Customer Reviews

Library of Dust

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Because "Library of Dust" is unique in its subject matter and presentation, it defies comparison or categorization. In my experience people are either moved and fascinated by it or indifferent and I suspect that reflects their life experience and aesthetic.

I had been struggling to find out whether my distant relative was one of the unclaimed cremains at the Oregon State Hospital (hospital for the "insane" when my relative died there over 50 years ago) when we found this book. We found it to be a rare two dimensional representation of an emotionally charged, complicated historical era. How better could you communicate how embarrassingly insensitive and ineffective our closeting of inconvenient people was for so many years? This book is not accusatory or bitter; it is ethereal, hopeful and maybe just a little sad, but I do not find it in any way depressing. After "Library of Dust" began to have its impact, the state laws that restricted access by the public to information on what had happened to over 3,500 people were changed and I was then able to find out that my relative was indeed still there and both her cremains and limited (though complete) medical records (less than one page per year of institutional care) could be reclaimed by my family.

David Maisel revealed how these cremains had been hidden away and forgotten, like the people they had been, and yet, somehow these canisters and their contents became distinctly individual again and surprisingly beautiful in an eerie way. In the dark with no intervention from the living world, these lost souls evolved. What an amazing visual metaphor for the wonderfully idiosyncratic uniqueness in each of us--even after death. And the book is a stark reminder of society's responsibility to the more challenging members of our community.

The very size of this book, a bit over 17 by 13 inches, suggests that it has something momentous to show you, as indeed it does. Though slender and easy to cradle in your lap, it is a slab of a book that looks as if it might also rest comfortably on the lectern in a pulpit. Though light in the hand, with the weightlessness of pure spirit, it has a certain gravitas about it, like a text delivered on a stone tablet from a mountain top.

What the book contains, though, is not a text, but a sequence of photographs. The book came about as the result of a brief article that caught David Maisel's eye in 2005. It told of some copper canisters that had been discovered at an Oregon State psychiatric hospital after decades of storage in an underground vault where they had been water-damaged. Because Maisel had made aerial photographs of open-pit copper mines, whose tailings discolor in amazing ways the water into which they're dumped, he suspected that these canisters might be extraordinary objects to see. There were 3,500 of them, each containing the unclaimed remains of a patient who'd died at the hospital and been cremated between 1883, when the facility opened as The Oregon State Insane Asylum, and the 1970s. During his first visit to the room in which the canisters were now stored in neat rows on floor-to-ceiling shelving, a prison inmate on a clean-up detail stuck his head in the room and, letting out a low whistle, said softly, "the library of dust."

Like the pollution from the copper mines, these canisters fit a pattern in Maisel's career of photographing what he calls "things that aren't intended to be seen." He was moved by the poignancy of the fact that these objects represented people "who had been . . . abandoned by their families, written out of their families' own histories." One such inmate whose story came to light as a result of Maisel's photographs was Ada Winterburn, who was afflicted with "melancholy" when committed in 1911 and died at the asylum 40 years later. Inspired by Maisel's 2008 publication of his photographs, a distant cousin investigated Ada's fate and concluded that many like her were, the cousin said, "committed not because they were insane, but because they were inconvenient."

Nonetheless, Maisel himself is philosophical about the history his photographs document. The records of these patients and their fate had lain neglected for so many decades, he feels, "not through any malicious intent, but because we want to forget" such sad, lost lives. Maisel photographed the canisters in a kind of slow time befitting their own history. Placing each against black felt, he photographed them in window light with exposures taking as long as eight minutes. Partly as a result of the attention he called to the canisters, the state has made an effort to preserve them better by sealing each in a plastic bag and then placing it in a separate plastic box. While examining the new storage system, Maisel peeked into one box whose top was ajar and saw that drops of moisture had formed on the interior of the plastic bag, "fogging the surface slightly," he observed, "like the condensation of breath on a window."

In the late 70's I worked in a psychiatric hospital in Wales, UK, where there were still women who had been incarcerated for having illegitimate children in the 1930's. In the early 80's I worked in a hospital in Cheshire, UK, where nurses brought bags of cigarette stubs from home to give to patients as `rewards'. Chewing these dog ends was a popular means of ingestion. This was considered amusing.
I have often thought that the forgotten inmates of these hidden hells needed something like a Holocaust memorial. When I first saw one of the images from the `Library of Dust' in New Scientist, I instantly felt that David Maisel had a given us a huge contribution towards that.
Whatever the strange alchemy that corroded the canisters in this extraordinary way the outcome is hauntingly, strangely, beautiful. Some of them look like weather systems on strange planets or maps of ocean currents: they have a quality that I can only call soul.
As an art psychotherapist I work every day with the capacity of art making to express, contain, transform, and heal suffering and trauma. This individual healing power of art can sometimes work at a social and cultural level too. The Library of Dust helps us to face and remember the collective shame of `the bins', as they were appropriately nicknamed in the UK. The Russian poet Yevtushenko wrote that `That which has not been expressed/ Will be forgotten/That which has been forgotten/Will happen again'. This work, with all its eerie beauty, stands as art: but is also a step towards healing a deep shared cultural wound, and is a medicine against forgetfulness.
Last year, with David Maisel's help, I was privileged to show some of this work in the corridors of a Victorian mental hospital in England which still partly functions caring for patients, but is mainly an administrative headquarters for a mental health service. The hospital corridors seemed an ideal place to contemplate these images and they produced some strong reactions. Fascinatingly the most negative reactions were all from staff who felt that patients should be `protected' in some way from the hidden history of psychiatric treatment. Perhaps there was an element of shame to that. There was no who such response from people who were or had been patients themselves. Below are just two responses from the feedback book: one from an ex patient, and the other from a psychiatrist.
It was so moving. I was a patient in this hospital 6 years ago. It is about remembering the people who have been so sadly forgotten and abandoned. I cannot convey what I feel in words- but I found the exhibition intensely moving and evocative. In the silence of the corridors it spoke deeply to me.

