5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
remarkable biography, December 15, 2007
This review is from: The Life & Times William Shakespeare: 1564-1616 (Hardcover)
[this is a review in progress, to be continued and revised]
Here's a very impressively-researched and well-illustrated book (and given the high quality of illustrations, many in color, reasonably priced). She claims Shakespeare was a life-long secret Catholic. Others have claimed this before. Surely he was baptized as such and had family members and friends who evidently were still Catholic when that was illegal in England. But his book goes beyond that, claiming that Shakespeare studied in continental European colleges set up for English Catholics. She claims much else too. It may suggest caution that she claims to have discovered so much: who was the Dark Lady of the Sonnets (Southampton's wife), which four portraits are genuine (and others not), and even what disease she thinks he died of--and more! (Even if he had the disease, which I'm not qualified to evaluate, it does not necessarily follow that he died from it.) So one might think that's just too much to believe, and, perhaps, though I don't know this, she might want him to be a Catholic, to claim him. But all that said, and even if some of her claims are speculative, she offers pretty good evidence for some of these claims. Less persuasive speculations include what life situations gave rise to some of his writings--occasionally possiblilty but not necessity--and whether or not he wrote a sonnet copied on a painting that forms part of the "Dark Lady" identification; if his sonnet, it is not among his best.
It is at least quite plausible that Shakespeare had more education than grade school would have provided. And he could not have attended Oxford or Cambridge without taking an oath of loyalty to the Queen and the Church of England. Though perhaps one could argue that he was merely an avid reader, largely self-educated, I think his apparent education is one reason that so many theories have been proposed and enthusiastically promoted that really Francis Bacon or de Vere or Marlowe (with a supposedly faked death) or someone else really wrote Shakespeare. Years ago I read several of these alternate author scenarios and conspiracy theories, all of which I found, besides being contradictory, unpersuasive. Also, there's the relatively sparse documentation of his life--lesser authors contemporary with him left a bigger personal paper trail. For some reason--temperament or a need to hide his religion, or both?--he kept a low profile, especially considering that he was a writer and actor. When asked to write a poem honoring Queen Elizabeth, who persecuted Catholics, he declined. That last item is merely circumstantial evidence, but she piles up many such circumstances, and she gives a plausible chronology of his trips to Europe, even giving plausible names and photographs in the school registers that he might have used to prevent English spies from identifying him. At a minimum, she has reopened some old questions in an interesting way, and has provided at least some new relevant evidence. Even at that (tentative) minimum appraisal, that's remarkable, I think, especially when the subject has been investigated before as much as Shakespeare has. (A review of the earlier German edition by E. A. J. Honigmann and her energetic response to the review is available online.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
You Have to LOVE the Subject, June 1, 2011
This review is from: The Life & Times William Shakespeare: 1564-1616 (Hardcover)
First the good. There is a great deal of interesting material and illuminating illustrations in this book. I learned a great deal, especially about Shakespeare's formative years, that I never got as an English major in college -- even in the Shakespeare course.
The not-so-good is the presentation. This is one tough, ponderous read. It's as if she had to throw in every possible fact she had collected. The author wanders into every possible byway, to the point where the narrative thread vanishes under all the minutiae. This is a "castor oil" book; you read it because it's good for you, and it's just about as pleasurable.
This book is very easy to put down. I know; I put it down a lot. I also picked it up a lot because I love the subject. If I hadn't, I'd have let it stay on the shelf -- and if you don't love, really LOVE, the subject, that's what you'll do.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No