14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting real life examples, but little more!, August 7, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Leap! A Revolution in Creative Business Strategy (Hardcover)
Trusting the positive comments of other reviewers I purchased Schmetterer's book. To start with a positive comment, the author digs deep into his great experience to share some very interesting real life stories with the reader; these stories earned him the 2 stars in my review. Other than that, the book turns out to be a big disappointment.
If you are already familiar with the concept of branding and brand management, many of the examples for Schmetterer's CBI concept sound extremely familiar and - from a conceptual point of view - not very innovative. Brand essence, brand experience and the like are - or should be - very familiar concepts for managers in almost any industry nowadays. Also, for people outside of the advertising industry it's not a big revelation that advertising alone doesn't constitute an integrated marketing concept and that marcom is only one part of a marketing strategy. Overall, in my opinion the CBI concept doesn't really add much to current marketing and/or strategic thinking.
In today's business environment, you can't blame an agency man for his attempt to expand his business beyond classical advertising into the fields of marketing and business strategy consulting. Also, you can't blame him for emphasizing the one asset that his industry can provide better than most others, namely creativity. However, as there is a difference between simple DATA and INFORMATION, there is also a difference between CREATIVITY in itself and true INNOVATION. What counts is not just the ability to come up with good ideas but the ability to turn these ideas into actual INNOVATIONS in the marketplace.
One reason why most advertising agencies to this day are NOT strategic business partners for their clients is because creativity is "only" a necessary, but not a sufficient condition for successful strategy development. And, unlike most agencies, managers, marketers, and strategy consultants are "in the business" of creating product, process, and strategy innovations and making them count in the marketplace. Being an expert for the creative execution of a communications strategy doesn't turn an account manager or copy writer into a business strategist.
You can only wish Schmetterer a lot of success in trying to familiarize his fellow ad industry professionals with the fact that marketing and business strategy require much more than developing an advertising campaign. So, if you work in advertising, get this book! If you work in marketing or consulting, don't expect more than some interesting real life stories.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Highly Recommended!, June 6, 2004
This review is from: Leap! A Revolution in Creative Business Strategy (Hardcover)
Every executive pays lip service to creativity, but truly unusual ideas are tough to find among the button-down set. When it comes to encouraging and developing groundbreaking ideas, most organizations are at a loss. Enter advertising exec Bob Schmetterer and his focus on creative business ideas. These strategies, such as Volvo's emphasis on safety, set a brand apart from its rivals. How do you get creative? It could be as simple as tearing out your office doors and walls, and hiring a few dyslexics. Schmetterer`s clear, crisp writing style, bold suggestions and liberal use of intriguing corporate case studies make this book a joy to read. We suggest it to any executive whose brand must cut through the clutter.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Could have been a great one, August 19, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Leap! A Revolution in Creative Business Strategy (Hardcover)
Apparently the juggernaut of Euro RSCG'ers have been rating Bob's book on Amazon. That is the only explanation I can find for so many stars.
For anyone who doesn't work for Bob, this book does not deserve more than an executive skimming.
And while you're at it, you might as well skip the parts about how top management need to encourage creative thinking, or being a renegade, or the need for trust and a good relationship for the client. And oh yeah, you get to hear a lot about what a great job Bob did for his clients. I mean really, didn't we read this stuff in Fast Company in 1998? And shouldn't a book about creative business ideas be a bit more creative?
I love creative ideas and look forward to the day that agencies step up to the plate and actually propose them to clients. Until then, if you're looking for a way to institutionalize creative ideas, I wouldn't recommend starting with Bob's book.
Perhaps a company-wide subscription to Fast Company...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No