9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
refreshingly original work, October 17, 2004
This review is from: Like We Care (Hardcover)
Seventeen year old Joel Karstan hopes to go to college on a baseball scholarship but he takes an unexpected time-out from playing when his jaw is broken when he is hit by a ball. After six weeks of having his jaw wired shut, the popular teen is hanging out at the Happy Snack convenience store when he realizes that the managers treats him and the other teens like garbage. With the help of his friend Todd Noland he organizes a boycott that grows bigger every day and finally attracts the attraction of television executive Annie McCullough.
She works for a rock Cable music station that makes gangsta rap seen like lullabies. She finds Kyle charismatic and believes he and his protest would play very well on her television station. Joel and his boycott grab the attention of teens across the nation who start boycotting stores that exploit teenagers as a demographic group. Todd and Joel's next project is getting their black history teacher elected to the white city council by getting the 18-23 age group to come out and vote. They prove that teenagers can make a difference.
Tom Matthews takes sacred cows and satirizes thing in a way that is simultaneously funny and sad. LIKE WE CARE is a story of two wise arse students who know how to play the system and make it work for them. Annie goes from executive flunky to detached observer to active participant. If teenagers ever truly organized they would have plenty of economic and political clout. This is a refreshingly original work that has a very special appeal to the younger crowd and anyone who remembers Wild in the Streets.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great discussion book, September 28, 2004
This review is from: Like We Care (Hardcover)
I don't know that I would have picked up this book on my own. A friend loaned me an advanced copy to read, and I was pleasantly surprised by several things. The best part of this book is the humor. I really enjoyed the clever turns of phrase and especially the parenthetical comments...laughed out loud every few pages! The second pleasant surprise is the depth with which Matthews explores this scenario. I was fascinated to learn about the marketing philosophy and techniques of the fictional network, which shamelessly and very aggressively stalks teens both to rake in their revenue and shape their views, at literally all costs.
While the political race tie-in was interesting, I found myself more drawn to the relationships and language of the young people, the garish, almost characatured behavior of the 'celebrities,' and the power of one person...or a small group...to make a huge difference.
The underdog aspect, with Todd and Ira sort of masterminding everything and getting their own brand of geek-revenge just has to be satisfying to anyone out there who wasn't the most popular in school!
Matthews's ability to let us hear what goes on in his characters' heads (truly remarkable; I could 'hear; their voices and inflections) and his shrewd representation of marketing on a national level are what make this book rich with questions and discussion opportunities. While the media prey on teen apathy, I don't think anyone would say the teens in this book are stupid. Like We Care is a study in revolution....just not the kind the network had in mind!
Today I'll buy my own copy so I can mark it up and talk about it with my book group!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
I care!, March 1, 2006
This review is from: Like We Care (Hardcover)
The premise of this book sounds simple: Tired of being tricked, two teenagers start an anti-consumerism revolution. The reality of the book is far more complicated and oddly deep.
It starts out simple: Josh, star athelete, minor rebel, all around "Mr. Popular" is beaned in the face by a fastball -- and, as a consequence, has his jaw wired shut for six weeks. Unable to speak -- or smoke -- he really starts to see the people he's hanging with. To really hear what kind of bull they're saying. This book has one of my favorite lines -- "maybe when you stop speaking, you really start to listen."
Temporarily on the fringes of the group he formerly lead, Josh winds up hanging out with elementary school buddy, Todd -- all around nice guy, school nerd, philosopher. It is Todd who points out to him all the money he's not spending on cigarettes (since he can't smoke with a wired jaw!) or soda or candy. It is Todd who notices -- and verbalizes -- how everyone, including them, is being tricked into buying more, bigger, more, more, more!
The "revolution" starts simply -- Josh refusing his cigarettes. Stepping away from the counter. Todd follows suit. Between the two, they carry this message to other teens in their neighborhood, and with the aid of an MTV-style TV network, R2Rev, the movement sweeps the country.
Personally, I thought this book was well-written. Most of the characters were believable, the continual threat of backsliding into consumarism absolutely credible. My only problem with the book was that it became so obsessed with it's grassroots message that sometimes the story got lost. Since it *is* a YA book, I suppose Tom Matthews reasoned he had to state the moral of the story clearly, instead of couching it in symbolism like many adult books. But once I surfaced back into the story, I enjoyed the book again.
There is only minor character development, believe it or not. Even Josh only undergoes the most minor of changes to his basic personality -- but that, in my mind, makes it all the more realistic. This is not a book with a fairy-tale ending. After all, these characters aren't just characters -- they're pieces of our own personality. The part of us that wants to fit in, the part of us that just wants stuff. The part of us that's tired and cynical and doesn't want to be tricked anymore. You know there's more to the story.... more happens after the final chapter. It's just up to us to figure out it out.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No