Beautiful, quiet images, strangely affirming. Thank you for your patience and perception and showing `what gets left behind' in this institution.

Malcolm Learmonth
Insider Art
England

I am a reference librarian at a small liberal arts college. Captivated by the idea of this photo project when I heard Maisel interviewed on NPR, I immediately researched LIBRARIES OF DUST and ordered it. Like other Maisel works, this book reminds us that we all hold a sacred responsibility to honor that which gives us life. His respect for the those forgotten and abandoned humans whose ashes fill thousands of canisters at the Oregon State Mental Hospital provides a profoundly rich historical and spiritual context through which we can find the sublime in those whose lives were shut away from us.

Judged unworthy in life, their anonymous deaths command respect when seen through Maisel's lens. Thousands of voices and and tormented minds call to us through each compelling photograph; seeking belonging, love, compassion, relief from torment---yearning for understanding.

When I opened the book, an aching, overwhelming gratitude and awe filled me. I cried. I saw individual human souls manifested in azure, turquoise and malachite. Entire galaxies swirl in blue and white brilliance reminiscent of the Northern Lights; rivers and glaciers actively flow across a century of human time--offering an incredibly beautiful eternity. Some of the canisters so strongly resemble living tree bark that I found myself looking for a leafy branch.

If David Maisel's work here became music, every choir of every religion would sing it to the heavens. Every deity revered by any human would recognize what David Maisel shares with us. Any teacher could open this book and find a theme: chemistry, law, sociology, art, poetry, music, religion, love, psychology, literature, physics, and theatre. I want to see the play that some amazing writer will make from the combination of Maisel and Kesey. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest: (Great Books edition) (Penguin Great Books of the 20th Century)

"Among my concerns with Library of Dust are the crises of representation that derive from attempts to index or archive the evidence of trauma; the uncanny ability of objects to portray such trauma; and the revelatory possibilities inherent in images of such traumatic disturbances. While there are certainly physical and chemical explanations for the ways these canisters have transformed over time, the canisters also encourage us to consider what happens to our own bodies when we die, and to the souls that occupy them."

~ David Maisel

Of yet greater concern is the implications of faux-concern indicated by this melodramatic outpouring of verbiage incommensurate with the subject matter itself, an uncannily egocentric rant on anonymous canned corpses, a quintessentially post-modernist drama-queen rhetorical strategy that should have long since gone the way of dubstep. It is, we are ironically dismayed to learn, still "all about MOI!"....

- G1

David Maisel's work is very similar to the most famous photographers of the WPA in that his social concerns are interwoven with his artistic prowess. This book is simply astounding. A group of forgotten people in our society died, were cremated anonymously in the same building where they died, were housed in copper canisters, and assigned a number. A sad ending, yes? But the story continues! A flood in the basement inundates a number of the canisters, and they begin to grow and change. They fluoresce. They glow. Each one becomes as unique and colorful as the people whose remains they contain. It's truly amazing, beautiful, and deeply profound. This is a huge book, but you'll want a large space in your library to house it. Heartbreaking and joyous at once.

I ran across a mention of this book on one of the blogs I follow... Library of Dust by David Maisel. It's a *very* oversized coffee table book of photography focused on a peculiar topic: corroded copper cans of human remains. Of course, the back story is what makes the topic interesting, and the photography is eye-catching. Having said that, the writing is overly ethereal for my liking, and a few pictures of this sort go a long way.

These cans start their story in the late 1800's. The Oregon State Hospital was a mental asylum with a large number of inmates. Up until 1910, those who died and were not claimed were buried on the grounds of the institution. But expansion plans targeted the cemetery, and the bodies were dug up and cremated. These remains were stored in copper cans and housed in a basement area of the hospital until the practice stopped in the 1970s. Flooding in the basement drenched the forgotten cans, and the result was a kaleidoscope of color as the cans corroded. Maisel was given permission to photograph these cans, and Library of Dust is the result.

The pictures are beautiful and stunning, to be sure. But the layout of the book is strange. Most of the pages have a picture on one side, and a nearly blank page facing it. The only thing on that page is a minute number indicating the identification number assigned to the can. Given that the whole book is only 108 pages to begin with, losing 30 pages to massive white space is a bit much. On the pages devoted to narrative about the subject, the prose is heavy on the philosophy of life and death, the continued interaction with the remains with the containers, and so forth. For me personally, it all seemed to be over-the-top in drama and imagery, as if the writers were trying to instill some additional significance to the objects being photographed. I could have done without that.

As a library book, this was fine. But I'm not sure I would have been happy paying $80 for this based on the contents.

Disclosure:
Obtained From: Library
Payment: Borrowed