101 of 104 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I hate to complain. However ..., February 6, 2010
This review is from: Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide: From the Silent Era Through 1965, Second Edition (Mass Market Paperback)
Back in 2005 when Leonard Maltin published the first edition of his "Classic Movie Guide", he noted in the foreward that it contained over 1,000 new reviews of pre-1960 films that had begun to show up on DVD and cable channels like Turner Classic Movies, Fox Movie Channel and (Encore) Westerns. He especially trumpeted the addition of many B Westerns, including the complete filmographies of Roy Rogers, Gene Autry, and Hopalong Cassidy. Sure enough, glancing through the book, I noticed that it was heavily weighted toward the "sagebrush sagas" of the 1930's and 1940's, while missing some key "A" titles from the same decades. But Mr. Maltin promised that this fledgling effort would be freshened and updated in five years time; accordingly, I simply took him at his word, was grateful for the first edition, and began eagerly awaiting 2010 and the arrival of the second edition.
Well, it's here. But unfortunately, it definitely was not worth the wait. Sure it covers over 1,500 more films than the first edition - but according to Mr. Maltin himself, over 1,200 of the so-called "new" entries are the result of films from 1961 through 1965 being transferred to this book from his annual "Movie Guide". Just over 300 of the reviews in this second edition are genuinely new material that was previously unavailable elsewhere. Divided into five years, that only comes out to 5 fresh reviews a month - which is only a problem because there are dozens and dozens of older films resurfacing on DVD, cable, and the new DVD-R "manufactured on demand" programs like the Warner Archives, the MGM / Amazon exclusives, and the newly announced Universal MOD series. At best, this second incarnation of Maltin's "Classic Movie Guide" isn't keeping up with the market.
Among the missing are such titles as "The Locked Door", Barbara Stanwyck's first talkie which has been rotating fairly frequently on TCM's schedule; "The Ruling Voice", a fascinating Warner's crime drama starring Walter Huston and Loretta Young; early films currently available from The Warner Archives such as "The Flying Fleet", "Let Us Be Gay", and "Son of the Gods"; "The Perfect Clue", one of many "lost" films now found and available on DVD from companies like Alpha Video ... the casualty list goes on and on. Of course, not every title can or should be included in a reasonably sized and priced volume like the "Classic Movie Guide". But still, one is left to wonder ... are more readers going to be looking for information about "A Ship Comes In", for which Louise Dresser was nominated for the first Best Actress Oscar, and is not included - or for "Hear Me Good", a 1957 turkey that is included?
The bottom line - if you have the "Classic Movie Guide", first edition, think twice before you "upgrade". If you don't have a copy of the original, then go ahead and pick up the 2010 version. It's obviously not perfect, but depite its flaws, it's still the best mass market single-volume guide to the classics that's currently available. I give it **1/2 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Little difference from his regular movie guide, January 19, 2011
This review is from: Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide: From the Silent Era Through 1965, Second Edition (Mass Market Paperback)
I've not yet found a review in this book that is different from his usual guide. I'm assuming it contains old movies that are not in the regular guide, but I haven't yet run across one. I would rather that Maltin publish a comprehensive two-volume set of the regular movie guide than to have a separate classic movie guide that has so many overlaps with his regular guide. My husband, who likes vintage movies, does not use this guide because every movie he's look up is in the regular guide.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
LEONARD MALTIN'S CLASSIC MOVIE GUIDE, September 23, 2010
This review is from: Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide: From the Silent Era Through 1965, Second Edition (Mass Market Paperback)
MR. MALTIN, ONCE AGAIN, HAS COMPILED THE BEST MOVIE GUIDE, IN THIS CASE, FROM THE SILENT ERA THROUGH 1965. WE REFER TO THIS GUIDE ALMOST DAILY GIVEN THAT WE DO WATCH TCM MOVIES QUITE OFTEN. I WOULD CERTAINLY RECOMMEND IT TO ANYONE.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No