Customer Reviews

Liberty Heights

5 star:		(15)
4 star:		(14)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(3)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Writer/Director Barry Levinson was prompted to make Liberty Heights after he became infuriated over what he perceived to be an anti-Semitic comment made by Entertainment Weekly film critic Lisa Schwarzbaum in her review of Levinson's Sphere (he accuses her of unnecessarily emphasizing the Jewishness of Dustin Hoffman's character). All I can say after viewing this superb film is that I hope more film critics piss Mr. Levinson off, for his fourth foray into the Baltimore of his youth is richly nostalgic without being overly sentimental (which was Avalon's biggest flaw). The young cast, headed by newcomer Ben Foster and ex-The Thin Red Liner Adrien Brody, does a fine job of bringing to life Levinson's vivid characterizations of sensitive adolescents struggling to come to terms with the colliding social and ethnic spheres of America in the 1950's. Levinson does a commendable job of avoiding the stereotypes that plague many of the films about the youth of this era; for example, the young African American girl that Ben Kurtzman becomes attracted to (Sylvia, played by the beautiful and charming Rebekah Johnson) is not some uneducated inner-city slum girl, but rather the intelligent daughter of a respected and wealthy physician; also, the WASP trust-fund-baby princess that is the object of Van Kurtzman's lust (Dubbie, played very capably by model Carolyn Murphy) reveals herself to be tormented by familial troubles that push her to find relief in alcohol and promiscuity; and, most notably, Dubbie's WASP boyfriend Trey (Justin Chambers) avoids prejudicial bulliness and ends up befriending and looking out for Van rather than eschewing him for his Jewish background.

Occasionally, Liberty Heights falters when Levinson belabors the Jewish point, but this flaw is negligible in the light of the film's enormous strengths, not the least of which is expert cinematographer Chris Doyle's fluid, vibrant images (Doyle is Hong Kong maverick writer/director Wong Kar-Wai's longtime collaborator) and Andrea Morricone's moving and low-key score (very reminiscent of his father's emotionally resonant work). These highly talented artists come together to craft a film of quiet beauty and lasting poignancy.

"Liberty Heights" revolves around a Jewish middle class Baltimore family of the mid 1950's. The father (Joe Mantega) is a decent and honorable man who just happens to earn a living as a boss of an illegal gambling organization. He is not perceived as a criminal to his immediate community, but merely as a family bread winner doing the best he can. To hide his earnings from the IRS, the father also runs a unprofitable burlesque house. The acts are so tame by today's standards that they seem hysterically funny instead of lascivious. Many like myself born into a minority Catholic background will readily commiserate with the young son (Ben Foster) who is astonished to learn that few people in the world are Jewish. There is a warm and tender scene where the child unintentionally insults his gentile lady host for serving him white bread, luncheon meat, and milk. The boy is appalled by all the revolting "white stuff" on the table. The innocent child looks at the well meaning woman as some sort of weird human being. Later we observe him as a teenager tackling the mysteries of adolescent sexuality and interracial relations. He is forced to learn that racial prejudice is not limited to the outright cruel and uncivilized. The older brother (Adrien Brody) is already thrust into an adult world where being Jewish is an serious obstacle to full economic and social participation. His buddy even goes so far as to hide his Jewish heritage from a WASP female in order not to repel her. This incident is very uncomfortable to watch. The whole family undergoes a crisis when the father's betting operation has to make good on a bet that it doesn't have the money to cover. These characters are engaging and the audience cares about what happens to them. We may even get to love them.

This latest Barry Levinson quasi-bographical release failed at the box office. It was a well done film deserving of respect but perhaps made twenty years too late. Do I recommend this movie? The answer is yes. Levinson is offering us sufficient new material and themes to make it worth our while. Nonetheless, I suspect that the great film maker perhaps should think twice before returning again to his roots for creative inspiration. Levinson may have gone to this particular well one too many times. The subject matter is starting to exhaust even his most loyal admirers. Most of us have already seen the beautiful and thought provoking "Diner" and "Avalon." I dare say that "Liberty Heights" would have been financially successful only if Jews were still victims of virulent discrimination. Younger Jews fortunately ( or at least I hope this is the case!) can no longer identify with an era of almost fifty years ago when signs were posted on Baltimore area swimming polls denying admission to "Jews, Dogs, or Coloreds." Some anti-Semitism persists today in America, but it is rarely blatant. Most hostility usually results from the low self esteem of individuals possessing marginal power and influence. Ignoring history increases the chance of evil repeating itself. The overindulgence of focussing on past troubles, though, may deter us from confronting the challenges of the here and now.

Barry Levinson writes and directs a story about growing up Jewish in Baltimore, MD in the 1950's, a topic he knows a lot about being a native of that city born in 1942. As a period piece, this is outstanding. As a comedy/drama, it has its moments but is too scattered to have much impact. The story follows the lives of Nate Kurtzman (Joe Mantegna), and his two sons, Van (Adrian Brody) and Ben (Ben Foster) over the period of one year. Nate's subplot shows his life as a small-time racketeer. Van develops a crush on a wealthy gentile girl at a party, and spends much of the film pining after her. When he finally gets to know her better he finds that she is much different than he had imagined. Ben develops a crush on a black girl in his class and embarks on a friendship with her that flies in the face of the taboos of the times.

The entire film revolved around a single theme, i.e. how hard it was to grow up Jewish in the 1950's. Much of the material was amusing, some disturbing and some charming, but Levinson was so intent on relieving (or reliving) his angst that he kept wandering from the main storylines. If he had focused more on the relationship between Ben and Sylvia (Rebekah Johnson), it would have been a much stronger film.

