6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Historic Edition, August 23, 2010
This review is from: Leaves of Grass, 1860: The 150th Anniversary Facsimile Edition (Iowa Whitman Series) (Paperback)
In 1860, when the United States was on the brink of civil war, Walt Whitman produced a book of poems that he hoped would provide a roadmap for preserving the Union. It was "Leaves of Grass," the third edition.
Reading Whitman is always an exhilarating experience but when reading from this facsimile edition put out by the University of Iowa Press, there's a touch of something else - a sense of history. The introduction by antebellum historian and Whitman scholar Jason Stacy does an excellent job of situating the collection within its historical framework, showing clearly the issues that Whitman was trying to address and how he proposed to do so.
One of Whitman's central ideas for preserving the Union was fervent brotherhood as portrayed in "Calamus," a poem regarding love between men but which gains a deeper political meaning in the 1860 edition:
"States!
Were you looking to be held together by the lawyers?
By an agreement on a paper? Or by arms? . . .
There shall from me be a new friendship - It shall
be called after my name,
It shall circulate through the States, indifferent of
place . . .
Affection shall solve every one of the problems of
freedom,
Those who love each other shall be invincible,
They shall finally make America completely
victorious, in my name.
One from Massachusettes shall be comrade to a Missourian,
One from Main or Vermont, and a Carolinian and
an Orgonese, shall be friends triune, more precious
to each other than all the riches of the earth."
Stacy also points out that Whitman - who numbered the stanzas in the 1860 edition as if they were Bible verses - believed that a new humanistic religion would save the Union and he was establishing himself as its prophet: "I too, following many, and followed by many, inaugurate a Religion." In the same poem - "Proto-Leaf" - in which this poet-prophet sets the tone and purpose of the entire collection, he (nearly) sings:
"I will make a song for These States, that no one
State may under any circumstances be subjected
to another State.
And I will make a song that there shall be comity by
day and by night between all The States, and
between any two of them.
And I will make a song of the organic bargains of
These States - And a shrill song of curses on
him who would dissever the Union . . ."
The entire collection isn't all so explicitly focused on its times as are the quotes mentioned above but its poems - some reworked from the previous two editions and 146 new to the third (and unfortunately this is not itemized clearly in the introduction) -- were geared towards saving the Union, whether in a subtle or a direct way. And apart from the collection's mission (and it's occasionally strident poetry), some Whitman scholars believe that the third edition is the best: a general improvement over what came before and superior to those editions that followed.
Although the third "Leaves" was a critical success, 19th century America obviously didn't have the patience to listen to Whitman's song long enough to find its national salvation. But with the new facsimile edition, it is possible to hold in one's hands a collection of poems, exactly it appeared 150 years ago, written by a patriotic poet who believed in his ideas so fervently that he thought they could prevent a war.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Wonder To Behold, September 18, 2009
This review is from: Leaves of Grass, 1860: The 150th Anniversary Facsimile Edition (Iowa Whitman Series) (Paperback)
Referred to as "The New Bible" I prescribe to all who are
interested in the evolution of the written word, the human Spirit
and Walt Whitman to pore over this book, and, to see it, and read it
as it was created by the man himself - then decide if you too will become
a disciple.
I also recommend
Walt Whitman and the Civil War: America's Poet during the Lost Years of 1860-1862
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Whitman at his absolute peak, January 14, 2012
This review is from: Leaves of Grass, 1860: The 150th Anniversary Facsimile Edition (Iowa Whitman Series) (Paperback)
Between 1855 and 1860 Walt Whitman channeled his greatest work. How this mediocre journalist and sometime writer of short-stories and verse suddenly erupted with so many astonishingly original poems is one of those delicious mysteries. Some suppose he underwent a spiritual epiphany on a par with that of Rilke or Eckhart Tolle; others say that with the exception of his moving ode to Lincoln, "When lilacs last in the dooryard bloom'd" (1865), Whitman's greatest poems were already written and contained in this, his third edition of "Leaves." Nevertheless, he went on writing for another three decades, inserting lesser pieces and rearranging the order of his earlier poems, depriving them of their original context and diluting their overall effect.
In short, if you're looking to be zapped full-force by Whitman's big, friendly voice and inclusive, evolutionary vision, the 1860 edition is Whitman at the absolute peak of his powers. For those looking for an edition of "Leaves" that contains the very best of the 1860 edition plus the juiciest poems from his later years, I strongly recommend "Walt Whitman: Selected Poems 1855 - 1892," edited by Gary Schmidgall.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
