16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lenox v Riedel and Spiegelau, August 4, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Lenox Tuscany Classics Grand Burgundy, Set of 4 (Kitchen)
I imagine most shoppers will be considering crystal stemware from Spiegelau (the slightly less expensive Authentis collection) and Riedel (roughly half the price of the Vinums.) Having had the pleasure of sampling Burgundy -- Oregon Pinot Noir actually -- from all recently, I offer the following commentary on the Lenox stemware:
1.) In terms of wine-tasting, the glasses perform better than the comparably priced Spiegelaus, and (in my humble opinion) better than the more expensive Riedel Vinums. I believe this is mainly due to the shape of the lip on the Lenox glasses, which directs the Pinot Noir grape to the proper area of the mouth while allowing a generous aroma to protrude from the bowl. Riedel's Vinum Burgundy glasses do not offer the curved lip, although the very expensive Riedel Sommeliers do.
2.)Regarding general concerns and aesthetics, I have several comments. First, these glasses are much heavier than those of its competitors. I believe this is the result of the fact that they are crafted with full-lead crystal (vs. 5% for the Spiegelau and 24% for the Riedels), and the fact that they are larger, holding roughly 5 more ounces than the others. Keep in mind that those with petite hands and fingers may prefer the less heavy stemmware. Second, although heavier, the glasses are more durable due to the high-lead content in the crystal. The common complaint regarding the Spiegelaus concerns their breakability. (This is less of an issue with the Riedels due to the higher lead percentage.) Lastly, the sheer beauty of the curved-lipped Lenox glass is not to be overlooked.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No