As a period piece on the `50's, this is outstanding. The costumes and props were perfect and the entire film had a genuine 50's feeling to it. Levinson captured not only the images, but also the attitudes.

The ensemble cast was very solid. Joe Montegna is always terrific, especially when he is playing a crook. He is extremely believable in those roles and though he has tried to break out of the type, he keeps coming back because he does it so well. Ben Foster gave a wonderful performance played with a great deal of wit and sensitivity. He and Rebekah Johnson had excellent chemistry and made the forbidden relationship enchanting.

This film had potential, but Levinson' mission to expose injustice kept distracting him from the storyline and dissipated its overall effect. I rated it 6/10. Add a point if you are Jewish and another if you are nostalgic about the 1950's. Not bad, but it could have been much better.

The first time I watched this movie was on a whim and I didn't know what to expect from it. I quickly found myself becoming infatuated with the story line. Barry Levinson has created a masterpiece with this film that stars Joe Mategna, Ben Foster, Adrien Brody and Bebe Neuwirth who are theKurtzman family living in suburbian Baltimore, Maryland in a place called Liberty Heights in the year 1954. Along the way their experiences are chronicled as integration has just begun. I could go on and on, but you have got to see this movie for yourself. I guarantee that you will not be disappointed.

Who says they don't make nice, intimate films anymore? "Liberty Heights" is a movie that deserves a bigger audience than it eventually got. Barry Levinson has written a film with plenty of sweet moments--the mating dance between a Jewish boy and black girl, the sobering realization that the ideal girl isn't everything she seems to be, and the deep bond between family. Levinson elicits strong performances from Ben Foster, Adrien Brody, and the rest of the spirited cast. This is a film well worth renting (or buying eventually).

Why LIBERTY HEIGHTS didn't enjoy a bigger box office presence and success is only evidence that the tender little movies get buried by the blockbuster explosion epics. This incredibly adroit recapturing of the 1950's, with all the incipient class and race issues just below the headline level, helps us understand our own insecurites no matter which one of the numerous minority groups we each claim. This is a simple, wonderful film that addresses major issues in such an honest manner that we cannot help but grow from the experience. A feel good, keep-on- the-active-shelf-of-the-DVD-library treasure!

A lot of Americans---especially the younger generations---are breathtakingly ignorant of their own very recent history, and films like "Liberty Heights" are invaluable for reminding us that no, this country has never been a utopian paradise of freedom as current day simpletons (read: George W. Bush and all his right wing partisan prostitutes like Rush Limbaugh, etc.) would have us believe.

The idea is not to fixate on the past but to use it as a guidepost towards the future---the kind of racist and anti-semitic world that "Liberty Heights" portrays has abated on many fronts but is far from vanquished, and all this progress did not magically arise but was the fruit of the blood sweat and tears of many principled and brave individuals over the course of the last several decades. Many battles have been won but the war is not over by a long shot.

Aside from social history, Levinson's film is also stirring entertainment: he has assembled a very strong cast, with an excellent script and masterful camera direction. "Liberty Heights" does not have the grand epic sweep of "Avalon" but is deals more directly with racial and ethnic tensions in 1950s Baltimore without falling into the usual cliches and sensationalistic traps that such socially conscious films (see "Grand Canyon" or recent Spike Lee movies) often stoop to. This is no cheap Hollywood tear-jerker but an honest, balanced and very mature work---probably explains why it tanked at the box office.

I loved this movie, and I certainly didn't grow up in the 50's. Rather, I grew up in the late 80's-early 90's! I thought that the chemistry between the two main characters was great, and I loved how they were so... well... proper! (Unlike today's movies, where they would have had a baby by the end). It was funny and touching, and I ultimately I felt like I was there. I definently recommend it!

Liberty Heights was one of those movies that seemingly came and went and was forgotten before anyone really had a chance to see it. This isn't all that surprising considering the film didn't contain many things blowing up, didn't have any special effects to speak of, and lacked a big name star. It's a shame though, because this is really a hidden treasure. I wouldn't even know how to categorize this movie. I suppose "coming of age" film would be the most generic way. The plot centers around two Jewish brothers, one in high school, one a bit older, growing up in a predominantly Jewish neighborhood in the 1950s who come to the enlightened realization that 99% of the country is non-Jewish and some are even of a different race! Thankfully the film never gets preachy about this subject; the boys come to this discovery while avoiding the annoying cliches that "message" movies are too often filled with.

What I enjoyed so much about this film, besides the terrific performances by the mostly little known actors, was the quality of the writing. In most films centered around teenagers I have a difficult time suspending disbelief because the characters don't act like real teens would in the given situation. Not so with this film. The relationship between the main character, Ben, and his newfound black friend, Sylvia, progresses almost exactly as I imagine it would have in real life. And when the older brother, Van, comes to the discovery that just because we might idealize someone (in this case a beautiful, blond, WASP), it doesn't necessarily mean the idealized individual deserves the admiration, I had to smile, having had very similar experiences in my own dating life.

The only real flaw I can think of in "Liberty Heights" is a subplot regarding the boys father, and the trouble he gets into when a numbers scam he is running goes sour. It just seemed like one of those things they add into a movie to add more conflict. I thought the story of these two brothers was strong enough to carry the film, without having to throw in the somewhat convoluted subplot.

Otherwise, I highly recommend seeing this extremely underappreciated movie.

This is one of the sweetest films I have seen in quite some time. I was really touched by the gentleness of the story. Everytime I thought something bad would happen to the characters, it wouldn't. I was very disarmed by that and it helped remove me from myself and really drew me into this very loving portrait of growing up in Baltimore in the 50's.

Wonderful.