14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Up-close glimpses of Marcel Proust, June 21, 2008
This review is from: Letters of Marcel Proust (Paperback)
This book was first published in 1949, the letters having been selected by Mina Curtiss from the editions then available. This means that she did not have access to Philip Kolb's 21-volume magisterial edition of the original French correspondence. Even so, for a newcomer (to Proust's correspondence, not to Proust in general) this book is a treasure trove. We have here a collection of 236 letters by Marcel Proust (as well as 2 by André Gide and 3 by Madame Straus addressed to M.P.), the first of which was written in 1885 or 1886 and the last in November 1922.
Ms. Curtiss has given us a translation that is more than decent. Her avowed goal was to use "a kind of English that it seemed to [her] Proust might have written, had he been bilingual". My only complaint is that here and there she left words or phrases in the original French, feeling that they were essentially untranslatable. This may be so, but for the English- (but not French-) speaker it interferes (given its frequency, not very seriously) with the understanding of some subtle points.
Furthermore, Ms. Curtiss has provided some very informative brief biographical notes on Proust's correspondents, given right before a new person appears as the addressee. These are accompanied by approximately 50 pages of notes, which offer further biographical facts, cross-referencing with "In Search of Lost Time", and some practical clarifications relating to the specific context of certain letters.
This edition also contains a useful index and a new introduction by Adam Gopnik which, though not mind-blowing, serves its purpose well.
Regarding Proust's contribution to this book (!): we see him corresponding with countless people, including family members, friends, and publishers. Among the topics that we see discussed are the Dreyfus affair, the Great War, as well as Proust's efforts toward getting "Swann's Way" published. I was also fascinated by Proust's attempts to summarize in a few (relatively short) paragraphs the content of the later volumes. The writing in these letters is in some senses different from that in the long novel, but, for all those who have already grown to love Proust's voice, it is wholly gratifying.
(Two corrections, one quite trivial, the other less so: a) the last page of the book is p. 564, not p. 462 like amazon says, and b) the book's title is "Letters of Marcel Proust", not "The Letters of Marcel Proust".)
Alexandros Gezerlis
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No