Amazon.com Review
While there may be many novels about teens who dream of becoming writers, this may be the only one to take readers deep into the writerly process. A tentative Liz sends an introductory letter to Julia, an editor in New York, after her English teacher connects the two. Liz never dreamed that Julia would have time to coach Liz on her writing (twisted stories based on life with eccentric, divorced parents), yet a dialogue develops. After each chapter Liz submits, Julia writes back in affirming prose. Liz may actually have what it takes to become a writer--if she can untangle the web that grows between her and her new editor. In the course of this correspondence, Barbara Ware Holmes chronicles a journey of hope, misunderstandings, dependence, and craft. Liz may have more to teach her editor than either of them realize.
From School Library Journal
Grade 6-8. In a series of personal letters, journal entries, and chapters from her autobiographical novel-in-progress, Liz Beach, an aspiring author, relates her relationships with her separated parents and with Julia Jones, an editor at a New York publishing house. Prompted by her English teacher to submit her creative writings to Julia, Liz receives an encouraging initial reply, and before long she and the editor are exchanging letters expressing mutual friendship. Julia urges Liz to send chapters of her novel, which depicts an acrimonious home life with dull, unsympathetic parents. As the teen communicates disappointments with her family, Julia's letters are unfailingly supportive and nurturing, even after the woman loses her elderly parents, then her job, and eventually suffers a nervous breakdown. Liz does begin to gain a measure of appreciation for her father, but the relationship between Liz and Julia is highly implausible and weakens the book, as does Liz's didactic transformation from self-absorbed aesthete to perceptive, caring young woman who, in the end, is not-too-ironically encouraging Julia to write as rehabilitation therapy.?Susan W. Hunter, Riverside Middle School, Springfield,
Copyright 1997 Reed Business Information, Inc.