27 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
messy and biased, April 21, 2002
By A Customer
Derek Wilson's book is a messy summary of the familiar events and personalities of Henry VIII's reign. If you're not familiar with the main characters -- Sir Thomas More, Thomas Cromwell, Thomas Howard (Duke of Norfolk), Thomas Cranmer (Archbishop of Canterbury) and Thomas Wriothesely (Earl of Southampton), you'll get little more than a quick tour of their lives and accomplishments. There's little new here, and the research and scholarship are worryingly pedestrian: a quick glance at the footnotes shows that most of Wilson's primary quotes are cribbed from other secondary sources, and he uses biased contemporary sources by Protestant apologists like John Foxe with little or no warning as to their prejudices. Many questionable events and quotes are not footnoted. Moreover, Wilson's viewpoint is decidedly "progressive" -- he views the Reformation as the logical and necessary "freeing" of the English people from the "tyranny" of the Renaissance Catholic Church.
What's really shocking, however, is how bad the writing is. Wilson's book seems not to have been edited at all, and the awkward sentences run on with commas seemingly randomly interspersed. Together with a strange obsession with certain words that crop up with amazing frequency ("rumbustious," "scotched," "roistering"), an annoying habit to draw strained 20th century parallels (such as comparing pre-Reformation England with Eastern Europe of the 1980s), and an unfortunate tendency to pepper the text with inappropriate quotes from Shakespeare, Chaucer, and even Gershwin (?!), the style makes this book a most frustrating and disappointing read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Lost Focus, April 29, 2002
Derek Wilson needed an editor to remind him of his thesis: that life in the court of Henry VIII was dangerous for those who sought to share their sovereign's power and ambition. Much of the material in this book does not support that thesis, and the narrative that does support the thesis could have been summarized with far less detail.
Addtionally, I found the writing dull and the scholarship sloppy. I do not think that this book added to my knowledge of the Tudor era; I had hoped for new insights from the stated angle of the book, but found only repetition and redundancy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Different Perspectives, June 27, 2002
England's King Henry VIII has already been extensively discussed in various books as well as portrayed in a number of plays and films. Why another book? In his Introduction, Wilson acknowledges that much attention has been devoted to Henry's six wives (Three Catherines, two Annes, and a Jane) and shares this mnemonic:
"Divorced, beheaded, died,
Divorced, beheaded, survived."
and then observes: "I propose a different set of relationships which I believe offers a more illuminating approach to the court and government of Henry VIII. Specifically, Wilson focuses his primary attention on six Thomases: Wolsey, More, Cromwell, Howard, Wriothesley, and Cramner. "I can even suggest an alternative mortuary mnemonic, although one admittedly not so trippingly off the tongue.
Died, beheaded, beheaded,
Self-slaughtered, burned, survived."
Henry's VIII's relationships with all six serve as the basis of Wilson's narrative. There were lions in London at that time ("the King's Beasts") housed in the Tower menagerie and a major tourist attraction. More once compared the king's court to a lion pit "in which the magnificent and deadly king of beasts held sway."
Of the six, More interests me the most. One of my favorite plays and films is A Man for All Seasons. (In the film, More is brilliantly portrayed by Paul Scofield.) In both, Robert Bolt focuses on More's rectitude which threatens and infuriates Henry and eventually results in More's execution. Thus presented, More is a tragic but noble political victim and religious martyr, later canonized by the Roman Catholic Church. He is no less admirable as portrayed by Wilson but, in my opinion, is much more complicated than Bolt and others suggest. For years, More skillfully navigated his way through a court ("a lion pit") characterized by what Wilson refers to as its "seamy realities": "The royal entourage was a vicious, squirming world of competing ambitions and petty feuds, guilty secrets and salacious prudery,. Courtiers, vulnerable to threats and bribes, could be induced to perjure themselves, to exaggerate amorous incidents which were innocent in the context of stylised chivalric convention, to indulge personal vendettas....Over all these momentous happenings looms the larger-than-life figure of Henry VIII, powerful and capricious yet always an enigma."
In certain respects, this book reads as if it were a novel. It has a compelling narrative, dozens of unique characters, all manner of conflicts and intrigues which create great tension throughout, and a number of themes such as power, ambition, loyalty, betrayal, piety, terror, and (for most of the main characters) ignominious death. Wilson draws upon a wealth of primary sources to ensure the validity of his historical facts. However, some readers may question his interpretation of those facts. (A non-historian, I consider myself unqualified to do so.) Those who share my high regard for this book are urged to check out Alison Weir's Henry VIII as well as The Six Wives of Henry VIII, Karen Lindsey's Divorced, Beheaded, Survived, and David M. Loades's Henry VIII and His Queens.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No