30 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A tasty read, December 16, 1999
This review is from: Lessons in Excellence from Charlie Trotter (Hardcover)
What does a $100 per person, prix fixe', 7 course gourmet dinner have to do with your business? Everything, if you believe Paul Clarke.
For those who might not know, Charlie Trotter's is an award-winning restaurant located in Chicago. I haven't yet been able to save up the $300 needed to eat there, but, from what I hear, it's an experience you'll not soon forget.
Back to the book -- this is a tough call. I like it. I hate it. I can't make up my mind. And maybe that's because it's almost like reading three different books.
First, it's a semi-bio of Charlie Trotter: his restaurant, how he runs it, his marketing strategies, his continual quest for excellence, his ongoing mission to make the dining experience in his restaurant extraordinary.
Secondly, it's an examination of how you can apply the pursuit of excellence to your business. Both these aspects make it an interesting read.
Then there's this underlying, ongoing discussion of having employees 'buy in' to your vision for your business. Though Clarke emphasizes rewarding this loyalty, and Trotter does so, I can say from my own experience, it just ain't so!
I found myself talking back to Clarke as I read. My husband thought I was going gaga. But I was so angry!
Much of what Clarke says feels manipulative to me. When I was an employee I was an excellent employee. I was the one who came in early, stayed late, did whatever it took, asked for more responsibility -- in other words I played the game.
It seems as though all the suggestions favor the employer rather than the employee. And this is where I get bogged down. I'm torn.
As an employee, I was used & abused too many times by the companies I worked for. And I know I'm not the only one.
But, as a small business owner, I'd want my employees to act exactly as Clarke suggests. It feels wrong, although I can't put my finger on exactly why that is.
I suppose any book that elicits this kind of response must be read. That's my recommendation to you. If you hate the management advice, you'll love the discussions about food, wine, & the restaurant experience.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I strongly recommend this book -- it is excellent!, October 4, 2007
This review is from: Lessons in Excellence from Charlie Trotter (Hardcover)
As a management consultant to top companies world wide (Merrill Lynch, Microsoft, IBM, GE, Abbott, PepsiCo...) I read a minimum of 120 business books every year, and have since 1989. My personal library is nearly 3,000 volumes and I would put "Lessons in Excellence from Charlie Trotter" in my top 5 for books on understanding what it truly takes to build a superior business.
I agree with another reviewer that you will likely not find any ideas that are shockingly innovative, but what you will find is a clear and detailed description of the business philosophy that has allowed Charlie Trotter to create one of the most respected restaurants in the world. You will also see that the fundamental strategies that Charlie Trotter focuses on are absolutely 100% transferable to any business that is serious about achieving excellence in their industry.
I have recommended this book to my clients for years, I use Charlie Trotter as a case study in many of my workshops, I have applied the ideas in this book directly to one of my other companies (an advertising firm I own) with tremendous success, and I have dined at Charlie Trotter's restaurant to verify that they actually live the ideas in this book... and they do!
If you are genuinely serious about building a business that is passionate and disciplined in striving for excellence - this is a must read.
John Spence
www.johnspence.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
27 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Where are the Lessons?, March 30, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Lessons in Excellence from Charlie Trotter (Hardcover)
I found the book to be void of any new leadership "Lessons" and to be particularly skimpy on any real "Lessons from Charlie". Ok, so someone leads each guest to the restroom and checks to see that it's in order and his servers wear double-stick tape on their shoes. But other than those two specifics, there's just no Charlie Trotter flavor to the book. (And, I'd personally be totally uncomfortable having someone follow me to the ladies' room every chance I got up. Can't they straighten the room on someone else's time, not while I'm waiting to use it?)
The book talks about Trotter's passion, but fails to explain or illustrate his inspiration and execution. The book is dull, with no feeling for the fire that incents Trotter. I'd love to know how he goes about changing the menu every day. There has to be a process to his creativity, not just the outcome. But we're left with nothing.
For the first time in my life, I threw the book away. There was no one I could imagine who would be willing to waste the time I had on the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No