Most Helpful Customer Reviews
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Prodigious Amount of Research, February 4, 2007
This review is from: Lee Morgan: His Life, Music And Culture (Popular Music History) (Hardcover)
This to me, is a rather troubling book. I had very much looked forward to reading this since Lee Morgan was one of my favorite trumpet players. Particularly during his exciting days as a member of Art Blakey's Jazz Messengers. The author, a 30 year old college professor from England and contributor to The Wire magazine has obviously put a tremendous amount of effort into the project. He meticulously has footnoted every chapter. He conducted close to 40 personal interviews with people who knew the subject. He further cites a bibliography of sources that amounts to more than eleven pages. It is no secret that Lee Morgan was a Black African American. He was born in Philadelphia in 1938 and was shot to death at Slug's jazz club in NYC during February 1972. So his life history was probably not unique from other's of his race during that time frame. Except, of course, for his genius as a jazz star. My sense is that the author mentions Black or African American on virtually every page of the book. Frequently, multiple times. The book is every bit as much about the authors historical and sociological interpretations of race relations in the U.S. as it is about Lee Morgan's jazz career. Really, it seems to me to be very much an outsiders view that was much influenced by some of his material sources. While it's true that towards the end of his career Lee Morgan became involved with what could be called Black Nationalism. That certainly was not the central focus of his entire life. My purpose in buying this book was to learn more about Lee Morgan's musical life. Not to be bombarded page after page by the authors perceived political insights.It is my sense that most readers came to this book because of Lee Morgan's contributions to jazz. If readers are interested in Black politics there are multitudes of books on that topic. I am not upset that the author mentioned politics in this book. Because, as stated previously in this review, during the latter part of his career the subject did in fact become a political activist. The problem here is that the author emphasized the political content far out of real life proportion thruout the entire book. So, reluctantly,and in spite of much innovative research, it is my view that Lee Morgan deserved a biography more concentrated on his musical achievements than this work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
DenseLee, April 14, 2007
This review is from: Lee Morgan: His Life, Music And Culture (Popular Music History) (Hardcover)
This book left me a bit disturbed. There is very little of the Lee Morgan I got to know. I appreciated Tom Perchard's research in his attempt to find out what it was in Lee's background that made him the musician he was to become. However, his time would have been better spent trying to find out what was in the water they were drinking in Philadelphia that produced all those great musicians, Clifford Brown, Trane, Tyner, Timmons, the Heath brothers, Ray Bryant, Charlie Persip and Dizzy, or he could have attributed his talent to the famous "Jess Grew". The Lee Morgan I got to know was a fun loving young musician. When I saw him with Dizzy's big band(late 50s) at Sparrows beach in Md. That band had Quincy Jones, Wynton Kelly, Charlie Persip and Joe Gordon. When I arrived at the beach the first thing I saw was Lee and Persip running out of the water with inner tubes trying to get on the bandstand before Dizzy started to play. Several years later I was in a bar next to Birdland (60s) and Philly Joe Jones was telling Art Taylor that he had just saw Lee sitting on the curb without any shoes on so he went back in the house got his bedroom slippers and gave them to Lee. My next vivid experience with Lee(late 60s-until he died) came when as business manager for the Left Bank Jazz Society, we presented Lee in concert on Howard's campus. At that concert before a sold out auditorium Lee received a standing ovation before a single note was played. That concert was reviewed by the late Ralph Matthews in the Washington Afro-American and contains some the quotes about Lee that Perchard uses in his book. Booking Lee Morgan kept the LBJS afloat for about 3 years. His concerts always sold out thus providing us with seed money to book other artists. I once offered to increase his fee for future shows but he said, "everything is cool as is, just keep the other bands coming". As a trumpeter player Lee had a lot of fire, and was a crowd pleaser. He was also a very good band leader who took care of the business side of things, was always on time for the shows made sure he got deposits before the gig and always had first class musicians performing with him. The tragedy of his death, like so many others of his era, was that he had gained all this life experience,good and bad, and musical knowledge at a very young age, had given a lot back to the music, and still had so much to share.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
perchard on morgan's life and music, January 28, 2007
This review is from: Lee Morgan: His Life, Music And Culture (Popular Music History) (Hardcover)
Perchard gives a detailed account of Lee Morgan's life and music in the context of the jazz scene in general from the fifties to seventies. Lee Morgan afficianodos will enjoy the descriptions of many of Lee's recordings although they may not always agree with the musical evaluation by Perchard. For example, not everyone would agree with the description of Morgan in "The Big Beat" of 1960 as raw, agressive, with an unkind sense of humour; it is not clear why this is discussed by Perchard as a development towards greater rawness AFTER the description of "Roots and Herbs", recorded in 1961, as a peak in accomplishments of the same five Jazz Messengers: Lee Morgan, Wayne Shorter, Bobby Timmons, Jimmiy Merritt, and Art Blakey. Be that as it may, someone who admires this type of jazz will be captivated by this book and go back listening to recordings to compare own notes with those of Perchard.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|