Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
12 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Don't let it go..., March 27, 2007
With his last two albums, Tim McGraw has been crafting the best music of his career. Gone is the "Indian Outlaw," the guy "likes it, loves it, and wants some more of it." Here is a McGraw who knows a good lyric when he hears it, who knows how to choose a song. He manages to make un-commercial material radio-ready, to take a song and make it his own.
On LET IT GO, he does it yet again. The album isn't quite as edgy as its two predecessors, but what it lacks in edginess, it makes up for in lyric and performance. One of McGraw's best qualities is his ability to take other artists' material and transform it into his own stuff; he does so here with Big Kenny's "Last Dollar," Lori McKenna's "I'm Workin'," Eddie Rabbit's "Suspicions," Anthony Smith's "Kristofferson" and "Shotgun Rider" (also co-written by Sherrie Austin and Jeffrey Steele), and the ever-reliable Warren Brothers' "Between the River and Me" and "Train #10" (the latter a co-write with McGraw).
There's not a song on here that lags too far behind...all of 'em (including the duet with Faith Hill, "I Need You") are high-caliber songs, performed wonderfully by McGraw and his band. However, if you want some highlites, I'd have to go with the stone-cold country of "Kristofferson" (an off-handed tribute song that, strangely, works) and "Shotgun Rider"; the exquisite "Whiskey and You;" the whimsical "Last Dollar"; and the revenge rocker "Between the River and Me" (McGraw's version is indeed noteworthy, but pales next to the original found on the Warren Brothers' WELL-DESERVED OBSCURITY album). Basically, it's hard to go wrong with this album, which may indeed be one of the best of McGraw's career. It's a thinking-man's commerical country album, bridging the gap between radio and alternative...and nobody does that better today than Tim McGraw.
|
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
DON'T BE FOOLED BY (EXTRA TRACKS), November 14, 2007
THIS CD IS NOT THE LATEST RELEASE OF "LET IT GO" CONTAINING THE SONG "IF YOU'RE READING THIS...".
THIS CD IS LISTED AS "LET IT GO (EXTRA TRACKS)", WHICH BY AMAZON DEFINITION MEANS, EXTRA TRACKS ARE BONUS SONGS NOT INCLUDED ON THE STANDARD CD RELEASE. IT IS A INCORRECT LISTING OF THE ITEM. IT IS THE STANDARD RELEASE VERSION.
I RATED IT A 1 STAR, BECAUSE I DID NOT GET THE VERSION LISTED THAT I WANTED, I.E. THE VERSION WITH (EXTRA TRACKS). A AMAZON ERROR, NOT TIM'S FAULT.
AS FAR AS TIM MC GRAW, HE'S ALWAYS A 5 STAR !!!
DON'T BE FOOLED, AS I WAS, REGARDING THE (EXTRA TRACKS VERSION).
|
|
|
14 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
GO GET LET IT GO, March 27, 2007
Tim McGraw didn't get to be a country superstar by having the best voice in Nashville. He did it by having the best ear in town. Every Tim McGraw CD has been marked by the impeccable selection of songs. And "Let Go" continues the family tradition. It's another collection of powerful songs including "Train No. 10," "Shotgun Rider," "Put Your Lovin' On Me" and "Comin' Home." These alone would be enough to make this CD a success but wouldn't earn it 5 Stars. For that you need a little bit more and different.
And Tim gives us the extra effort with a kids' chorus on "Last Dollar," a Metallica-like break on the brilliant "Between The River And Me" and by overturning our expectations of the usual duet with Mrs. McGraw by not giving us another syrupy love song but by choosing a meditation on the addictive nature of love, "I Need You" (I need you like a needle needs a vein) in which even Faith sings with a desperate gravitas we don't expect from her.
Now don't think my saying Tim doesn't have the best voice in Nashville means he isn't a masterful singer, able to comfortably handle anything from the uptempo cowboy songs to the agonizingly honest ballads like this CD's brilliant "Nothing To Die For." As his songs show more maturity so do his vocals. He is no longer just a singer but a first class interpreter. His vocals take these high quality songs and elevates them further. He has handled the jump from superstar to artist with complete success. His creative vision and ability to wonderfully convey it is a rarity in music, especially country music with its pretty boys in hats and Shania wannabes.
The new Tim McGraw CD is a complete success that doesn't let it go after the music stops. It stays with you and leaves you wanting more.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|