and reveals different things, and they overlap only every now and then. Besides the point that everyone is a walk-on in someone else's life, the film reminds us that what we know about other people is only what's visible, which is limited, but being at the center of their lives doesn't necessarily provide them with privileged insight. All three men, in one way or another, "don't have a clue," as one of them admits.

I loved this film. You sense that it could easily unfold in a multitude of directions, if we could only follow all the characters. Some clever use of props, like a coconut and a silk scarf, weave through a couple of the stories, gradually taking on a significance of their own. But for the characters there is far more ambiguity, which is reflected in the final scene, as they watch a home movie, and we watch their faces, quietly reflecting emotions unknown to each other and that we can only guess.

Stuart has died in a boating accident, leaving his sister Judy (Ellie Haddington) to sort out his money and his lover Nick (Tom Hollander) to manage the restaurant that they owned. Judy's husband Dan (Bill Nighy) wonders if he would be happier if he had an affair, and he wonders what being happier might mean. Nick isn't sure if he should stick around or move to London where he has friends, and he seeks consolation in a dysfunctional but lively woman named Charlie (Sukie Smith). Tim (Douglas Henshall), who was a childhood friend of Stuart's, has returned to town in time for the funeral. Tim has always been an errant hippie of sorts, but now he has found a woman with whom he'd like to settle down, only to find that she loves his adoptive brother David (Stuart Laing).

"Lawless Heart" is a film about relationships and the decisions that they entail, told three times from three different perspectives. My description of the film may make it sound like a soap opera, and perhaps it is in the most basic sense. But "Lawless Heart" is, for the most part, understated and lacks the melodrama of pulp fiction. Tom Hunsinger and Neil Hunter both wrote and directed the film. Their decision to tell the story from three different points of view and through three different experiences sets "Lawless Heart" apart from many other movies that explore interpersonal relationships in that the differences in perspective and what people don't know about one another become central to the film. As soon as we realize that we are seeing the same set of circumstances from a different point of view, the audience focuses on the divergence of the perspectives and looks for new information that might fill in the gaps left by the other perspectives. In this way, "Lawless Heart" engages the audience more than films of this genre generally do. The three different perspectives that we observe are those of Dan, Nick and Tim. The story takes place over the course of a few weeks and focuses on three events: Stuart's funeral, Tim's party, and Judy's birthday. "Lawless Heart" has a nice symmetry, and watching the same three events three times doesn't seem repetitive. Fans of true-to-life films about interpersonal relationships will enjoy "Lawless Heart"'s multi-perspective twist and admirable dramatic performances.

Lawless Hearts is a slick, well-made British soap drama, which is probably most notable for the ingenious way it tells the story. Viewers who like realistic British, character driven drama will like this film, particularly those viewers of the East Enders or Two Thousand Acres of Sky on PBS. Well acted with a story that is told from multiple viewpoints, Lawless Hearts - using the symbols of a coconut, a tacky scarf, and a stolen corkscrew - is a rather bittersweet tale of three very different men who are thrust together after the death of a friend.

Set in a seaside town in England, the deceptively simple story follows the frustrated Dan (Bill Nighy) as he's led to ponder his marriage and life choices after the death of his brother-in-law Stuart. Stuart was a gay restaurateur whose sudden death has sent his friends and family into emotional tailspins. At Stuart's funeral, Dan meets and forms a connection with Corrine (Clementine Celarie), an attractive flower arranger. Tim (Douglas Henshall) is also at the funeral. He's a hippie lay about who has returned after eight years abroad to a lukewarm reception from his family and a possible budding romance. Nick (a marvelous Tom Hollander) is Stuart's lover and business partner, and while waiting for the outcome of Stuart's estate, he befriends Charlie (Sukie Smith), a damaged, spunky woman who helps him grieve and makes him rethink his life.

Stuart's funeral provides the centerpiece for each man's journey as the three men's stories branch out from this central incident. The story constantly shifts perspectives, as we see the same incidents from each man's viewpoint. The search for love and the ability to cope with devastating loss is at the heart of this film. Dan is unfulfilled in his marriage and contemplates having an affair; Tim is disenfranchised from his family, and is desperately searching for love; and Nick - the most complex and fully rounded character - is so emotionally fraught over the loss of his lover and partner, that he can't decide whether to stay where he is or move to London to live.

While each character is faced with the complications of love and loss, Lawless Heart is ultimately about perspective-how each of us sees the world, and how our preoccupation with that view can blind us to the experience of others. The unique story telling structure, which at first might seem gimmicky to some, is actually a really good way to show the intricate points of view, and there is never a scene that is repeated from the same angle.

All the actors are excellent and do a good job of conveying the naturalism of their characters. Tom Hollander is especially good. Family conflict - dealing with monetary inheritance - and also sexual politics are well presented and there's a particularly fanciful moment, when Dan asks Nick whether he's ever been unfaithful in his relationship with Stuart - it's an awkward meeting of the gay and straight worlds. Lawless Heart is a quiet, intimate film, which some viewers unfamiliar with British dramatic realism may find a little dull. The film demands a focused viewing as there are many intricacies, subtleties and symbols which the viewer will need to grasp in order to really appreciate this film as a whole. Mike Leonard January 05.

A tremendous story, set in rural Essex, of the aftermath of a death, seen consecutively through the eyes of three of the characters. First you see it through the Father's eyes, then through the other-half's, and then through a third person, each time seeing the same incidents and scenes from a slightly different perspective and with more becoming apparent - and yet despite it looking at the story three times, it never palls. Some excellent scenery, beautifully filmed, and an insight into how different people get something different out of every situation.

