Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
A Light That Never Goes Out: The Enduring Saga of the Smiths Hardcover – December 4, 2012
See the Best Books of the Month
Want to know our Editors' picks for the best books of the month? Browse Best Books of the Month, featuring our favorite new books in more than a dozen categories.
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Q&A with Tony Fletcher
Q. How did the project come about?
A. For starters, I was a fan and a contemporary; I’m the same age as Johnny Marr, Mike Joyce, and Andy Rourke. (Morrissey is approximately five years older.) But primarily, it was because the only other biography on The Smiths had been published back in 1992. Somewhere between the benefit of two additional decades of hindsight, the public’s ongoing fascination for the group, and my own passion for their music, it seemed like time their tale was told. Or that I told the tale. Or both.
Q. You were granted more detailed interviews with more key players, and were loaned or provided access to more letters, company memos, and contracts than any previous author or journalist writing about The Smiths. Describe your experience.
A. I had come of age, as a teenage fanzine editor, alongside many of the key players at the group’s record company, Rough Trade. I’ve long known many of the musicians, producers, and businesspeople associated with The Smiths, on both sides of the Atlantic. I’d conducted Morrissey’s first television interview back in January 1984, and my old magazine (Jamming!) had developed a strong relationship with the band. All of these past experiences and ongoing connections helped open doors for me when it came time to research the book; many of these doors, I should note, had otherwise remained long closed to others.
Q. How/when did you first get into The Smiths?
A. As editor of Jamming! back in 1983, I was sent, if not personally delivered, the first single, “Hand in Glove,” by Scott Piering at Rough Trade, who later become one of the Smiths’ many managers. Word spread incredibly quickly on the group, and by the time I got to see them in concert, that September, they were already all over evening radio and it was obvious that they were going to be huge. I will be honest and say that it was only with the second single, “This Charming Man,” released in November 1983, that I was truly converted. It was absolutely magical—the first genuinely classic guitar-based pop rock anthem to have come out of Britain’s independent music scene—and from there, I was hooked. I saw them in concert every year, got every record, read every interview.
Q. What were some of the most important aspects for you to get across in your biography?
A. As with all my biographies, I really wanted to place my subjects in the context of their times. Nothing happens in a vacuum, least of all great pop music, however much the subjects themselves might wish to encourage such a notion! The Smiths were a product of post–World War II Irish immigration to Manchester, of Roman Catholic schooling, of inner-city slum clearance, of a rapidly declining industrial city that—not coincidentally—became one of the global capitals of punk rock, and then even more musically vibrant with the emergence of a post-punk independent music scene. I make no apology for setting out my stall, so to speak, on all of these cultural developments. I think it makes the story of The Smiths themselves that much easier to understand.
As a Brit who has lived in the States since 1987 (the year The Smiths broke up), I wanted to ensure that I place the band in American context as well. Almost everything written in books about The Smiths tends to start and end in Europe. Yet The Smiths were enormously popular in America—their two albums released in 1987 each sold 500,000 copies without a video or a live date—and it’s important to understand how and why that popularity came about. The increased popularity of college radio, the emergence of Anglophiliac “progressive commercial” stations, and the existence of an “alternative” dance floor all played their part, as did Morrissey’s ability to cross international boundaries, despite what some presumed to be parochial lyrics.
Finally, I wanted to make sure that this was a story about a band called The Smiths, not about a singer called Morrissey or the partnership between Morrissey and Marr. And as such, I was determined not to be drawn into the solo years and the ongoing acrimony, legal action, and lingering bitterness that seems to exist between certain band members. That side of the saga has been endlessly covered. I was determined that my particular narrative should end when the band ended.
Q. What surprised you most about the interview process? What was the most interesting conversation you had?
A. I was warned, early on in the process, that the breakup of The Smiths had caused so much still-existent tension among its major players that I would need to tread very carefully and diplomatically if I wanted to get my interviews. This turned out to be sage advice. I was not totally surprised, but certainly intrigued, by how many of my prospective interviewees checked in with Johnny Marr before talking to me. (By comparison, only two or three people told me that they would only talk with Morrissey’s permission.) Which leads to the most interesting conversation—without doubt, it was the extensive multiple interviews I conducted with Marr. We spoke for 18 hours across two days in Manchester, including an almost unbroken 12-hour interview on the second day, which ended, around midnight, with us taking a nostalgic drive past Morrissey’s old house, where Johnny had first knocked on the door back in 1982. (Even then, we continued the interview process with phone conversations and multiple e-mails.) Johnny was incredibly giving not only of his time but of his memories, his emotions, and his regrets—and the book would not possibly have been the same without his input.