***1/2 "Lawless Heart" feels a bit like a confused mess at the start - until you realize that it is telling the same story from the perspective of three different characters. When the elements begin to fall into place, the film becomes a touching human drama about exactly what the title implies - the inability to make the heart do what one wants it to do.

Written and directed by Tom Hunsinger and Neil Hunter, the film begins at the funeral of a gay man named Stuart who drowned a few days earlier in a boating accident. The story focuses on three of the people closest to him: Nick, Stuart's lover; Dan, Stuart's brother-in-law; and Tim, an old friend of Stuart's who's been off trying to make a success of himself and not doing a very good job of it. Rather than relate the tale in a straightforward, linear fashion, the filmmakers have chosen to employ a multi-level narrative structure, showing us events first from the perspective of one character, then backing up time and showing us them again from the perspective of another. Although the technique is often more distracting and gimmicky than illuminating, the film ultimately becomes a moving study of loss, jealousy, confusion and passion, with each of the film's many characters (not just the three listed) making a memorable mark on our hearts. The movie is helped immeasurably by its highly gifted cast, its complex interplay of character and time, and its understanding that the one thing we can't control is who we care for and who we love. The maturity of the film is evidenced in the fact that each of the characters comes to learn that he must temper his passions if he hopes to get through life with his sense of morality and decency - and his self-respect - intact.

Well written and acted, "Lawless Heart" is a quiet, unassuming film that has some important things to say about The Big Three: life, death and love.

The British version of this DVD comes not only with directors' commentary, but with deleted scenes that are also accompanied by commentary. Why First Look produced such a bare bones DVD when a much more complete one is available is beyond me. If you have a DVD player than can play PAL region 2 DVD's, then you'll want to get this movie elsewhere.

Lawless Heart is a very quiet, contemplative film that deals with the emotional aftermath of losing a loved one. In this case, Nick (Tom Hollander) must sort out his feelings as well as the monetary and family things of coping with the loss of his longtime boyfriend, Stuart.
The order of the day in this film is calm, deeply felt emotion that makes itself known, not through over-the-top crying jags or chest pounding melodrama, but from truthful scenes of regret and fondly recalled memories.

Lawless Hearts plot is revealed through the eyes of three people: the aforementioned Nick and his friends Dan and Tim. This is not a Rashomon style film though, as in that film the same incident is told from several perspectives while in this one, Nick, Dan and Tim recall the road that brings them to and beyond Stuarts funeral. Each story is colored with the indelible stamp of personality and with the same humanity that infuses the entire film.
Directors Tom Hunsinger, Neil Hunter, their screenwriter and actors have created a film filled with hope and respect. And in particular, Tom Hollander as Nick unforgettably manages to weather the emotional storm of the film with grace, humor and compassion despite all the negative baggage that is thrust upon him.

What better location for a story about the intermingled lives of folk who know each other's every move than on the Isle of Man, a flat and lonely appearing extension of the world populated by some very strange but perfectly wonderful characters for this story!

This small town tale written and directed by Tom Hunsinger and Neil Hunter is anything but simple: through kinky flashbacks and flash forwards we see the views of three men responding to the drowning death and funeral of a gay man named Stuart who had been owner of the local restaurant with his lover Nick. Each of the characters is introduced in the opening funeral sequence and just when you think you know them, the vantage changes and previously viewed scenes are further developed from someone else's view.

The deceased Stuart (David Coffey) is survived by his lover Nick (Tom Hollander), his long lost slightly crazy friend Tim (Douglas Henshall) who just happens to surface for the funeral, his sister Judy (Ellie Haddington) who must sort out the small inheritance left by Stuart's will-less death, Judy's husband Dan (Bill Nighy) who tries to make sense of it all while facing temptations of his own, and a crew of odd blokes that weave in and out of the picture like super scene decor. The ultimate point is how to assign the small amount of money from Stuart's 'estate' and the way that happens ties the story together.

At times confusing in format presentation (we are never wholly certain the exact identity of anyone - it all depends on the current perspective!) - this little film is so beautifully acted and directed and written that what we are left with is a thoroughly entertaining and informative story that addresses many social issues with out being preachy. It is a film about loss, death, the financial sequelae of passing, and the ultimate importance of knowing how to live with fellow human beings. I would imagine that after repeated viewings the techniques of telling this wonderful little story would only make this film grow in stature. A small movie to treasure. Grady Harp, December 2004

I can only imagine that the sleeve design of this DVD was hoping to grab the attention of Red Shoe Diary, or Hunger viewers, when the film itself couldn't be further from that genre. A very clever piece of film making though it is, as we see three separate stories revolving around a funeral that happens at the beginning of the movie. Unlike ordinary flashback style pictures however, this shows the same story over from three completely different angles, keeping the viewer absorbed, whilst peripherally catching parts of the other two stories played out behind the one being watched. This is a story about ordinary people in a small community united in the loss of a friend, and in an almost "Wonderful Life" homage, the ramifications of that loss, and effect had on all who came into contact with him. A quiet Isle of Man (small island off west coast of England for those unsure)community where most people know everything about each other anyway, adds to the flavor of the story, and although you could hardly call this movie, action packed, sexually charged, or even gripping - it is strangely, and almost beautifully compelling. Each little cameo is well acted and very believable, and although it has a cast of little known or unknown actors, don't be put off. Not a movie to appeal to all tastes I'm sure, but highly enjoyable.

Good story from three perspectives. Relates to real life situations. Good choice for Bill Nighy fans.