Q. What are the biggest misconceptions people have about The Smiths?
A. That they were miserable. You only have to look at pictures of The Smiths: they were having such a wonderful time throughout most of their five-year arc. Morrissey certainly suffered from periods of depression, and his claims to celibacy, his admission to suicidal thoughts, and his determination to write, as he said in a print interview, “for people who wouldn’t normally go to concerts, watch television, buy records or listen to the radio,” rendered him utterly unique within the world of pop music. But he was also one of the funniest characters in the history of that pop music, as evidenced by any number of his interview quotes—and also by his lyrics, never more so in the frequently misinterpreted “Heaven Knows I’m Miserable Now.”
Amazon's editors selected this title as a Best Book of the Month in biography & memoir. See our current Editors' Picks.
Top Customer Reviews
This is over 600 pages long and I read it in about five days, like Guralnick's first book on Elvis Presley this work immediately goes to the top of popular music biographies. The research, the level of detail, the balanced comment and Mr Fletcher's straightforward storytelling skills have all combined to make a fine work.
The main thing that I like about the book is that the author has focused strongly on the backgrounds of the various characters, especially Morrissey and Marr, placing them in the context of their times. The book is very strong in providing an understanding of the Manchester music scene the various Smiths emerged from. The fact that Tony Fletcher is a contemporary gives additional depth. We have also a great deal of information on The Smiths creative process, the business side and the touring (I didn't realise that The Smiths were as big as they were in the United States and were on the brink of major breakthrough).
It's a pleasing book in that there is very little dirt to reveal, we are reading about young popular musicians doing the work of popular musicians. I'm not greatly interested in Hammer of the Gods type biographies. The only disappointing 'revelation' (and it isn't one really) is Morrissey's meanness and reluctance to pay people, he probably pips Rod Stewart as the meanest man in rock. Morrissey and Rodders in the same sentence! Well he only has himself to blame.
I am a big Smiths and Morrissey fan but I am not familiar with the minute details of their career so there may be errors, I doubt that the errors are major.Read more ›
The stuff I found most fascinating and illuminating were the bits about Moz's youthful writing exploits as a chapbook scribe, playwright (he sent a play to Tony Wilson of Factory Records, who unfortunately lost it), and small-time music journalist. Fletcher has had access to letters of Moz's that we may well never see (though I have read his books on James Dean and the New York Dolls, quite easily available on the net), and I can't be the only one who thinks a collection of Moz letters/early writings would be a great thing to read.
Apart from that, well, Fletcher (sometimes nearly too) comprehensively documents the band from start to bitter finish 'in a chippy.' Many details will be already well known to Smiths fans, but the biographer still manages to find a great many details for the casual reader and obsessive apostle (and I would not consider myself one of these people, just somebody who loved The Smiths and Moz as a teen 20+ years ago) to dig into. A great, fun, fascinating read, and definitely one to listen to all the albums as you read, the songs exploding louder than old still-potent bombs in your head.
The only reason for the four stars rather than five is because despite how much information is here there are some things the author alludes to that he then never elaborates on and I found that a little frustrating.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
As a big fan of The Smiths and being someone who has already read Morrissey’s autobiography, I was interested to see what insight someone outside of the band could give on The... Read morePublished 6 months ago by Soraya Nair
This book is full of just about everything you wanted to know about The Smiths, from beginning to end. Read morePublished 10 months ago by Zach Branson
A thoroughly researched and balanced account of the history of the Smiths (not to mention a fairly detailed history of Manchester). Read morePublished 10 months ago by Marc Schuster
Great book! The author, who has written several other biographies about figures in the music industry, does a really nice job of delving into the different personalities of the... Read morePublished 15 months ago by Mike N